
Tony Gerdeman
95
APPEARANCES
6
PODCASTS
036
DEC 30
JAN 6
JAN 13
JAN 20
JAN 27
FEB 3
FEB 10
FEB 17
FEB 24
MAR 3
MAR 10
MAR 17
MAR 24
MAR 31
APR 7
APR 14
APR 21
APR 28
MAY 5
MAY 12
MAY 19
MAY 26
JUN 2
JUN 9
JUN 16
JUN 23
JUN 30
JUL 7
JUL 14
JUL 21
JUL 28
AUG 4
AUG 11
AUG 18
AUG 25
SEP 1
SEP 8
SEP 15
SEP 22
SEP 29
OCT 6
OCT 13
OCT 20
OCT 27
NOV 3
NOV 10
NOV 17
NOV 24
DEC 1
DEC 8
DEC 15
DEC 22
DEC 29
JAN 5
JAN 12
JAN 19
JAN 26
FEB 2
FEB 9
FEB 16
FEB 23
MAR 2
MAR 9
MAR 16
MAR 23
MAR 30
APR 6
APR 13
APR 20
APR 27
MAY 4
MAY 11
MAY 18
MAY 25
JUN 1
JUN 8
JUN 15
JUN 22
JUN 29
JUL 6
JUL 13
JUL 20
JUL 27
AUG 3
AUG 10
AUG 17
AUG 24
AUG 31
SEP 7
SEP 14
SEP 21
SEP 28
OCT 5
OCT 12
OCT 19
OCT 26
NOV 2
NOV 9
NOV 16
Nov 16, 2026
BONUS: Juck on Bucks with Tony Gerdeman on the Ohio State Staff, Decision Making
23:22
23:37
23:44

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Well, and whether or not things need a massive overhaul in today's college football, things get a massive overhaul.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And thinking back to last year as well, 2025, there was nothing in the regular season schedule to expose them.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And this year, coming into this year, I said many times this could be a three-loss team that still makes the playoffs because of the schedule.
25 MINS LATER
Mistakes, confusing decisions and Ryan Day's staff decisions with Tony Gerdemen of Buckeye Insiders
25:02
25:09
25:17

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And thinking back to last year as well, 2025, there was nothing in the regular season schedule to expose them.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And, uh, you know, this year coming into this year, I said many times, this could be a three loss team that still makes the playoffs because of the schedule.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
So like when people want people fired and, uh, everybody's talking about the sky is falling.
29 MINS LATER
Who won't be back on Staff? Tony Gerdeman sets the over/under on staff changes
3:40
3:47
3:55

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And thinking back to last year as well, 2025, there was nothing in the regular season schedule to expose them.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And this year, coming into this year, I said many times this could be a three-loss team that still makes the playoffs because of the schedule.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
So, like, when people want people fired and everybody's talking about the sky is falling, if Ohio State wins out, they're where they could have been regardless if things had gone differently.
9 MINS LATER
Ohio State 28, Northwestern 19: 3 Things We Learned From An Uneven Win
2:32
2:39
2:49
2:58
10:37

Tom OrrHOST
But when Ohio State throws the football in Jeremiah Smith's general direction, good things do tend to happen.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
17 targets in this one, 11 catches, 117 yards, a touchdown, along with just 22 yards, but was a focal point of an offense that is struggling.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
So, hey, why not get the ball to them as much as they could? They threw them the ball a third of their plays in the first half.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
But while you've got an opportunity, why not do it? And we saw some catches from him.
8 MINS LATER

Tom OrrHOST
But if they hadn't done that, that gets talked about as the moment that the season was doomed.
Ohio State vs Northwestern Pregame: Can the Buckeyes Save Their Season?
10:11
10:17
10:28
10:45
14:05

Tom OrrHOST
Chip Kelly is going to stress even teams that are not so bad at this, and Ohio State has been not bad at that this year.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Well, and if you haven't watched Northwestern at all, they will flip their tackle and go unbalanced and put a tight end over it where the old tackle left, and they'll have just some unbalanced looks.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And so we've seen Ohio State when they've run up against the up-tempo Oregon and USC getting lined up late, still waiting to get a call in or get it communicated.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Because you can't be waiting for a call or a signal when that's happening, when things are moving to get it communicated.

Juck MilettiGUEST
Like, what else do you do at this point? So I think that there should be some personal drive there from him to get these guys together and get something going today, something positive to come out of this week feeling at least decent about special teams for the remainder of the year.
Oregon 41, Ohio State 28: 3 Things We Learned From A Total Collapse
3:29
4:18
10:05

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Yeah, but from I think like the three-minute – three minutes remaining mark in the first quarter until about the three minutes remaining mark in the third quarter no targets for jeremiah smith and i mean he's still on your team so you might want to just go at him and and i'm not talking about the behind the the blinder scrimmage stuff that has not worked the last few weeks yeah this is a situation where oregon wasn't overly concerned with like, well, we got to put two guys on him or whatever.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
You need to move him up in the progression and get him the ball or attempt to get him the ball, throw it up to him, whatever, because you need something that works and your best chance of doing something that works down the field is number four.
6 MINS LATER

Tom OrrHOST
It's like, well, you'd be crazy to run a fake punt here, and Tony, you're not going to believe it, but the guy who's known for doing crazy stuff did a crazy thing, and Ohio State seemed totally unprepared.
Ohio State vs. Oregon Pregame From Ohio Stadium
3:21
3:30
3:49

Tom OrrHOST
Boy, that feels like Jay Timmons might be one of the keys to making sure they go back to the previous version, the good version of the Ohio State defense.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
The interesting thing of those two big plays, 139 yards on those two plays, they went a total of about, I don't know, maybe 10 yards downfield when you take the minus 5 and the 15 or whatever from those throws.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
But with the Jay Timmons back, we saw last week, they went right at that nickel situation.
No Home Night Games For Ohio State: What Can The Buckeyes Do About It?
6:26
6:33
6:44
6:52

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Yeah, and we saw Texas and Oklahoma do this in the Big 12 and people didn't like it.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
The money now at this point and the things you're asking of Ohio State and I'd say others like it, but really it's mostly just Ohio State at this point in the Big Ten.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
There should be some sort of a perk, and yes, if you're going to be as reliant upon them, then they should be a little bit rewarded more for it.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Now, the Big Ten has always been one for all and all for one, and they would never do this.
5 MINS LATER
BONUS: Ohio State vs. USC Pregame LIVE Part 2
19:02
19:13
52:53

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And going after an in-state Tennessee running back, you know, there's a reason there's a connection there, and it just makes things much more difficult.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And Ohio State is this, a couple of defensive line classes they've got coming in, certainly not cheap at all.
34 MINS LATER

Juck MilettiGUEST
And when it comes to running the offense, I think it's very clear decisively that the trust that they have in Fahey shows us that the gap is pretty sizable.
BONUS: Ohio State vs. USC Pregame LIVE Part 1
3:27
3:32
3:37
4:12
4:17
18:21

Tom OrrHOST
So maybe that makes it more likely that you see more Philip Daniels than we're thinking.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And, and both could be playing well and you still get to you to rotate them just because.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
makes everybody better so the austin cerebell thing i'm also going to be very interested to see how aggressive these two defensive coordinators are because i i wrote um friday night that whoever blitzes the least will lose especially like the least aggressive defensive coordinator is going to lose this game because there's really I don't think there's much reason to not be aggressive in this one because we keep talking about what Wisconsin was able to do against Jaden Maiava and USC.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Now you've got an Ohio State offensive line that's going through some shuffling and a true freshman quarterback.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
If you just sit back and say, well, we can't let him beat us with his legs, you're an idiot.
14 MINS LATER

Tom OrrHOST
I think that's defensive line, this is quarterback, but I think the goal is kind of the same here.
How SEC Chaos Could Benefit The Buckeyes In The 2026 College Football Playoff Race
1:59
2:05
2:08
2:23
2:32
2:39

Tom OrrHOST
Everyone's going to pick up another loss or half the league is going to pick up another loss that wouldn't have been out there in previous years.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Yeah, and it's not just the bottom eight that are going to pick up the losses.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
It's going to be a mix of everything, especially what we've seen this year where you've had some unranked teams beating the number one ranked team or beating undefeateds or just coming up and biting some teams that you would think would be better than that.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Now through the more difficult schedules, the NIL and the transfers, it's really hard to stack and stock.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And you've seen quarterback injuries and how many teams have dealt with that this year and how many teams have been devastated by it and how many teams are still powering through.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Like Mississippi State with their quarterback injuries has been pretty devastating.
7 MINS LATER
S
9:37speaker_2ADVERTISER
like
INDIANA WEEK / Ohio State Buckeyes LIVE 391
7:01
7:12
12:15

Tony GerdemanGUEST
They, they rested guys who needed to rest, and y- you hope that they're ready to go against Indiana, and they didn't lose anybody via injury that, uh, necessarily they need this week.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
So yeah, it's, it's over and done with, and now to me the season finally begins.

Mark RogersHOST
The numbers look remarkable, but missing a lot of guys and maybe not quite on the same page with, uh, two elite receivers.
BONUS: Behind the Scenes - Covering An Ohio State Football Game
11:49
12:09
12:20

Tony GerdemanGUEST
All the teams that we finna play, we most likely gonna see one of them in the Big 10 Championship

Tom OrrHOST
The camera is already set up for Tony and I to go live, and we just have a couple things to finish.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Um, did you guys hear that? Did, did you guys, did anybody talk about it? Yeah.
Ohio State 45, Maryland 16: 3 Things We Learned From A Rainy Buckeyes Win
2:14
2:37
2:42
2:49
2:57

Tom OrrHOST
This is also one of those games where for the coaching staff and the players, I think you come out of this game and all you're focused on is the stuff that you didn't do right, the stuff you didn't do well, the stuff you need to improve because you know that that Indiana game is just six days away.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And the lack of discipline in the first half, seven penalties for 50 yards for the Buckeyes.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
They finished with eight for 65, that last one being a 15-yard penalty for Bo Atkinson late in the game.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
You made it most in the second half because I'm sure there was a chewing out at half about knocking off with penalties.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And one of those touchdown drives from Maryland in the first half completely led by Ohio State penalties, four penalties on that drive to get them down there.
BONUS: Juck's First Thoughts Following Ohio State's 45-16 Win Over Maryland
29:41
29:50
29:53

Tony GerdemanGUEST
This is, you almost had to treat this as the week before Texas where it's like, you can make your mistakes against all state and it's not going to come back to haunt you.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And so you can't, you can't just, you know, we can't do that stuff next week.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And, and you know, it's, it's, probably to the point that Nate Roberts basically said that, like, it's not bad to have something to learn from for them because they're going to hear about it this week.
Ohio State vs. Maryland: Pregame Show From Ohio Stadium
14:28
14:34
14:50
15:02

Tom OrrHOST
And if you're going one-on-one with Jeremiah Smith – you're going to get a bunch of 70-yard touchdowns in the first half.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Yeah, and Devin McEwen being, at this point, questionable, that creates an issue where I thought this would be a perfect game for him to just explode because of the attention on Jeremiah Smith.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
So can Maryland get to Julian Sane and – create some issues there, although Julian Sane was fine within that pressure.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And if Maryland wants to keep their safeties back, Julian Sane is completely, perfectly happy to take eight-yard completions and just move the chains, pick up a third and two or whatever.
BONUS: The Most Surprising Buckeyes of 2026
10:31
10:42
10:50
10:57
11:12
15:17

Tom OrrHOST
This Saturday against Ba- against Maryland I'm assuming you're going to see backup quarterback or backup quarterbacks, and I have almost no question that Luke Fahey's going to be the first guy off the bench.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And even in camp watching, y- he, he was able to move the ball and make plays and there'd be some, some nice throws.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And he's got a big arm and he's confident, and everybody saw him able to run the ball in the spring.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Like, there's, the only reason to put him out there first as the backup is if everybody knows he's the backup and you're okay with the repercussions of essentially having a freshman move ahead of somebody who's older.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Because we know once that happens, y- you've basically said everything that you need to say about the status of both players.

Tom OrrHOST
It's just d- what, what happens Monday to Friday that, that, you know, that then results in whether you see him or not on Saturday.
Ohio State Football: The Most Surprising Buckeyes Of 2026
6:32
6:38
7:48
7:54
11:13

Tom OrrHOST
And I have almost no question that Luke Fahey is going to be the first guy off the bench.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And even in camp watching, he was able to move the ball and make plays and there'd be some – some nice throws he's got a big arm he's confident and everybody saw him able to run the ball in the spring but i was with you with you like there's the only reason to put him out there first as the backup is if everybody knows he's the backup and you're okay with the repercussions of essentially having a freshman move ahead of somebody who's older because we know once that happens you've basically said everything that you need to say about the status of both players and so now you've got luke fahey who is you know is the backup and until we hear different then he's going to be the backup until we see different and again like i said i don't expect to see different because he's been getting backup reps and that's just the role that he has now so it's up to Tavian St. Clair to change that and we'll see how he responds to that.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And I know the, I guess the comp was, well, it's the CJ Donaldson role because that's what we know.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Cause we're not going to say, well, he's being brought in to play the quinch on Jenkins role because that's quinch on Jenkins.

Tom OrrHOST
It's just what happens Monday to Friday that then results in whether you see him or not on Saturday.
BONUS: Ohio State vs. Iowa: Pregame Show From Kinnick Stadium
1:36
1:44
4:31
4:52
4:59

Tom OrrHOST
For Ohio State, what's the key to getting to that magic number of 24 28 31 whatever it is more touchdowns and field

Tony GerdemanGUEST
goals i think that's it not settling that seems overly simplistic and yet it feels like it's also the answer more touchdown drives with this yeah you're gonna have maybe 10 possessions you can burn four of those into touchdowns you should be fine so it comes down to red zone explanation or maybe not getting to the red zone or just scoring before you get there but running being able to run the ball and do red zone but also i think continuing to target jeremiah in the red zone that's been something we've all been talking about for three years now don't take him off

Juck MilettiGUEST
The way it happened, I mean, that's like a – huge drain after that and they probably didn't get their bearings till wednesday and all of a sudden here comes a better team into their place they got home field advantage they're going to rely on that to build them up confidently but if ohio state can get off to a lead early in this one man they're booked

Tony GerdemanGUEST
They talk about wanting to keep going fast, keep the speed up, keep the pedal down.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And if you stay 14 points up the entire time, eventually that's going to be 21.
Friday Night Live: #5 Ohio State Buckeyes vs. #14 Iowa Hawkeyes Preview
3:11
3:42
3:48
42:50

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Yeah, and is seeing what works well how far you can go with the passing game as it is as sort of part of the running game but also getting out of the running game what you can and figuring out what is best they started out a bunch of zone and they have become more and more gap gap scheme and running those sorts of things and trying through all of this to find some explosion in the running game And the frustrating thing is I think they showed some in the first game.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
They showed a little bit in the second game, and they have not shown any since those two games.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And you shouldn't be regressing now that the schedule – you should not be regressing against Kent State and Illinois, especially what we've seen happen to Illinois' run defense.
39 MINS LATER

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Well, here's the thing about hat science and if you guys don't understand what hat science is good for you Hat science is a real thing that has been just destroyed by the administrators and the army games and all of that, where it's not about the kid and the kid's family putting out the hats and trying to fool you.
Ohio State Team Arrival In Iowa, Ryan Day Interview
6:54
7:13

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Ohio State will, they've picked up the tempo this year offensively, so I know i- in, in the last couple of years, Ryan Day has been, you know, "Let's just mosey on down the field." Now it's kind of been like, "Okay," Arthur Smith is like, "Let's get it in, g- get going.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Let's keep things on, um," you know, it's keep the defense on their heels, not knowing exactly when the snap is coming.
20 MINS LATER
Ohio State 42, Illinois 19: 3 Things We Learned From The Buckeyes' Win
6:01
6:18
6:25
9:01

Tom OrrHOST
And to me, a lot of that boils down to you got a couple pieces on the defensive line, but this is just not as good an Ohio State defensive line as we've seen in most of the last five to ten years.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And you're just looking at the entirety of the game where against Texas, like, boy, they collapsed in the fourth quarter.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
This one, Illinois had 119 yards in the first quarter, 102 in the second, 128 in the third, 113 in the fourth.

Tom OrrHOST
And that, I think, is my third takeaway is, boy, I think the running game for Ohio State might just be an is-what-it-is situation right now.
BONUS: Juck's Helmet Stickers and Initial Takeaways
35:59
36:06
36:42
S
35:59speaker_9ADVERTISER
man,

Tony GerdemanGUEST
you know, I mean, Chuck, you were, you, it sounded like you felt like he was maybe okay.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And based on what you saw afterwards, I just, I just saw him on the field right as it happened.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And if there's one week when you're not going to need a slot, you're playing in Iowa City next week.
BONUS: Ohio State vs. Illinois - Gameday Preview
17:45
17:49
17:57
18:06

Tony GerdemanGUEST
Because we saw him at times, he was the second tight end at times against Kent State.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
But the idea that they're going to look better because of Gabe VanSickle, I think they're going to look better because of Illinois.

Tony GerdemanGUEST
And then next week if Phillip Daniels is back and it's going to be Iowa, it's like, boy, they don't look nearly as good this week against...

Tony GerdemanGUEST
It's like, well, these are two very different defenses, so you've got to factor that in.
3 Things We Learned From Ohio State's 59-3 Win Over Kent State
1:45

Tom OrrHOST
One of the reasons I think it felt not particularly overwhelming was because the running game, which has been sort of a question for Ohio State all year, was once again good but not incredible.
5 MINS LATER
Scroll for more appearances