Skip to main content
Thomas F. Madden

Thomas F. Madden

American historian

Nov 2, 2026

55:40
Let's go back to Carthage and Hannibal.
55:43
OK. Carthage is itself a republic.
55:49
There are not a lot of republics in history, at least in pre-modern history.
55:56
It's a complex government.
56:00
The simple governments would be...
56:03
The ancient Greeks would talk about that a simple government is either rule by one, rule by a few, or rule by many.
56:11
So, in other words, it would be a monarchy, rule by one, an oligarchy ruled by a few, or a democracy ruled by many.

59 MINS LATER

115:37
What were some of those key...
5:13
So what are some major key circumstances that led to this whole fourth crusade? What happened in the first three crusades that brings us to about 1204? What's so important about the first three and how did they play out?
5:28
Sure.
5:29
The first crusade is called... by Pope Urban II in 1095.
5:37
And the original impetus is new Turkish invasions in Asia Minor.
5:43
The Seljuk Turks had conquered most of the Byzantine Empire, both after the Battle of Manzikert, but then also in the decades since then.
5:54
And the emperor in Constantinople, whose empire is pretty much gone by this point, really all he has left is Greece, He goes really to the only Christian powers that are left in the world, and that's Western Europe, and asks the Pope to ask the knights of Western Europe to help them to take back these lands.
6:20
And so that's the initial impetus.

13 MINS LATER

19:17
It kind of starts taking things off course.
19:43
Talk a little bit more about Restoration England and how ultimately a Republican form of government wasn't going to fly there.
19:51
Yeah.
19:52
During the time of Cromwell, there were many, like John Milton, who believed that Cromwell, having toppled the monarchy, would usher in a republic.
20:04
And it was clear that that was not going to happen.
20:07
Now, if they had really thought about, particularly with the ancient precedent of Polybius, that when you get rid of the monarchy and you get rid of the Senate or the aristocratic element and all you have left, is the popular element, which is what happened after the death of Charles I, then almost always you get a tyrant.
20:30
And that's exactly what happens here.
20:32
Cromwell becomes in all but name the king.

38 MINS LATER

58:22
Dr. Madden, what other lessons did the framers learn from Adam's digestion of the ancient republics?
35:56
would you describe the reforms over the long history of of this republic when does it kind of reach
36:03
its peak form i would say certainly by 1300 it's reached the most mature form of the republic by that time all of the major components of the republic are there the the doge is there the great council is there and it's also there were reforms known as the sarata which essentially defined who could be in the Great Council.
36:28
The Great Council was the democratic component to the Venetian Republic.
36:34
And it was not elected directly by the people.
36:39
It was elected by its own members, really.
36:41
And these were all important, generally wealthy men who would then bring other generally wealthy men into it.
36:50
and by the 13th century it had become very closed and it was very hard to get into the great council but that doesn't work in a capitalist system because you have other people new families who are becoming very wealthy and they want in and so with the sarada what they did was they set up a basic system for people to be able to come in to the great council and be assured that you would be able to remain in the great council provided you didn't do something terrible, you know, you weren't guilty of treason or something of that sort.

12 MINS LATER

49:47
He reaches capitulation with them, but what eventually kind of tips him into saying, I'm done with Venice?
29:02
Dr. Madden, how would you describe the Roman Senate, especially to those of us for whom Senate means the upper house of divided government?
29:13
I mean, it was that, but the difference in the Roman case was that the Senate was not elected, not directly anyway, and it was also not a legislative body.
29:29
It did not create legislation, and its vote did not create the law the way that the US Senate does.
29:38
So it was purely a deliberative body.
29:42
Now, the way you became a senator, there were, depending on what period we're talking about, but in the earlier period, there were certain patrician families that were just afforded certain seats in the senate later in the republican history that was no longer the case but there were some people who just got into the senate simply because of their family and a senate seat was given to you not for a set term but it was for life so you could serve in in that body for the rest of your life Now, there would be regular, usually every 10 years, there would be examinations of all of the people in the Senate done by the censors.
30:27
And if someone had committed crimes or in some other way had brought dishonor to Rome, they could be removed from the Senate.
30:37
But otherwise, as long as you did things right, you would stay in for the rest of your life.

12 MINS LATER

42:26
When did the emperors enter the picture?
19:00
What are you talking
19:01
about? I'm getting this idea really from the earliest republics and from the earliest writers about republics, particularly Aristotle.
19:12
The earliest republic, I think the earliest long-term republic is Sparta, and the Spartans very much believed that their republic, one of the basic foundations of it was fear.
19:27
And in fact, they had a temple to fear in Sparta because they believed that their government relied on it.
19:36
Now the fear, In part, it's fear of punishment.
19:40
In other words, if you're not a good citizen and you don't pull your weight and do your part for the government, that you'll be punished.
19:49
But much more importantly was the fear of external enemies.

13 MINS LATER

32:37
What is notable about the Republic
2:19
Talk about that plan and what thwarted it.
2:23
Yes, that's right.
2:25
Now, here we're jumping up to the 16th century, but the great fear was that the new sultan of the Ottoman Empire, now I should say the Ottoman Empire, which grew out of the Turks in Asia Minor, they expanded into Europe and then ultimately in 1453, they conquered Constantinople.
2:50
Selim I, the Ottoman emperor, he comes in in 1512 and he is very, very successful at conquering more territory.
3:03
Now, by this point, the sultans of the Ottoman Empire are also calling themselves the caliphs of the faith.
3:12
So they're both military leaders and religious leaders.
3:17
And as sultans and caliphs, it falls to them, they see it as being the ones who are supposed to prosecute the jihad.

12 MINS LATER

15:09
Dr. Madden, what ever became of the Crusader states then?
2:49
Was the Fifth Crusade that we're going to discuss today, was it an attempt to kind of finish the business of the previous crusade?
3:00
Yeah, I think that's a good way to look at it.
3:02
It was certainly seen that way by Pope Innocent III.
3:09
Remember, Pope Innocent, when he had been elevated in eleven ninety-eight, his first action was to call a crusade to redeem Jerusalem.
3:19
And that crusade had gone so far off the rails, the Fourth Crusade, and spun completely out of his control, that it ended up conquering Constantinople.
3:32
Now, Innocent was willing to accept that, and in fact saw it as the healing of the schism, wrongly.
3:40
That's the way he saw it the, for the rest of his life.

29 MINS LATER

33:00
How did that circumstance there occasion the Crusades of St. Louis?
3:12
Let's pick up where we left off yesterday with Dr. Madden's answer to the question, to what degree did the failure of the Third Crusade to completely take Jerusalem, because Jerusalem, while it was open to pilgrims, remained in Muslim hands, to what degree did that make the Fourth Crusade inevitable?
3:30
Yeah, there was always going to be another crusade to try to take Jerusalem, because as I said, everything in the twelfth century and the thirteenth century was all about reform, reform of the church, reform of Christian society, and the crusade was seen as one element in that reform.
3:49
And so it was always going to be another crusade to try to take back Jerusalem as long as, as that mindset, uh, remained.
3:59
The Fourth Crusade really was rescued by some kinsmen of Richard.
4:09
It was at a knightly tournament when Thibaud of Champagne and some of his other kinsmen, these were powerful nobles, decided to take the cross and devote themselves to picking up what Richard was not able to do.
4:28
So the ghost of Richard was very much behind all of this.
4:32
And what they wanted to do was bring together a very large crusade force.

13 MINS LATER

17:56
And while it may have been a financial success for the crusaders ultimately, and then maybe even for Europe, it c- basically went completely off its mission.
1:52
Before we get into the details of the Third Crusade, we need to talk a bit about the rise of Saladin and then that pivotal event, the Battle of Hattin.
2:03
Okay, yeah.
2:04
Saladin had unified the Muslim world over the years leading up to the Battle of Hattin.
2:15
He was the sultan in Egypt, but he had waged war in Syria against his main rivals there, and he did it very much under the banner of jihad.
2:26
The idea was that disunity among the Muslims in the Near East was the reason why the Crusaders had been successful in the first place.
2:37
Like the Christians, the Muslims viewed their setbacks as punishment by God.
2:44
And so, in this case, he argued, and he wasn't the first one to make this argument, that the disunity and the warfare between Muslims had caused God to punish them with this kind of plague of Crusaders who had arrived.

26 MINS LATER

28:40
Dr. Madden, how did the Third Crusade proceed?
15:25
Dr. Madden, what are the set of biggest myths about the Crusades?
15:31
There's a lot of them.
15:32
I would say, and this kind of builds on what I was just talking about, that is that the Crusades were kind of a, this unprovoked attack against the Muslim world, a peaceful Muslim world, and that those, because of that attack, it energized the Muslim world and caused them to, to fight back.
15:56
The truth is really the opposite.
15:58
The, the Crusades were a very belated response to many centuries of Muslim conquests in which two-thirds of the old Christian world had already fallen to Muslim conquest.
16:15
So at some point, the Christian world, both as a faith and as a culture, either defended itself or was completely subsumed, and the Crusades were essentially that defense.
16:31
All of the Crusades, all of the major Crusades in the East were all called in response to some kind of Muslim attack, usually th- with the aim of rolling those back.

10 MINS LATER

27:07
Dr. Madden, what kind of phases or time periods did the Crusades occupy?
5:47
The Galileo affair proves this.
5:49
Yeah, poor Galileo.
5:52
I mean, Galileo was a great scientist, there's no doubt about it.
5:56
He definitely discovered important things.
5:59
The problem with Galileo was that he was also a bit of a jerk.
6:04
He was one of these kinds of people who became famous as a scientist, and then, and I'm sure we've never met anyone like this in our lifetime, but he started to think that he was science.
6:16
And that if you disagreed with him, you were just an imbecile.

11 MINS LATER

17:33
Okay.
1:50
[laughs]
1:50
Uh, actually, people knew that the world was round since the Ancient Greeks.
1:55
The, uh...
1:56
And in fact, the Ancient Greeks knew how, how big the world was.
2:00
Um, this was commonly known in the Middle Ages.
2:03
If you look at any map of the world from the Middle Ages, they're all round.
2:07
There's not a single one.

17 MINS LATER

speaker_5UNKNOWN
19:13
[laughs]
22:51
Mm-hmm
22:52
... from the Arabs, um, making it very difficult for, for Christians to be able to make pilgrimages to Jerusalem anymore.
23:00
Um, and in fact, the, the churches are all pretty much in ruins in Jerusalem already by this point, so Jerusalem's in pretty bad s-uh, circumstances, uh, w-even before the Turks arrive.
23:11
But when the Turks arrive, it becomes very bad.
23:15
The emperor in Constantinople is out of-- I mean, by this point, the Christian world has become not much more than Western Europe.
23:25
It's getting smaller and smaller, uh, and the emperor in Constantinople, Alexius Comnenus, he doesn't have any other options.
23:33
Um, w-who else to ask? The only Christian powers that exist are in Western Europe, so he swallows his pride, and he asks the pope for help.

29 MINS LATER

52:59
Can you, can you tell us about the Vow of the Cross?
24:49
Venice is soon strong enough to take almost sole responsibility for keeping the seas around them safe.
24:57
And once they start doing that, really the Adriatic is theirs.
25:01
In fact, they start referring to the Adriatic as the Sea of Venice.
25:06
And that means that if you're doing business somewhere, if you're a merchant and you pick up something in Alexandria and then you come into the Adriatic planning to stop at another Italian port, once Venice has firm control over the Adriatic, they require you to unload in Venice.
25:27
So you don't get a choice as to where you're going anymore.
25:30
You're told by the authorities that if you enter our sea, you're going to Venice.
25:35
Either that or pay the taxes, pay a Venetian tax on the goods that you have, then you can go wherever you want.

13 MINS LATER

38:48
And that is not the only Christian ritual to get the Venetian treatment.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.