Listener sentiment
The fracturing documented over recent months shows no sign of healing: the newest ratings remain heavily negative, dominated by long-time listeners and former subscribers abandoning the show over its Gaza coverage — particularly the delayed, personal-framing treatment of the Ed Sheeran–Macklemore incident — with critics accusing Mia Freedman of pro-Israel bias, of centring her own feelings while the human toll goes unexamined, and of suppressing dissent in the show's Facebook community, while co-hosts Jessie Stephens and Holly Wainwright are faulted for not challenging her. A consistent loyal minority pushes back, praising those same episodes as measured and nuanced, warmly embracing new host Keeshia Pettit, and calling the criticism a coordinated pile-on. Beneath the political storm, the same structural complaints keep recurring: a perceived drift toward shallow celebrity, royal and social-media fodder at the expense of the substantive debate the show was known for, weak research and fact-checking, thin value in paid subscriber episodes, recurring playback glitches, Mia interrupting co-hosts, and lingering resentment over her son's appointment as CEO. Affection persists for Holly's humour, Amelia's dry wit and the hosts' easy chemistry, but the defining story remains a once-loyal audience losing editorial trust in a show it no longer recognises.
Apple3.2 · 811
Summary generated Nov 5, 2026
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/amelia-lester-Amelia-Lester-69dac3798b4e40df930f3844eb555464.jpg)
