May 23, 2026 · 52 min · 12 segments
This week Phil & Junko talk about what it means for Autonomous Vehicle to be safe enough. At a high level, in addition to net statistical safety, acceptable safety also requires an absence of risk…
Phil KoopmanHost
Junko YoshidaHost
And this actually relates to what I learned things like good enough, right? Engineers always worried about, you know, meeting the, you know, certain number and when is the good enough.

But safe enough actually is a concept that's, it's really related, but at the same time, it actually covers a broader area because we're not talking about just- improving one thing on robotaxi or you know autonomous vehicle in in general it's make it acceptable socially acceptable all right so let's start with the um your definition of safe enough and you know let's get to the heart of the matter when when people ask you right uh in a conference or the meeting so phil What is really safe enough for my robotaxis? How would you answer that?

Well, I've always said acceptable safety because people want to say anyone who wants safety for robotaxis is insisting on perfection.

But what's happened over the last few years is my understanding of what acceptable safety means has gotten better, has matured.

So let me start with the old definition, and then we can pick apart what's wrong with it, and then we can move to the new definition.

The original definition back in the Safe Enough book, which everything in there still applies, so it's not wrong, it's just turned out it's only half the story.

So the first half of the story is you want to be as safe as a human driver, to be really rigorous about it, no worse than a human driver.

And that is intuitively, who wants a robotaxi that's scary dangerous compared to a human driver? And OK, fine.

It sounds so easy, right? And you ask the questions about, well, what do you mean by which human driver? And say, OK, average car on an average road in the United States, something like that, right? And you say, well, hold on.

The average car in the U.S. is almost 13 years old now, and it doesn't have automatic emergency braking, and its airbags aren't as fancy, and it may not have stability control, and maybe it hasn't been maintained and all these other things, and maybe it has old, nasty tires, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, right? So an average car is not as safe as a new car.

Any new car is safer than an average car, whether it has a computer driver or not.

And this actually relates to what I learned things like good enough, right? Engineers always worried about, you know, meeting the, you know, certain number and when is the good enough.

But safe enough actually is a concept that's, it's really related, but at the same time, it actually covers a broader area because we're not talking about just- improving one thing on robotaxi or you know autonomous vehicle in in general it's make it acceptable socially acceptable all right so let's start with the um your definition of safe enough and you know let's get to the heart of the matter when when people ask you right uh in a conference or the meeting so phil What is really safe enough for my robotaxis? How would you answer that?

Well, I've always said acceptable safety because people want to say anyone who wants safety for robotaxis is insisting on perfection.

But what's happened over the last few years is my understanding of what acceptable safety means has gotten better, has matured.

So let me start with the old definition, and then we can pick apart what's wrong with it, and then we can move to the new definition.

The original definition back in the Safe Enough book, which everything in there still applies, so it's not wrong, it's just turned out it's only half the story.

So the first half of the story is you want to be as safe as a human driver, to be really rigorous about it, no worse than a human driver.

And that is intuitively, who wants a robotaxi that's scary dangerous compared to a human driver? And OK, fine.

It sounds so easy, right? And you ask the questions about, well, what do you mean by which human driver? And say, OK, average car on an average road in the United States, something like that, right? And you say, well, hold on.

The average car in the U.S. is almost 13 years old now, and it doesn't have automatic emergency braking, and its airbags aren't as fancy, and it may not have stability control, and maybe it hasn't been maintained and all these other things, and maybe it has old, nasty tires, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, right? So an average car is not as safe as a new car.

Any new car is safer than an average car, whether it has a computer driver or not.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.