Bentham's Newsletter — Unofficial AI Narration
Oct 31, 2026 · 13 min · 7 segments
Why I disagree with Ellen Burns Unofficial AI narration of "“AIs Without Minds” Without Convincing Arguments", a free public post by Bentham's Bulldog published in Bentham's Newsletter on October 31…
Ellen Burns, PhD is confident enough that AI isn't conscious that her blog is titled AIs Without Minds.
My view in contrast is that we don't know whether AIs have minds and should have a good deal of uncertainty about it.
I plan to write a long piece laying out my reasoning, but in short.
I think biological naturalism is likely false and consciousness arises when the right functions are performed.
On many leading theories, it's at least reasonably plausible that the LLMs of today are conscious, and likely that the LLMs of the future will be.
I think the sophisticated behavior of LLMs should raise our credence that they're conscious.
Just as we'd be pretty sure that smart aliens who solve Millennium Prize problems are conscious, even if they had silicon brains, we should similarly think it's within the realm of plausibility that AI is conscious.
I think we should have a lot of uncertainty about what conditions are needed for consciousness.
Given LLMs' sophisticated behavior, this makes it reasonably likely that they're conscious.
For this reason, I decided to read Byrne's blog to see if there are any convincing arguments for AI unconsciousness.
I did not find any of the arguments convincing and found it worth explaining why.
I admit that I have not read every essay on her blog, so it is possible that there are some arguments that I've missed.
Ellen Burns, PhD is confident enough that AI isn't conscious that her blog is titled AIs Without Minds.
My view in contrast is that we don't know whether AIs have minds and should have a good deal of uncertainty about it.
I plan to write a long piece laying out my reasoning, but in short.
I think biological naturalism is likely false and consciousness arises when the right functions are performed.
On many leading theories, it's at least reasonably plausible that the LLMs of today are conscious, and likely that the LLMs of the future will be.
I think the sophisticated behavior of LLMs should raise our credence that they're conscious.
Just as we'd be pretty sure that smart aliens who solve Millennium Prize problems are conscious, even if they had silicon brains, we should similarly think it's within the realm of plausibility that AI is conscious.
I think we should have a lot of uncertainty about what conditions are needed for consciousness.
Given LLMs' sophisticated behavior, this makes it reasonably likely that they're conscious.
For this reason, I decided to read Byrne's blog to see if there are any convincing arguments for AI unconsciousness.
I did not find any of the arguments convincing and found it worth explaining why.
I admit that I have not read every essay on her blog, so it is possible that there are some arguments that I've missed.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.