Listener sentiment
Earth Ancients has built a deeply loyal audience over the years, and the majority of recent ratings remain enthusiastic — listeners praise host Cliff Dunning's guest selection, calling it a standout in the alternative-history space, and appreciate the show's willingness to explore fringe archaeological theories and challenge mainstream narratives. However, a consistent strain of criticism recurs across the review window: multiple reviewers independently flag Cliff's tendency to interrupt and talk over guests, his long rambling introductions, and pronunciation errors that undermine credibility. Political tangents and the host's personal commentary on topics outside ancient history have alienated a notable share of longtime listeners, particularly episodes touching on Elon Musk, COVID, and partisan themes. The most recent reviews suggest a possible shift in direction, with one former fan describing the show as having "lost its identity" by pivoting toward AI promotion, and another citing heavy ad load and declining content quality. The companion "Destiny" series remains divisive, with some listeners requesting it be published separately. Overall, the show retains a strong core of admirers who value its niche and guest roster, but recurring frustrations with hosting style, editorial focus, and ad intrusiveness temper the enthusiasm.
Apple3.9 · 398
Summary generated Jul 16, 2026
