Skip to main content
Simcha Rotman

Simcha Rotman

Israeli lawyer

Jun 9, 2026

speaker_1HOST
8:49
[bell rings] Reforming the way Israeli judges are appointed.
8:54
In most democratic countries that I know of, judges are appointed by the body politics of the state, parliaments, executive, combination of both.
9:03
I support the American way.
9:04
Most democratic countries work that way.
9:07
If you give so much power to courts, you should have at least the say of who gets in.
9:12
Otherwise, you have a runaway court, that the distance from the court to the public is huge.
9:17
We passed a compromise that is not as nearly as democratic as the American way, but it gives more power to the parliaments.

5 MINS LATER

speaker_1HOST
14:29
Which brings us to the fourth and final point, defining the scope of the attorney general's authority.
speaker_0HOST
27:44
But as time went by, and as the court made more and more rulings that directly challenged decisions by Bibi Netanyahu's government, Israeli politicians, particularly on the right, began speaking openly and loudly about the need for a sweeping judicial reform.
28:02
Judicial reform is about making Israel democratic again, because Israel started as a democratic country.
28:10
It's one of the few countries in the world, U.S. included, that are democratic in nature from the day of its beginning, from the first day.
28:21
Some would argue that the U.S. or other countries had democracy, but it wasn't perfect, that some parts of society did not have the voting rights, women, Afro-Americans, or others.
28:36
In Israel, from day one, everyone had a vote, women, men, Jews, Arabs, from day one, and even during the war.
29:41
Is the beginning and end of the aim to neutralize Hezbollah in Lebanon, or does it also include this aim annexing a large chunk of the south of the country?
29:52
Um, I don't think the, the aim is to annex, uh, parts of Lebanon, but I think is if Israel has a border that is not being safe, w- no one should expect his citizens to be under constant attack.
30:07
And that's the situation in northern Israel for many, many years.
30:11
It stopped for a few years, but it returned and, uh, Hezbollah was not using the time of peace and quiet in the north or in south Lebanon in order to promote, uh, the economy or in order to, uh, deal with agriculture or with political party, uh, actions.
30:32
Hezbollah was using the time, effort, and money.
30:36
By the way, a lot of the money comes also from-International drug, uh, uh, trafficking and human trafficking and all kind of terrorist operations from around the world.
30:47
He was using it to, to buy more missiles to be aimed at Israeli cities and citizens, and I th- I don't think any sovereign country, uh, should, uh, should accept this kind of a situation, um, threatening its, its citizens.
33:13
You can see people's objections, can't you?
Sarah Montague
Sarah MontagueCORRESPONDENT
22:39
Can I ask you, do you think it's justified for settlers to put pressure on-
22:44
I just want to, uh, give you, um, from, just from, from, from this Sunday.
22:49
Let's choose Sunday, okay? Um, near the entrance to Efrat, uh, the, the roads that you just passed, at 9:04 in the morning, stoning of a Jewish car because he's Jewish.
23:03
Um, um, 10 4, uh, 10:54, um, um, stabbing attempt against a Jew, 10:54.
23:12
I- we're talking only Sunday.
Sarah Montague
Sarah MontagueCORRESPONDENT
25:11
Mm-hmm.
25:12
Um, I know there is a pressuring of communities in London when new... a group of people arrive to a neighborhood, and then, and groups that used to live there move for different reasons.
25:23
It happens everywhere around the world.
16:45
Mm.
16:45
... to the, to the break.
16:47
Um, you mentioned what, uh, Netanyahu said.
16:51
Um, and if you see it as a goal, I understand why people might be worried because you explain it as if the goal of the war is to demolish the houses.
17:01
No.
17:02
If you hide, if you Hamas and you're hiding your terror tunnels, that, the tunnels that you are using to bombard Israeli communities and cities and towns, um, from, uh, to, where you hide your, the hostages you kidnap, where you, uh, troop re- uh, where you, where you train your troops, where every piece of land is being used by you to hide explosives.
17:29
Just last week, one ton of, of, an explosive in a, in a, in a, in a communi- in a, in a civil area, in a neighborhood in Gaza.
20:08
But when you, when you responded to her question about the children also being your enemies, I mean, what is the logical conclusion to that, if children in Gaza are considered, uh, enemies of Israel?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.