Skip to main content

Rob Russo

Canada correspondent for The Economist and veteran political journalist who led Ottawa and Washington bureaus at The Canadian Press and CBC News.

Nov 17, 2026

2:15
How far do you think Mark Carney's willing to go on the China push, the push for more trade with China?
2:24
I can tell you that the Chinese think he's only willing to go so far.
2:30
They actually believe that he will eventually turn back to the United States, and they are, in effect, being used as leverage.
2:40
In the interim, they don't mind getting a foot in the door of the Canadian market for some of their goods, and they don't mind looking like At a time when the world is surrounded by, you know, two or three superpowers, two of whom are involved in very difficult wars and look like they're faltering.
3:06
One is stable and increasing power.
3:09
its presence in parts of the world where it didn't have a presence before.
3:14
But let's put this into context.

15 MINS LATER

18:36
Talk to me about that.
6:21
metaphor morning.
6:23
I'm going to use the word bridge, and I'll tell you why I'm using it.
6:26
It's because it appears 74 times in the document.
6:29
And it's not about constructing a span.
6:33
It's about bridging Canadians to the promised land.
6:38
And I think that there's an acknowledgement that that's not working as well as it should be working when the government talks about building, tripling the rate of non-market housing, that they're going to get involved in building houses.
6:54
That's an avowal of failure in terms of their objective.

6 MINS LATER

12:30
Do things get any easier for Canada?
speaker_0HOST
0:49
Where
0:49
votes are at.
0:50
In a cross-section of regions of the country.
0:53
Yes, yes.
0:55
And some very, very interesting candidates, I find.
0:59
You know, people, particularly liberals, are talking about the fantasy of winning in a place like York and Melville.
1:07
I'll wait for Kate to hear about how much of a, to tell us how much of a fantasy it is.

8 MINS LATER

speaker_0HOST
9:35
It's important to show that they can have a foothold in that province, right?
18:45
Rob, what do you make of these?
18:47
Well, I love by-elections more than I love polls because they're particularly in a series of by-elections like this, cross-sections of the country, French and English, East-West.
19:04
We're going to get a real sense of something that I think is that a lot of political scientists are looking at.
19:11
have we reached Pete Carney or is he capable of launching into a higher political popularity orbit? And real voters will tell us this in different regions of the country.
19:27
I absolutely agree with Althea about what conservatives are saying.
19:31
about Brantford, Brant South.
19:34
There's a guy named Dave Carroll there who was fighting hard for the nomination, didn't get a chance to actually contest for it.

14 MINS LATER

33:31
So it seems like there's an attention paid to that as well.
5:15
But I'm just wondering how you're seeing this one because, of course, everyone's waking up today saying, what just happened there?
5:21
Well, from now on, David Eby will be synonymous with the stuff of baleful political lore.
5:28
He'll replace David Peterson, who called an unnecessary election that led to the first time ever election of the NDP in Ontario.
5:38
That name, Peterson, will be replaced by David Eby, and he accomplished a feat that is quite unique.
5:45
Katie's right.
5:46
He reunited the right in British Columbia, but from a distance, he accomplished a feat greater than that, a feat greater than Stephen Harper accomplished.
5:55
and Peter McKay, who reunited the right across the country, David Eby resurrected the right.

11 MINS LATER

16:40
So how does this change? political provincial landscape affect that dynamic between the feds and the provinces?
15:29
I'm sure it's something that the PQ in Quebec is paying attention to.
15:34
Right.
15:34
Yeah, that's along the lines of the old Léon Zion knife at the throat strategy that Quebec has successfully employed for 60 years.
15:45
They have made the loudest noise ever.
15:49
brandished the biggest threat and and there are a lot of people who believe as a result they've got much of what they wanted in a decentralized Federation so let's look at some of the things that Danielle Smith says she wants she wants more control over immigration And I think that that's one of the nine questions that had the highest level of support so far.
16:15
There's no reason why the federal government and the province of Alberta can't cut a deal on Alberta having more say over immigration.
16:24
There's already a separate deal with the province of Quebec that respects the linguistic and cultural distinctiveness of Quebec.

12 MINS LATER

28:58
Rob, do you agree with that? It's not going to get the attention that at least Althea thinks it deserves.
2:28
[laughs]
2:29
Look, um, I, I think, I think before we, we, we talk about centrifugal forces, and there are some, I do think we have to point out that, uh, at 28%, uh, the separatist party, uh, that won last night, the Parti Québécois, has less support than the levels of support for independence in the province of Quebec.
2:53
Um, and, and that, uh, they will not soar towards a referendum on, on separation.
3:01
They have buckshot in their wings at 28%.
3:05
Um, but it is true, if you're looking at the country in, in, in, in its entirety, that we now have a separatist movement in the east, in the province of Quebec.
3:16
Depending on the results of the referendum in Alberta in a couple of weeks, we certainly have a burgeoning separatist movement in Alberta, and we have other forces tugging us apart from the south.
3:29
So from the east, the west, and the south, Canada faces centrifugal forces that are trying to pull it apart.

22 MINS LATER

26:00
Um, what's your take on what you think last night means to the Alberta story?
9:14
Um, so how much of that drop in trust is as a result of the way the media has been painted and treated?
9:25
I, I, I, I'm go- I'm, I'm going to be offside with some of my colleagues here, but I do believe we bear a, a fair amount of the burden for the drop in trust in, in media.
9:36
We get it wrong, uh, and that happens.
9:38
There's nothing wrong, uh, with us getting it wrong.
9:41
It, it, it's, again, it's, it's a normal part of consuming, uh, uh, a, a whole bunch of complex information, distilling it to its essence, and articulating it in a way that connects with people.
9:53
Sometimes you get it wrong.
9:55
However, however, when you get it wrong, you need to acknowledge it.

10 MINS LATER

20:07
Rob?
3:46
Of all the things that happened, what do you think was the most consequential thing that was announced?
3:51
Well, let's give some credit.
3:53
The fact that a Canadian prime minister was able to attract these people here all at once, I think, rates a success story for a couple of reasons.
4:06
For number one, Canada used to have to go out on what was called Team Canada missions.
4:11
Prime minister would gather a whole bunch of of CEOs, take them abroad to Beijing or to Singapore or to London, and they would sign some deals and that would be the end of it.
4:23
Carney said, no, we're not doing this.
4:26
I'm going to try something else.
9:02
Could Canada join the EU? But do we have any sense yet of what that could actually mean?
27:58
What is the bar for success? Rob, how do we know that it worked?
28:03
Well, if there's a second one, that would be one indication, one barometer of success.
28:07
They're hoping to have more than one.
28:10
It's not just deals.
28:12
I think it's this – their goal is to change the perception that Canada has great resources – But none of the infrastructure and a lot of the regulatory problems that aren't found in the United States.
28:29
I think the goal is to say to people, if you're interested in investing in North America, don't just automatically go to the United States.
28:37
Look at us.

17 MINS LATER

Bob Rae
Bob RaeGUEST
45:43
I didn't
15:48
Mm
15:49
... than, than CUSMA.
15:50
Um, and, and now CUSMA is, is really what's, what's saving us.
15:56
I, I think people in Canada have, have determined that, that, uh, you, you cannot negotiate with a creature like Donald Trump.
16:04
Uh, but that being said, the, the Prime Minister did promise something better.
16:08
He, in his Saturday news conference of August First, I believe, remarkable news conference if you go through the verbatim.
16:16
He did, uh, say that there was a, uh, a-another version, another try to get a, a prosperity and security agreement with the United States that in some ways would have tied us, uh, closer to the United States, and, and we're, we're, we're not gonna get that, uh, now.
21:03
What happens if there's no deal? Is that when we really start to see job losses, shrinkage on the economy of, um, uh, in a number of provinces if not all, crashing of small businesses, the automotive sector going under? Is that, is that the picture?
25:06
Hmm.
25:07
Uh, and we do need a strategy to come to some sort of arrangement because he- here's where, where we are, Pia, right now.
25:15
It's impossible for any business to predict what grenade is gonna go off next.
25:21
A- and it's, it's not just, uh, the businesses that have been hit by the new tariffs or the old tariffs.
25:28
It's any, uh, Canadian business that is exposed to trade.
25:32
They're all waiting to see what comes next, whether it g- gets lobbed out in a, uh, in, in, in a, a social media post from the, uh, from the President of the United States, or, or it's something that they dusted off like they did with the 100-year-old Smoot-Hawley, um, uh, uh, legislation.
25:52
So, uh, the next few days, I, I, I was more than intrigued that the prime minister, uh, offered two weeks before replying and retaliating with Canada's own, uh, tariffs.

6 MINS LATER

32:16
What does the prime minister need to do in, say, like the next week to ensure that we're, like, all rowing in the same direction?
1:23
So what was your reaction when you heard about this now delay?
1:27
I was still baffled and befuddled that there is no clear outcome.
1:34
If you think of it, think of it as a hardly or difficult hockey game, tough fought game, hard fought game, an underdog.
1:44
And after all of that effort, now we're in overtime.
1:47
And so we go back into overtime and we start talking and keep talking.
1:52
I'm struck by the difference in tone from both sides.
1:58
And in one side, We have jubilation almost.

6 MINS LATER

8:21
So what do you think about that wait it out strategy for Donald Trump and just kind of plug the holes in the boat while that's all going down?
5:18
So, Rob, what could doing whatever it takes look like?
5:24
Well, if you listen to the premiers, there is no unanimity of opinion on that.
5:30
We have two or three choices.
5:32
We can retaliate.
5:33
And to those who favor retaliation, I would pose the question, to what extent? Do you really, really want to think about cutting off energy exports? Let's say you're in Quebec.
5:46
You want to consider cutting off hydro exports to the northeastern United States.
5:51
Or let's say you're in Alberta and you want to consider cutting off oil exports or tariffing them or reducing them to the United States.

13 MINS LATER

19:16
What is the deal with this deal?
6:36
So Rob, that's the premier's justification, but what is her motivation? What is the political calculation she's making here?
6:45
Well, there, there are a couple of them.
6:46
Um, first of all, she is trying to develop the economy of her province at a...
6:52
And, and I also think trying to assert some of the economic power that A- Alberta has at a time when its political power in our federation is, is stunted.
7:02
Uh, it, it, it is, um, a kind of a, a cruel reality of, of the Canadian Constitution that New Brunswick, which has less than a million people according to official figures, has 10 senators, uh, in, in the Parliament of Canada, and Alberta, which has five million people, and I would say is probably, uh, well, I know, it per capita the biggest contributor to our prosperity, uh, it, it only has six senators.
7:31
It has, uh, it has less representation in Ottawa than some of the smaller provinces.
7:36
Um, it's, it's had its, uh, economic ambitions and, to a large extent, its political voice, um, thwarted, if not suffocated, over the last little while.

6 MINS LATER

13:45
So despite the upcoming Alberta referendum, could this be, I don't know, the beginning of a strengthening of national unity, or is this hurting it?
31:08
[laughs]
31:08
Um, that is not the case when it comes to Pete Hoekstra.
31:13
We are getting unfiltered Trump.
31:16
Um, and is that, uh, a, a pleasant thing to hear? It isn't.
31:21
It isn't always a pleasant thing to hear.
31:23
Is it a helpful thing to hear? I, I think in many ways it is.
31:26
We know where we stand.

12 MINS LATER

43:28
At least you have it to dye.
3:02
So I guess my question is, given that, and given this discussion of a post-America world, and Canada's dominance seemingly in it, what are the risks and rewards for Canada, and for Mark Carney in particular? And Rob, why don't, uh, why don't you start us on this?
3:24
Well, um, I, I don't know that he has much choice to, to do what he's doing.
3:30
The, the, the prime minister is trying, in effect, to be-- to fashion a garment, almost like an economic tailor, uh, a, a fine garment stitching together trading blocks in Europe, in the Pacific, and, and in South America, in Mercosur.
3:46
He might as well also be stitching a red handkerchief right in the middle of that garment because he's waving a red handkerchief in the face of Donald Trump when he says that, uh, the, the new international order will be built out of Europe.
4:00
Um, and I think he's quite fine with waving that red handkerchief in front of Trump.
4:06
Uh, I, I don't think he does it, you know, deliberately, but it does not perturb him to do it.
4:12
Um, so, uh, sure, he, he has to do it.

28 MINS LATER

32:06
Uh, what are you hearing?
14:13
And y- a lot of this European focus also got a, a big bump from the prime minister's speech at Davos in Switzerland, and the critics say, "Look, speeches are nice, but we need you to put your money where your mouth is." And so when you suggest, "Look, we haven't even ratified a trade agreement for so many years, years ago," how politically risky is this for the prime minister?
14:35
I think the, the biggest political risk lies, uh, in terms of his relationship with the United States.
14:41
Um, y- your previous guest, uh, mentioned that, that Germany is, is now, uh, suffering the great gusts of Trump's contempt.
14:50
Uh, and it's, it's following a pattern, okay? The, the people in Europe, some of the leaders, it, it be- it began with Keir Starmer who's, who said he had a marvelous relationship with Donald Trump, and then, uh, uh, uh, France's Macron, the same thing.
15:04
They, they start, uh, in these relationships.
15:07
They, they, um, they speak frankly to him.
15:11
Uh, and when that frankness spills out into public, they're then, uh, the, the subject of ridicule, humiliation, and in the case of Germany, uh, real economic costs.
19:44
What are the political calculations Carney's making by saying things, uh, uh, about a pipeline, quote, "More probable than possible"?
1:47
Now, listen, we've heard a lot of things from the Trump White House over the years, uh, but this one seems to take the cake a little bit, and I have a hard time believing it, but I wanna check on two of the best reporters on Parliament Hill to see whether they're ear to the ground, they've heard anything remotely like this, and Rob Russo's gonna start us off.
2:12
[laughs] Well, um, I think it wasn't an accident that Mark Carney a-asked King Charles to come and open our Parliament.
2:24
Uh, I think that was done by design.
2:26
It was done because, uh...
2:28
Well, I know, we all know, I think it was done because, uh, they believed that that was a pow-powerful signal, a potent signal.
2:37
Uh, the signal was, uh, twofold.
2:39
Number one, it, it underscored, uh, the differences between us and the United States, and it was also a signal to, uh, that well-known monarchist, Donald Trump.

15 MINS LATER

speaker_5UNKNOWN
18:14
There, there are, there are, there are people who are quite content and supporters of Mr. Poilievre.
4:29
Well, I'm going to ask you to try and answer that question, but I want to hear from Rob first of all, um, in terms of his sense of what this Monday night was all about.
4:40
I, I've sat in, um, on a lot of these take-note debates, and often they're, um, they're devoid of any, any real, uh, insight, uh, any real debate.
4:52
Uh, I didn't feel like that was happening from what I listened, uh, to.
4:57
Uh, I, I thought that there was some, there were some worthwhile questions asked about Canada's preparation ahead of this, whether or not we were ready to get people out, whether or not we did enough to get people out.
5:10
Uh, I thought both, uh, Conservatives and Liberals, uh, I, I confess that I didn't, uh, hear Mr. Blanchet, um, made a, made a, a, a good point, uh, several good points about what we do have at stake.
5:24
We are not combatants.
5:25
We will not be combatants.

21 MINS LATER

25:57
So why? What's the interest?
4:12
So I guess the question becomes, you know, is it a spirit of, uh, cooperation or is, uh, a spirit of survival, especially on the part of the Conservatives? Rob, what's your take on this?
4:23
Yeah.
4:24
I, I, I think that, uh, that Andrew Scheer is going to great pains to paw at the ground, snort, uh, suggest that, uh, they compelled the government to make all kinds of changes to legislation like C-15, and that he's prepared to fight them right up to the line where a confidence vote would be required that could dissolve Parliament, uh, and result in election.
4:48
Um, I, I, I think that it's poll-driven.
4:51
Much of what we're seeing now in terms of the Conservative posture is poll-driven.
4:56
It's not a bad thing necessarily, uh, that, that parties get together and actually compromise.
5:02
It, uh, in a minority Parliament, that's, that's the way it's supposed to, it's supposed to work.

32 MINS LATER

36:40
Um-
18:48
I feel like I have not enough inputs of information to know whether this was a productive meeting or if it was just productive for Canada or if it was just productive for Jamil Jivani and his social media feeds.
19:02
Rob? Well, given the, well, I don't know, 250 words of dribbling snot we got from Donald Trump last night, I don't know how productive it was.
19:18
And you're talking to a guy or you're listening to a guy who was in favor of Jamil Javani going down there.
19:25
At a moment like this, given what we're facing at this time, Point in our history, you use every asset you can in order to advance your interests.
19:38
And so why wouldn't you use somebody who has a great friendship with the vice president of the United States? No matter whether it was 15 seconds or 15 minutes or 150 minutes, nobody gets near the president of the United States unless the president wants that to happen.
19:56
He's thoroughly vetted.
19:58
And so the fact that he got near Trump and that they had a discussion is significant.

19 MINS LATER

38:46
But the possibility remains and the liberals are trying to cast it both ways.
6:12
What do you make of it, Rob?
6:15
I think Althea makes an important point at the beginning when she said we don't know what's happened because the Prime Minister's office hasn't given us a readout.
6:24
And that is an important point, not because reporters bellyache when they don't know what's going on.
6:30
We do.
6:32
But in this instance, the mushroom cloud from Mount Mar-a-Lago is going to billow out for a long time in an instance like this.
6:42
And you have to be in a position to control the fallout.
6:46
And if the White House or Scott Besant, in this instance, is putting out their version of events, you're going to be forced to react and it's going to put you in an unflattering light.

14 MINS LATER

21:19
What was your take on it?
12:05
Is there a sense of anything like that on this one? Rob?
12:09
Yeah, I think we learned today that Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe is going to be joining the Prime Minister on this trip.
12:18
As we all know, there are very steep tariffs on canola and other agricultural and aquatic products that China has applied on Canada.
12:29
The fact that Premier Moe is there is an indication that there will probably be an announcement on that.
12:35
But let's You know, let's face facts.
12:39
He wouldn't be making the trip if he wasn't going to be coming home with something.
12:42
And I know we've said that in the past, particularly about Donald Trump.

19 MINS LATER

32:07
Let me ask, though, and maybe to you first, Rob, has the prime minister been pushed on the Greenland comments that Donald Trump has made? No,
4:13
rob you see it that way too
4:17
Yeah, I think it's fair to say that I, like a lot of people, was slack-jawed with astonishment when this one happened.
4:26
And I think in a way it's emblematic of the whole year and the whole shift in the tectonic plates of political Canada.
4:36
I mean, a lot of us were talking about even on election night that given the numbers and how close the Liberals were to a majority, they were going to go shopping for MPs.
4:47
Almost all of us who were talking about that were thinking they were going to go after scattered and demoralized New Democrats.
4:56
And instead, it's been conservatives.
4:59
I think that that surprised people.

19 MINS LATER

23:56
I mean, if Polyev comes out of there with 80% support or better, how is a caucus member going to stand up in caucus and go after this, you know, his throat? I mean, he's got the support of his party.

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.