Sep 18, 2026 · 19 min · 12 segments
A 25-year-old friendship hits a dead end over a broken SUV. She claims she bought a lemon that disappeared. He argues, he can’t be expected to refund a vehicle that drove right out of the dispute!…
Yodit TewoldePanelistRachel JuarezPanelist
Joe MartinGuest
Dan MentzerPanelistHortonGuest
Okay, Ms. Horton, Mr. Martin, today we are going to be doing a little bit of judging and a little bit of detective work, it sounds like.
So, Ms. Horton, you are suing Mr. Martin for $1,500 to recoup a deposit you paid towards purchasing an SUV from him.
What you say happened is the defendant ultimately agreed that he would remedy this situation, but then the car disappeared.
You assumed he took it back, and so you don't have the car, you don't have your $1,500, and so you'd like your $1,500 back.
Mr. Martin, you claim that you gave Ms. Horton a smoking deal on a car, and that when she told you it wasn't in good shape, you said, no problem.
So you claim that you don't have the vehicle either and you don't owe her anything.
Read the full transcript.
Create an account to read the whole episode, search across every transcript, and follow the shows you care about.
Okay, Ms. Horton, Mr. Martin, today we are going to be doing a little bit of judging and a little bit of detective work, it sounds like.
So, Ms. Horton, you are suing Mr. Martin for $1,500 to recoup a deposit you paid towards purchasing an SUV from him.
What you say happened is the defendant ultimately agreed that he would remedy this situation, but then the car disappeared.
You assumed he took it back, and so you don't have the car, you don't have your $1,500, and so you'd like your $1,500 back.
Mr. Martin, you claim that you gave Ms. Horton a smoking deal on a car, and that when she told you it wasn't in good shape, you said, no problem.
So you claim that you don't have the vehicle either and you don't owe her anything.
