Listener sentiment
Good Noticings remains sharply polarized well over a year into its rebrand from Celebrity Memoir Book Club, and the most recent ratings show no movement toward consensus. The dominant negative thread is nostalgia for the memoir format: longtime listeners describe the old show as a genuinely original concept that played to the hosts' strengths, and they find the current pop-culture-and-current-events structure generic, under-researched, and padded with long intros and half-baked takes. Recurring criticisms include factual errors in political and historical commentary, episodes that feel overlong relative to their substance, and Claire's dismissive on-air treatment of co-host Ashley, which multiple reviewers describe as uncomfortable or condescending enough to prompt them to stop listening. A loyal contingent continues to champion the rebrand, praising the hosts' sharp banter, humor, and willingness to take clear progressive stances on issues like transgender rights; some even prefer the new format for its broader cultural scope. A few recent reviews also surface frustration with the show's framing of the Israel-Palestine conflict and with ad reads that seem at odds with its stated politics, adding a layer of credibility critique to the usual format complaints. The divide has hardened rather than narrowed — the same themes have defined the show's reception since the pivot, and the newest ratings simply echo them.
Apple4.2 · 1,075
Summary generated Sep 13, 2026
