Listener sentiment
Off Menu remains a beloved format with a devoted, engaged audience, though recent feedback reveals some friction points alongside enduring strengths. Listeners consistently praise Ed Gamble and James Acaster's natural chemistry and the show's ability to unlock personal stories and humor through food preferences, with standout guest episodes (Jeff Goldblum, John Kearns, Stephen Graham, Julian Clary) continuing to generate excitement. The newer Tasting Menu format has reinvigorated the show. However, ad volume has intensified as a frustration—multiple long-time fans report 4–10 minutes of pre-content advertising and cite it as a reason they've reduced or stopped listening despite enjoying the core content. Guest selection has also become more pointed: while comedy peers and naturally funny personalities thrive on the show, recent American celebrities on press tours are widely perceived as disengaged or low-chemistry, with listeners explicitly preferring episodes that contrast comedians with actors, musicians, and other non-comedy guests who bring surprising energy. A small minority object to Ed's wine tangents or the hosts occasionally interrupting guests, but the dominant sentiment remains warm and loyal.
Apple4.6 · 910
Summary generated Jun 14, 2026
