Listener sentiment
Recent listener sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with nearly every reviewer describing Ghosteas as a cozy, comforting listen that feels like hanging out at a sleepover with friends. Hosts Maci and Nadoly's sisterly chemistry is the most frequently cited strength — their banter, genuine reactions, and calming voices make even the scariest stories feel warm and approachable. Listeners also praise the depth of research behind historical and paranormal topics, the popular listener-submitted story segments, and the show's signature tea recommendations. Many fans discovered the podcast through YouTube or cross-promotions with other paranormal shows and report bingeing the entire backlog across platforms. The few criticisms are narrow: a couple of reviewers flag inconsistent audio levels that require frequent volume adjustment, and some would prefer less personal chatter before stories begin. One reviewer found the hosts' emotional reactions excessive, but this is an isolated view against an otherwise enthusiastic and loyal listener base that keeps asking for more episodes, guests, and themed content.
Apple4.9 · 63
Summary generated Aug 7, 2026
