Listener sentiment
Sentiment remains overwhelmingly positive and stable, continuing the pattern of the prior period: the overwhelming majority of recent reviewers call CreepTime their favorite true crime podcast, praising hosts Sylas and Stew's genuine friendship and banter, well-researched and respectful case coverage, and the show's mix of levity and gravity that many say carries them through commutes, workdays, and even hard personal moments. A notable trend in the newest reviews is listeners discovering the show through Sylas's guest appearances on the Heart Starts Pounding podcast and immediately subscribing — often to premium — suggesting that cross-promotion is actively driving new, highly engaged fans. Criticism stays a small minority and echoes familiar themes: a few reviewers find co-host Stew repetitive or feel her contributions lack substance, others flag occasional factual errors, uneven audio levels between the two hosts, a wish for episode descriptions and timestamps, and platform friction (premium perks favoring Spotify, guest-hosted episodes being skipped). One recent low rating objects to the show's ad sponsors. None of these signal a meaningful shift in overall sentiment, which remains strongly loyal and enthusiastic.
Apple4.6 · 491
Summary generated Oct 20, 2026
