Skip to main content
Sam Lowe

Sam Lowe

Singer

Nov 3, 2026

6:34
Was that just a, was that a cock up or was that deliberate?
6:39
It's an interesting one because if you actually look at how different G7 members intervened in respect of Chinese vehicles.
6:44
So the Canadians, for example, initially imposed just a very high 100% tariff on battery electric vehicles and hybrids coming from China.
6:54
Whereas the EU in the first instance tried to approach its intervention in a very proper way.
7:01
way insofar as it conducted an anti-subsidy investigation in which it at least on paper demonstrated that different Chinese electric vehicle makers were benefiting from distorting state subsidies in the form of cheap batteries or cheap land and calibrated a tariff on that basis.
7:21
And yes, they chose not to do hybrids in that first instance.
7:24
So do I think It was sort of an oversight, perhaps, because it was instantly the obvious thing that would happen, which is if you are going to get tariffed on one model, why don't you design it slightly differently and avoid that tariff? But to your point about...

7 MINS LATER

15:03
Yeah.
9:18
Where does the IAA stand at present in terms of its passage through the EU's rather complicated legislative procedures, and what are the politics which are informing the discussions at member states and European Parliament level?
9:31
Well, I think one of the challenges when discussing this is that as it stands, you have more or less three different proposals to base any assessment on.
9:39
Insofar as you have the original commission proposal, which I suppose is the one that all of this conversation is anchored to.
9:45
You have the leaked Irish president draft over the summer, and then you also have lots of different conversations and snippets coming up around that, so that's the council level, the member state level conversation.
9:56
And then in the European Parliament, you have the draft amendments proposed by the various rapporteurs coming out of different committees.
10:04
But now we're at the stage where everyone in the European Parliament's chipping in, and I know Borderlex, you were keeping tally of, of the number of amendments that have been proposed, but I think that we've cleared 5,000 now.
10:14
It's a lot, and I suppose the point here is that given we have this end of year target for the completion of the legislative phase, and given that we currently have a complete lack of consensus [laughs] on the EU side in terms of what this IAA should actually look like, how third countries should be treated, under what criteria origin should be judged, I'm not sure this is going to get done by the end of the year.

7 MINS LATER

17:17
Here, I also think that, as William and Sam pointed out, I think the risk is also in investment and long-term employment in addition to the immediate risks, and the gradual shift of investment and jobs towards the EU and how serious these will become seems to be still uncertain and depends on how the draft is going to be finalized.
ArnaudHOST
17:18
Il y a eu des petits soucis au dos, je crois, Roseng.
17:21
Oui, de physique, oui.
17:22
Mais c'est vrai que, bon, cela au PGA, la concurrence est très, très forte.
17:27
Et même avec toutes les qualités qu'elle a, c'est certain que ce n'est pas évident de bien.
17:33
On voit Pauline qui a eu sa carte plusieurs fois, c'est difficile à tenir.
17:37
Bon, Maintenant, au niveau swing, c'est vraiment top.
17:41
Ce qu'on voit là, c'est un combat.

46 MINS LATER

ArnaudHOST
63:34
C'est quoi la suite de sa saison, la suite du programme pour Loïs ?
24:06
Sam, over to you for your comments.
24:08
Thank you very much, and thank you for the incredibly useful report that actually clearly articulates the answer to many questions I often receive.
24:17
I think one of the points I would make in terms of business impact, and I think it's captured here, is that it is prolonged.
24:26
It wasn't a one-off thing.
24:28
event for many businesses.
24:29
I mean, my day job is advising companies on their trade issues.
24:33
And I wouldn't say that EU-UK is the number one thing I get asked about, insofar as at the moment you've got the US, for example, and Donald Trump, which takes the award for that.

15 MINS LATER

40:03
Sam, yes, your comments on that.
17:22
Has that happened? And where it has happened, what does that look like?
17:26
So it absolutely has happened insofar as in the first instance, the UK actually had to replace all of the free trade agreements it had as part of the European Union, and it largely did so successfully.
17:38
A couple of countries fell to the wayside, but we managed to replace Japan, Canada, Mexico, Chile, and others.
17:44
But then the UK did go off and strike a free trade agreement with New Zealand, with Australia, with India.
17:50
It acceded to the Comprehensive and Progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership, CPTPP.
17:55
The EU now has since moved on, for example, New Zealand, Australia, and India, but the UK did manage to do that more quickly.
18:02
So did the UK manage to fulfill the promise of many Brexiters that it would go off and strike new free trade agreements? In many instances, yes.
22:42
For goods and services?
4:43
Has that happened? And where it has happened, what does that look like?
4:48
So it absolutely has happened insofar as in the first instance, the UK actually had to replace all of the free trade agreements it had as part of the European Union.
4:57
And it largely did so successfully.
4:59
A couple of countries fell to the wayside, but we managed to replace Japan, Canada, Mexico, Chile and others.
5:06
But then the UK did go off and strike a free trade agreement with New Zealand, with Australia, with India.
5:12
It acceded to the Comprehensive and Progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership, CPTPP.
5:16
The EU now has since moved on, for example, New Zealand, Australia and India.
10:03
Overall?
9:35
What would the negative effect on the British economy be from that?
9:40
So the deal itself, in terms of its beneficiaries, largely, uh, all- uh, benefits UK exports of automotives in the first instance, also steel, and more recently, um, pharmaceuticals in the context of some recent tariffs that are going to come into force soon.
9:58
So for example, at the moment, a hundred thousand vehicles a year exported to the US from the UK are levied with a ten percent tariff rather than a twenty-five percent tariff.
10:06
Actually, a twenty-seven and a half percent tariff, sorry.
10:09
So if the de-deal were to go away, those vehicles would now receive a twenty-seven and a half percent tariff when entering the US.
10:15
So that would obviously be material for those companies [inaudible]
11:02
Now, do you think that there is willingness in Brussels to come to some sort of better arrangement with Britain that Britain could actually accept without Keir Starmer being accused of going back on the Brexit vote?
11:17
So I think no matter what Keir Starmer does in relation to the EU, he'll always be accused of [chuckles] going back on the, on the Brexit vote, at least in the domestic politics, because there's incentives to do so.
JonHOST
16:04
And we asked him, what does this mean for our trade deal?
16:07
The most important thing to note up front is that the court ruling solely applies to the so-called reciprocal tariffs, which is at the moment the 10% tariff that applies universally to all imports, and also the tariffs linked to fentanyl.
16:22
So these are the tariffs of varying levels linked specifically to Canada, Mexico and China.
16:28
This means that at least on the face of it, the UK/US deal is unaffected, given that this deal focuses exclusively on the 25% automotive tariff, which the deal possibly reduces 10% for a fixed number of vehicles and also possible future so-called Section 232 investigations on pharmaceuticals elsewhere, and, and of course steel, which is already in effect and should be going to zero.
16:55
So on the face of it, the UK/US agreement is unaffected, but I think the thing to note here is that it hasn't currently been implemented.
17:03
So while there are still question marks about the president's ability to impose the so-called reciprocal tariff, the US might be distracted, it might lead to delays in implementation, and then if it is the case that Trump is unable to impose this 10% duty and other reciprocal tariffs because he loses in the Supreme Court where this will probably be appealed to, that could lead him to revisit the UK deal, although I think at the moment that's a low probability.
17:31
And the reason it could lead him to revisit this deal is that the terms of trade have changed.
19:43
So is there a sense here that maybe the countries can stand up to him?
19:50
I suppose in terms of standing up to him, I suppose my question is which countries are able to actually inflict economic pain on the United States? And the answer is the answer isn't zero.
20:05
As in, you could think there are certain things China could do, there are certain things the EU could do, there are certain things Mexico and Canada can do because of how heavily integrated they are into the US economy, which means that when they respond saying, for example, we're going to consider cutting off your energy supplies, which is one of the things that sort of mumbled up through the Canadian government, discourse that sort of markets and therefore the president does have to take it seriously but for lots of countries it's quite difficult to argue anything they could do by themselves would inflict significant pain on the us they could for example as we've seen previously impose new duties on sort of headline us products such as harley davidson's oranges from florida you know the sort of things that have some political salience but in terms of actually damaging the us economy or getting them to go oh i'm not sure about that it's difficult so i think the answer is that if for most countries if you wanted to stand up to him and say we're not going to accept you doing that and if you do do it we're going to strike back and it's going to be damaging for you You're going to need to do it collectively.
21:15
You would actually need sort of, you know, if we pick some middle powers, UK, Japan, South Korea, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, you can throw Mexico into that, Brazil.
21:25
If everyone said, you know, if you do this, say the universal tariff on steel and aluminium, we're going to respond by imposing new tariffs on these products and new restrictions on certain investment or the like.
21:39
But the problem is, because everyone knows he can be bargained with, creating that United Front is incredibly difficult because it just takes one of them to go, oh, actually, I reckon I can talk my way out of this.
21:53
For example, Modi, just after Trump announcing the reciprocal tariffs, Modi's there going, well, we could probably do a deal here.

6 MINS LATER

27:51
And I just wonder how that might play out and how the EU could respond to that.
12:00
Trade Organization.
12:01
World Trade Organization.
12:03
And around the same time, he initiated new tariffs on steel and aluminium.
12:07
So this is the 25% tariff on imported steel, 10% tariff on aluminium.
12:12
And this is really what most people think of when they discuss trade wars in the context of the first Trump administration, because these tariffs triggered a reaction from everyone.
12:22
The EU reacted by putting eventually tariffs on headline, well-known American companies such as Harley-Davidson and also different whiskeys.
12:33
China also reacted.

15 MINS LATER

27:25
Do you think we have the capacity to stand out against such demands or are we just going to go along with them?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.