Listener sentiment
An Old Timey Podcast is overwhelmingly praised by listeners for the hosts' infectious chemistry, witty banter, and skillful storytelling that makes history feel urgent and emotionally resonant. Reviewers consistently note learning facts they should have picked up in school, but delivered with genuine humor and surprising depth—ranging from the tragic to the absurd across topics from the Donner Party to JC Penney. The show draws strong crossover appeal from fans of the hosts' prior work (Kristin's true-crime podcast *Let's Go to Court* and Norm's YouTube series *Gaming Historian*), many of whom were skeptical about a history pivot but have since become devoted listeners. A vocal minority, however, objects to political commentary woven throughout episodes, characterizing it as one-sided and jarring given Norm's prior commitment to political neutrality on *Gaming Historian*. Some also find Kristin's delivery—her interruptions, off-topic tangents, and theatrical reactions—grating rather than charming, though these complaints are far outweighed by listeners who celebrate her as a comedic foil to Norm's measured presence.
Apple4.8 · 499
Summary generated May 29, 2026
