Skip to main content
Rupert Darwall

Rupert Darwall

London-based strategy consultant and policy analyst; senior fellow at the National Center for Energy Analytics and author of "The Age of Global Warming," "Green Tyranny," and "The Age of Error and the West's Undoing."

Nov 17, 2026

1:45
Why would anybody want to reverse the Industrial Revolution? Because we all depend upon its fruits.
1:51
So environmentalism has quite a long history, which I actually delve into in two of my previous books.
1:59
You have to go back to Thomas Malthus and his theory of population, which incidentally was terribly badly timed because he published his work at the beginning of the 19th century at the onset of the British Industrial Revolution, which absolutely falsified his theory.
2:15
But when you had the post-war world, and I'm going to make a very big claim, which I'm sure Bill will have a pop at me.
2:22
But my contention is the single most influential book of the post-war period or the boomer period was Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, which was published in 1962 and contains the germ seed of post-war environmentalism.
2:37
And environmentalism had, it was extraordinary because it arose very, very, very quickly.
2:43
Within a decade, you had Richard Nixon forming EPA.

50 MINS LATER

52:33
And you can't alleviate poverty if you're not growing the world's
5:54
Do you think that's an accurate description of how the climate change debate has unfolded too? I
6:00
think that is an accurate but incomplete description of... what has happened and the starting book place in in in this book is an extraordinary essay 1983 essay written by mary douglas a british anthropologist and isaac um um the political scientist and it's called culture and risk and its basic hypothesis is that risk is culturally decided, culturally determined, that risk isn't something that's objectively out there, which, if you like, scientists go and perceive and then transcribe and write down.
6:48
What is seen as risk is what societies, and particularly the elites in society, say is risky.
6:54
And they made an observation and a prediction.
6:57
The first one was that They noticed the rise of environmentalism as an ideology.
7:06
And their explanation for it was that these were white liberal boomers who in the 1960s had been inspired by the civil rights movement but were excluded from it because of the colour of their skins.
7:19
But what they did is they appropriated the language and the moral absolutism of the civil rights movement and put it in the environmental movement.

6 MINS LATER

13:00
well now that that is fascinating that is that is fascinating now um what is do do you assess i think the very first question that anybody is going to ask of your book, when you face the barrage of media attention you're inevitably going to get, is are you a climate change denier? This is, I think, the language that's being
13:38
Can you unpack that idea?
13:40
Yeah, so one of the core sort of framing ideas of the book is that politicians have lost legitimacy, particularly since the financial crisis.
13:52
They've lost legitimacy, and to repair that loss of legitimacy, they have entered into a relationship of codependency with experts.
14:04
And the three types of experts I discuss in the book are central bankers, climate scientists and other forms of climate experts, so-called experts, and lastly epidemiologists and public health experts when we come to the pandemic.
14:21
And If we're looking first at central bankers, and I have a chapter on, particularly on Ben Bernanke, I think the financial crisis inflicted a profound trauma on Western elites.
14:37
Because we're so far on from the financial crisis, but we forget there was this sense, there was fear that the financial system could collapse.
14:46
And people were putting their money into gold.

48 MINS LATER

62:23
One of the big reasons that the vibe shift seems to have ended, not that we've backpedaled on climate change, but what do you make of the ongoing war with Russia and Ukraine and some of the negotiations around energy and even bring in Iran too with the Strait of Hormuz?
13:38
Can you unpack that idea?
13:40
Yeah, so one of the core sort of framing ideas of the book is that politicians have lost legitimacy, particularly since the financial crisis.
13:52
They've lost legitimacy, and to repair that loss of legitimacy, they have entered into a relationship of codependency with experts.
14:04
And the three types of experts I discuss in the book are central bankers, climate scientists and other forms of climate experts, so-called experts, and lastly epidemiologists and public health experts when we come to the pandemic.
14:21
And If we're looking first at central bankers, and I have a chapter on, particularly on Ben Bernanke, I think the financial crisis inflicted a profound trauma on Western elites.
14:37
Because we're so far on from the financial crisis, but we forget there was this sense, there was fear that the financial system could collapse.
14:46
And people were putting their money into gold.

48 MINS LATER

62:23
One of the big reasons that the vibe shift seems to have ended, not that we've backpedaled on climate change, but what do you make of the ongoing war with Russia and Ukraine and some of the negotiations around energy and even bring in Iran too with the Strait of Hormuz?
66:31
So my question to you from what you've seen over the last six to eight months, is there anything that you quibble with in terms of how Trump has approached energy policy and tried to leverage our energy independence?
66:47
No, I don't.
66:48
I think Trump absolutely got the fracking revolution, the shale revolution in his first term.
66:57
Harold Hamm had a lot of conversations with Trump.
67:02
He got the shale revolution.
67:04
He encouraged it.
67:05
And that was a big, big part of why that first term you saw actually pretty good economic growth.
69:11
And one wonders, as we're talking about generally speaking with Western Europe because of other policies – if their energy policy, as much as their open borders policies and confusion about criminals and law-abiding citizens and who deserves the government's protection, that the energy policy could be the factor to its long-term undoing.
19:05
Did the way that climate skeptics were silenced actually help create the system that was later used to shut down debate during the pandemic?
19:12
Yes, I think so.
19:13
And it's more...
19:15
It's more below board than just outright censorship.
19:20
I think what happened on the climate debate is, first of all, there was a very big political consensus.
19:27
So when the Climate Change Act was going through the House of Commons, only five MPs voted against it.
19:34
So there was virtual unanimity across the political spectrum.
21:26
What's your take on how they've reacted?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.