Skip to main content

Raffaele D'Anna

Historian of economic history and the history of science; tenure-track Assistant Professor in Economic History at the Sant'Anna School of Advanced Studies (Pisa) and author of "The Craft of Indo-Arabic Numerals" (Harvard UP, 2026).

Nov 11, 2026

18:28
My third question is, what was the most surprising thing that you found in your research?
18:36
Well, you know, I...
18:42
I try to think of my research process as kind of iterative, okay, which is a, at least to me, of course, I don't want to.
18:55
But at least to me, iterative means that you start somewhere with something that sounds interesting.
19:01
And you first get into that question with some assumptions, right? And then the more you are into that question, the more you also have to go back and kind of question the assumptions you started from.
19:19
So one of the moments in which this happened along this project was the fact that I started kind of tracing this practical mathematics with the idea of this was a commercial technology, this is an economic history.
19:38
And then when I finally started looking at the maps that I was getting from the evidence that I had collected, I saw that the pattern of diffusion across Europe was very different from what I was expecting, right? Because at least one of these standard narratives of European economic development between the late medieval and the early modern period is it is trade.

18 MINS LATER

37:45
So what do you think about this? Or do you also kind of adhere to the other dominant theory of money that says that money rather comes from debt in government bodies, imposing certain types of money, more a la David Graeber?
18:45
Can you tell us more about where in Europe these practices were first adopted?
18:49
Yeah, the adoption of these numbers in Europe was a complex process.
18:58
So again, this is a story in which it is very difficult to... identify inventors or origins or departures.
19:14
What we see in this story are processes.
19:21
which are processes of deep change, but which do not occur because of a sudden change, okay? They are incremental transformations.
19:36
And the adoption of these numbers into Europe is a very good case to see this.
19:41
So we have said that around the 11th century, scholars in Al-Andalus were... using and developing and experimenting with the mathematics that they had learned from what we would call, as Europeans, the Middle East.

33 MINS LATER

52:36
So can we talk a bit more about sort of who was learning this, why, and kind of how this sort of education process was part of the communication and adoption of these methods?
18:39
Can you tell us more about where in Europe these practices were first adopted?
18:44
Yeah.
18:44
The, the adoption of these numbers, uh, in Europe was a complex process.
18:52
Uh, so again, this is a story in which, uh, it is very difficult to, uh, identify, like, inventors or origins or, uh, departures.
19:08
What we see in this story, um, are processes, which are processes of, uh, deep change, but which do not occur, uh, because of a sudden change, okay? Uh, they are incremental, uh, uh, transformations.
19:30
And the adoption of these numbers into Europe is a very good case to see this.
19:35
So we have said that around the 11th century, uh, scholars in Al-Andalus were using and developing and experimenting with the mathematics that they had learned from what we would call, uh, as Europeans, the Middle East, okay? Um, but Al-Andalus was a very porous space at this time, okay? And this is also the place in which we start to see the first Latin translations, um, dedicated...

30 MINS LATER

50:41
So can we talk a bit more about sort of who was learning this, why, um, and kind of how this sort of education process was part of the communication and adoption of these methods?
17:15
Can you tell us more about where in Europe these practices were first adopted?
17:19
Yeah, the adoption of these numbers in Europe was a complex process.
17:28
So again, this is a story in which it is very difficult to... identify inventors or origins or departures.
17:43
What we see in this story are processes.
17:51
which are processes of deep change, but which do not occur because of a sudden change, okay? They are incremental transformations.
18:06
And the adoption of these numbers into Europe is a very good case to see this.
18:11
So we have said that around the 11th century, scholars in Al-Andalus were... using and developing and experimenting with the mathematics that they had learned from what we would call, as Europeans, the Middle East.

28 MINS LATER

46:16
So can we talk a bit more about sort of who was learning this, why, and kind of how this sort of education process was part of the communication and adoption of these methods?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.