Listener sentiment
Listener enthusiasm for this episode-by-episode Smallville rewatch podcast is remarkably strong and consistent, with near-universal five-star ratings across a wide review window. Reviewers repeatedly praise host Zach Moore's deep knowledge of both the series and broader Superman lore, the rotating panel of guest co-hosts (frequent collaborator Lance Laster is a particular favorite), and the show's signature tally-board segment, which listeners find both entertaining and fun to track alongside their own rewatches. Many describe the listening experience as feeling like chatting with friends, and a notable portion discovered the podcast through its crossover with Talkville, the companion show hosted by Smallville stars Michael Rosenbaum and Tom Welling. The few critical reviews center on two themes: a handful of listeners feel the hosts are overly nit-picky or negative toward certain episodes despite professing love for the show, and some first-time Smallville viewers find the frequent spoilers for later seasons frustrating, though most acknowledge that's inherent to a retrospective format. Overall, the podcast is regarded as the definitive Smallville companion podcast, with listeners appreciating its blend of behind-the-scenes trivia, genuine banter, and an expanding universe of sister shows covering the wider DC and superhero television landscape.
Apple4.9 · 134
Summary generated Jul 22, 2026
