Oct 19, 2026 · 44 min · 11 segments
We customize nearly everything in our lives. So why does K-12 education still look like one-size-fits-all? With Alabama's CHOOSE Act going fully universal in January 2027, families are about to have…
Kerry McDonaldGuestStephanie SmithHostOne of the central concerns for conservative policy advocates, you know, has been and especially from the homeschool community, but but but really across the board has been the possibility of regulatory creep where government dollars actually bring in government control.
So if you would just speak a few minutes on your experience nationwide dealing with different states about whether or not that's an active fear and what we can do to combat that.

so glad you asked that, Stephanie, because it is a concern and we should always be vigilant about encroaching government overreach and regulation and push back when and if that occurs.

But The data sort of shows that or does show that these fears are unfounded.

If we look at the state of Connecticut, which had some of the freest homeschooling laws in the country.

Up until recently, they just became the first state in 50 years to roll back homeschooling freedoms and now require some notification to the state in Connecticut.

And similarly, if we look at other states where there have been targeted threats of regulation toward homeschooling freedoms, it's states like Illinois and Maryland and New Jersey that also do not have any form of private school choice.

In contrast, if we look at the states that have robust school choice programs, I think about Wyoming, for example, that last year passed universal school choice and at the same time, within about a two-week period, also deregulated homeschooling to take away that sort of letter of intent or notice of intent to homeschool and now has become one of the easiest states to homeschool in.

And similarly, in New Hampshire, which has had a long track record of education choice policies, those policies last year went universal in New Hampshire.

And this year, New Hampshire also removed the kind of notice of intent to the government that had existed prior to also become now one of the easiest states in which to homeschool.

So the data show that while we always need to be concerned and vigilant, the data show that school choice programs can actually be a protectant of homeschooling freedoms and can actually lead to deregulation of homeschooling at the same time that we see the expansion of school choice.

And it's really not surprising, right? Because when you develop a culture within a state that supports parental choice in education, they will also often support the freedom to homeschool.

And that would become a part of the sort of banquet of education options available to families.
One of the central concerns for conservative policy advocates, you know, has been and especially from the homeschool community, but but but really across the board has been the possibility of regulatory creep where government dollars actually bring in government control.
So if you would just speak a few minutes on your experience nationwide dealing with different states about whether or not that's an active fear and what we can do to combat that.

so glad you asked that, Stephanie, because it is a concern and we should always be vigilant about encroaching government overreach and regulation and push back when and if that occurs.

But The data sort of shows that or does show that these fears are unfounded.

If we look at the state of Connecticut, which had some of the freest homeschooling laws in the country.

Up until recently, they just became the first state in 50 years to roll back homeschooling freedoms and now require some notification to the state in Connecticut.

And similarly, if we look at other states where there have been targeted threats of regulation toward homeschooling freedoms, it's states like Illinois and Maryland and New Jersey that also do not have any form of private school choice.

In contrast, if we look at the states that have robust school choice programs, I think about Wyoming, for example, that last year passed universal school choice and at the same time, within about a two-week period, also deregulated homeschooling to take away that sort of letter of intent or notice of intent to homeschool and now has become one of the easiest states to homeschool in.

And similarly, in New Hampshire, which has had a long track record of education choice policies, those policies last year went universal in New Hampshire.

And this year, New Hampshire also removed the kind of notice of intent to the government that had existed prior to also become now one of the easiest states in which to homeschool.

So the data show that while we always need to be concerned and vigilant, the data show that school choice programs can actually be a protectant of homeschooling freedoms and can actually lead to deregulation of homeschooling at the same time that we see the expansion of school choice.

And it's really not surprising, right? Because when you develop a culture within a state that supports parental choice in education, they will also often support the freedom to homeschool.

And that would become a part of the sort of banquet of education options available to families.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.