Skip to main content

Ask RayNew Trends Ads Appearances Podcasts API

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.

A Paranormal Chicks

A Paranormal Chicks

EP 446 - Lizzie Borden

Oct 5, 2026 · 1 hr 47 min · 15 segments

We're switching things up this week! Instead of our usual one true crime and one paranormal story, we're going all in on one of the most infamous cases in American history: Lizzie Borden. Kerri takes…

We're switching things up this week! Instead of our usual one true crime and one paranormal story, we're going all in on one of the most infamous cases in American history: Lizzie Borden. Kerri takes us back to Fall River, Massachusetts, on a sweltering August morning in 1892, when Andrew and Abby Borden were found dead inside their own home. She walks us through the family tension, the strange behavior, the evidence (and the lack of it), and the trial that had the whole country picking sides. Donna picks up where the history leaves off. The Borden house is now a bed and breakfast where you can actually spend the night, and guests and staff have reported footsteps, voices, and some things that are a lot harder to explain. If you have any local true crime, local urban legend/lore, ghost stories.. we want them all!! We want to hear from YOU. Especially if you have any funny Ambien stories! Email us at aparanormalchicks@gmail.com Join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/theAPCpodcast Edited by Caden Baughman at Guestroom Studio https://www.gstrmstudio.com/ Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

We're switching things up this week! Instead of our usual one true crime and one paranormal story, we're going all in on one of the most infamous cases in American history: Lizzie Borden. Kerri takes…

Speakers: CarrieHostDonnaHost

Spotify Apple Podcasts YouTube Amazon Music Website

Top entities: Lizzie Borden House×86 Andrew Jackson Borden×27 Cornell University×10 Snapchat×3 Ryan Murphy×3

Show signals: SuitabilitySensitiveBiasNot politicalAudience≈2k followers

The Cornell Seven allegations1:37 – 16:00

C

CarrieHost

1:37

What?

D

DonnaHost

1:39

C

CarrieHost

1:40

Oh, fuck that shit.

D

DonnaHost

1:43

Exactly.

D

DonnaHost

1:44

We have to talk about it because even though we're not Jane Doe, we are Jane Does.

C

CarrieHost

1:49

Yeah.

D

DonnaHost

1:50

And I'm so sick of seeing people on TikTok and Facebook and all the other social media.

D

DonnaHost

1:57

That's really the only two [laughs] besides Instagram.

D

DonnaHost

2:00

But they are always like, "Don't put their names out, these boys.

D

DonnaHost

2:05

You know, you're gonna ruin their future.

D

DonnaHost

2:07

You're gonna ruin their future." Are you kidding me?

C

CarrieHost

2:11

Okay.

C

CarrieHost

2:11

Well, maybe they should have thought about that before they did what they did, allegedly.

D

DonnaHost

2:16

Allegedly, yeah.

D

DonnaHost

2:17

But I'm like, absolutely not.

D

DonnaHost

2:20

Ab- Ugh, God, I just cannot stand that.

D

DonnaHost

2:22

So if you don't know what we're talking about, so this is at Cornell University, which is, like, a prestigious university.

C

CarrieHost

2:31

Yeah, I feel like it's Ivy League.

C

CarrieHost

2:33

I don't know.

D

DonnaHost

2:33

Yeah.

C

CarrieHost

2:33

I don't know shit about shit, but-

D

DonnaHost

2:34

Me either

C

CarrieHost

2:34

...

C

CarrieHost

2:34

in my brain, it's Ivy League.

D

DonnaHost

2:36

I'm Donna, she's Carrie, and we're a pair of dumb hicks, okay?

Lizzie Borden HouseEntityBed & breakfast in Fall River, Massachusetts
99%86 mentions
Andrew Jackson BordenPersonLizzie Borden's father
96%27 mentions
Cornell UniversityCollege or UniversityPrivate university in Ithaca, New York
94%10 mentions
SnapchatSoftware Application
92%3 mentions
Ryan MurphyPersonAmerican television writer
89%3 mentions
TikTokSoftware ApplicationWebsite
87%5 mentions
ParanormalEntity
85%2 mentions
Abby Durfee GrayPersonAndrew Jackson Borden's wife
82%43 mentions
Sharon OttermanPerson
80%1 mention
VintedCompanyOnline marketplace company
77%13 mentions
Aileen Carol WuornosPersonAmerican serial killer
75%7 mentions
ShopifyCompanyE-commerce company
73%1 mention
FacebookSoftware ApplicationSocial networking service
70%1 mention
John Wayne GacyPersonAmerican serial killer
68%1 mention
PatreonCompanyCompany
65%2 mentions
MassachusettsAdministrative AreaUS state
63%3 mentions
Amy BruniPersonParanormal investigator and writer
61%1 mention
Ivy LeagueOrganizationConference
58%2 mentions
WhatsAppSoftware ApplicationWeb site
56%1 mention
Fall RiverCityCity in Massachusetts
54%2 mentions
United StatesCountryCountry in North America
51%2 mentions
ZolpidemEntityMedication
49%1 mention
InstagramSoftware ApplicationSocial networking service
46%1 mention
Chi PhiOrganizationCollege fraternity
44%1 mention
Law & Order: Special Victims UnitTV SeriesAmerican drama series
42%1 mention
The New York TimesPeriodicalNewspaper
39%1 mention
MississippiAdministrative AreaUS state
37%2 mentions
CisternEntity
35%2 mentions
Tempur-PedicCompanyPillow company
32%1 mention
Ed GeinPersonAmerican serial killer
30%2 mentions
The Boston GlobePeriodicalAmerican newspaper
27%1 mention
Edmund PearsonPerson
25%1 mention
Sarah PaulsonPersonAmerican actress
23%1 mention
WikipediaSoftware ApplicationSoftware
20%1 mention
GoogleCompanyTechnology corporation
18%1 mention
GollumEntityLord Of The Rings character
15%1 mention
EuropeContinentContinent
13%1 mention
Grey PouponBrand
11%1 mention
Freddy KruegerEntityFictional character
8%1 mention
CanadaCountryCountry in North America
6%1 mention
RedditSoftware ApplicationWebsite
4%1 mention
ChicagoBookMusical by Bob Fosse and Fred Ebb
1%1 mention

Society
Alleged Fraternity Sexual AssaultCrime > Sexual Assault
Cornell University Cornell Seven CaseCrime > Sexual Assault > Alleged Fraternity Sexual Assault
Consent and Victim-Blaming DiscourseCrime > Sexual Assault > Alleged Fraternity Sexual Assault > Cornell University Cornell Seven Case
Sexual Assault ReportingLaw > Civil Litigation
Cornell Jane Doe Civil LawsuitLaw > Civil Litigation > Sexual Assault Reporting
Historical Murder CasesHistory > United States History
Lizzie Borden Double-Murder CaseHistory > United States History > Historical Murder Cases
1892 Fall River Borden MurdersHistory > United States History > Historical Murder Cases > Lizzie Borden Double-Murder Case
True Crime TelevisionEntertainment > Television
Ryan Murphy Monster AnthologyEntertainment > Television > True Crime Television
Monster: The Lizzie Borden StoryEntertainment > Television > True Crime Television > Ryan Murphy Monster Anthology
Haunted TourismSociety > Paranormal Culture
Lizzie Borden House Ghost InvestigationsSociety > Paranormal Culture > Haunted Tourism
United States HistoryHistory
Civil LitigationLaw
Law
History
Entertainment
Crime
Paranormal CultureSociety
TelevisionEntertainment
Sexual AssaultCrime

The Cornell Seven allegations1:37 – 16:00

C

CarrieHost

1:37

What?

D

DonnaHost

1:39

C

CarrieHost

1:40

Oh, fuck that shit.

D

DonnaHost

1:43

Exactly.

D

DonnaHost

1:44

We have to talk about it because even though we're not Jane Doe, we are Jane Does.

C

CarrieHost

1:49

Yeah.

D

DonnaHost

1:50

And I'm so sick of seeing people on TikTok and Facebook and all the other social media.

D

DonnaHost

1:57

That's really the only two [laughs] besides Instagram.

D

DonnaHost

2:00

But they are always like, "Don't put their names out, these boys.

D

DonnaHost

2:05

You know, you're gonna ruin their future.

D

DonnaHost

2:07

You're gonna ruin their future." Are you kidding me?

C

CarrieHost

2:11

Okay.

C

CarrieHost

2:11

Well, maybe they should have thought about that before they did what they did, allegedly.

D

DonnaHost

2:16

Allegedly, yeah.

D

DonnaHost

2:17

But I'm like, absolutely not.

D

DonnaHost

2:20

Ab- Ugh, God, I just cannot stand that.

D

DonnaHost

2:22

So if you don't know what we're talking about, so this is at Cornell University, which is, like, a prestigious university.

C

CarrieHost

2:31

Yeah, I feel like it's Ivy League.

C

CarrieHost

2:33

I don't know.

D

DonnaHost

2:33

Yeah.

C

CarrieHost

2:33

I don't know shit about shit, but-

D

DonnaHost

2:34

Me either

C

CarrieHost

2:34

...

C

CarrieHost

2:34

in my brain, it's Ivy League.

D

DonnaHost

2:36

I'm Donna, she's Carrie, and we're a pair of dumb hicks, okay?

Sign up to see more

The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode

Create an account Already have an account? Log in

No account is needed to search Radar.