T
Tonya McCarter
2
APPEARANCES
1
PODCASTS
012
DEC 30
JAN 6
JAN 13
JAN 20
JAN 27
FEB 3
FEB 10
FEB 17
FEB 24
MAR 3
MAR 10
MAR 17
MAR 24
MAR 31
APR 7
APR 14
APR 21
APR 28
MAY 5
MAY 12
MAY 19
MAY 26
JUN 2
JUN 9
JUN 16
JUN 23
JUN 30
JUL 7
JUL 14
JUL 21
JUL 28
AUG 4
AUG 11
AUG 18
AUG 25
SEP 1
SEP 8
SEP 15
SEP 22
SEP 29
OCT 6
OCT 13
OCT 20
OCT 27
NOV 3
NOV 10
NOV 17
NOV 24
DEC 1
DEC 8
DEC 15
DEC 22
DEC 29
JAN 5
JAN 12
JAN 19
JAN 26
FEB 2
FEB 9
FEB 16
FEB 23
MAR 2
MAR 9
MAR 16
MAR 23
MAR 30
APR 6
APR 13
APR 20
APR 27
MAY 4
MAY 11
MAY 18
MAY 25
JUN 1
JUN 8
JUN 15
JUN 22
JUN 29
JUL 6
JUL 13
JUL 20
JUL 27
AUG 3
AUG 10
AUG 17
AUG 24
AUG 31
SEP 7
SEP 14
SEP 21
Feb 9, 2026
The Reckoning
T
23:23Tonya McCarterGUEST
So I called home, and I talked to Daryl, and he said, "Well, you're gonna have to make a plea." And I said, "No, I'm not gonna plea." He said, "Well, you don't have to plead that you're guilty." And I said, "I've told everybody how I feel about this." So we went back and forth on it, and he told me Steve said that I would choose to go to court.
T
23:52Tonya McCarterGUEST
And Campbell told him, "Well, if she goes to court, it'll be at least a year or two before she sees the inside of a courtroom." And I told Daryl, "I guess I won't be coming home 'cause I'm not gonna plead." By this time, I'm crying, and he said, "It's not fair to me and the kids.
C
24:20Cooper MollHOST
When Tonya hung up, she carried the weight of the decision back to her cell, her family, her health, the years slipping away, and for the first time, she let herself wonder whether innocence was something she had to prove.
T
24:35Tonya McCarterGUEST
roomAnd I was crying and praying and asking the Lord, "Please let me know what to do." And I ended up falling asleep crying, crying myself to sleep.
Tables, Turned
C
18:16Cooper MollHOST
The two stood four feet apart on a dark stretch of nowhere, and when Nash finally caught his breath...
T
18:23Tonya McCarterGUEST
He had the gun aimed at me, and he said, "I told you what I would do if you tried to get away." And at that point, I decided I had nothing to lose.
T
18:36Tonya McCarterGUEST
He was drunk, so I lunged, and when I lunged, knocked the gun out of his hand, and we struggled, and he managed to get to the gun, and he said, "If you ever do anything like that again, you're dead."
T
19:02Tonya McCarterGUEST
We were in a cab, and we were on a back road, and I told Nash, I said, "I'm gonna be sick." And so the cab driver stopped, and I got out of the car, and I walked back behind the cab about 15 feet to a ditch, and I pretended like I was being sick, and I moved down the ditch further away from the cab and acted like I was getting sick again.
T
19:33Tonya McCarterGUEST
And a truck came by, and I tried to flag down the truck, but the truck just passed me by, and then I just took off running.