Skip to main content
Paul D. Miller

Paul D. Miller

Political scientist

Nov 2, 2026

13:36
And those who are all in, like, can you help us understand that spectrum and maybe the entry point and what carries people along farther in that spectrum? Yeah.
13:45
Really good, really important question.
13:46
And again, one that I think I maybe have answered more clearly after the book.
13:51
I wrote an article about this in Christianity Today in 23, 24, I think, specifically about this idea of the spectrum.
13:59
I think that there's a variety of different kinds of Christian nationalism.
14:03
There's both mainstream, peaceful kind, which I disagree with.
14:08
I think it's wrong and unjust.
18:04
And, you know, in a diverse nation like the United States, I guess my question is, how does Christian nationalism incorporate or respond to a multiplicity of ethnicities or races in our so-called melting pot? Like, how does that work with Christian nationalism?
Jared LongshoreMODERATOR
88:34
His talk this morning is Do They All Have to Go Back? So a warm welcome for Paul Miller.
88:51
Well, thank you to Doug, to everyone with Canon Press, New St. Andrews College.
88:56
Thank you all for your time.
88:58
It's been a really fun back and forth so far and I look forward to continuing it.
89:04
Most talks and panels are about 45 minutes to an hour and you can barely get a sentence out and then you're done.
89:09
So I appreciate that we have time to all be Baptists and speak at length here.
89:14
I recognize that I represent mostly a divergent view here.

1 HR LATER

149:24
So anybody who voted for Mondami should lose their citizenship.
64:06
Milt Bearden was a CIA officer who had been deeply involved in, among other things, the anti-Soviet period in Afghan affairs.
64:20
Yeah, he was the station chief in Islamabad in the 80s, I believe.
64:24
Great guy, and he sat down and chatted with me when I was teaching in Texas.
64:29
But so far as I can tell, it's the first time that the phrase graveyard of empires was applied to Afghanistan.
64:35
Some people think that it's like this ancient label or nickname that's been around for a century, and that's just not true that I can tell.
64:42
But it did give policymakers this handle, this little kind of like intellectual handle, say, oh, oh, Afghanistan is the place where empires go to die.
64:53
Therefore, we, America, the new empire, must be careful not to send in too large of a force.

10 MINS LATER

75:13
Talk a bit about some of those issues, if you would.
4:54
So, if we had the political will and the political capital for it, What would you see as the optimal strategy for weakening the Iran regime to the point of making it plausible that there might be some sort of uprising or anything which would allow it so that in the future, the United States, Israel, and our allies are safer from the threat of Iran? If you had the political capital, what would you do?
5:33
I'm not sure I would make regime change the sole explicit goal.
5:38
I want regime change.
5:39
I think everybody should pray for that because it's a terrible regime and it threatens everybody.
5:44
But I think the right way to approach this is create some kind of off ramp for the current Iranian regime so that negotiations might actually succeed in something, not just a meaningless statement, while also preparing the ground for regime change just in case.
5:59
So it's kind of a two pronged approach.
6:01
And that first prong is keep the military in place, sink the Iranian Navy, whoever the ships are out there.

27 MINS LATER

33:12
all right?
15:35
Mm, I don't necessarily agree that the, uh, that certainly Hamas' cause is right, or that all of the claims of Palestinian resistance are right, but my question is, knowing what you know about international law and just cause doctrine, how much does the rightness of the claims really matter, or does it stop at once you use the tactics, you're in the wrong, full stop?
15:58
If there's a non-state group that's got just cause for a rebellion or a, a movement for liberation or something, okay, then that's the American colonists against the British in 1776.
16:12
You still have to fight with justice.
16:14
You still have to exercise discrimination and proportionality.
16:18
And just because we're in the right, doesn't mean we get to go out and, you know, murder British civilians on purpose.
16:25
And the problem with Hamas, they are the greatest enemy of the Palestinian people, because they have- they've made it very hard to support the legitimate claims of the Palestinian people without feeling complicit in terrorism.
16:37
Hamas, as a group, denies Israel's right to exist, and they pr- and they, and they practice terrorism.

24 MINS LATER

40:37
What might be the tough thing for them to do, um, to reestablish justice as they define it, as you define it within their nation? And you can take into account, "I think it's important for them to get back in the graces of the international community," or, "I think it's important for them to realize that they're still under attack." However you want to take it, what do you think the best thing Israel should do now is?
3:18
Why should we bother with China? Are they really a threat to the US and a global threat?
3:23
Yes, China is a threat to the United States and indeed to the free world that we have built and sustained since World War II.
3:31
China is United States', I think, largest trading partner or one of the top two or three trading partners, but a lot of their goods are made by almost slave labor, and I think it's appropriate for us to have trade barriers to protect against that.
3:44
We don't want to import their labor standards and their environmental standards, and there's geopolitical reasons why we want to maybe decouple or de-risk our economy from theirs so that China can't import their censorship into our economy the way they've done in the past.
3:58
It's a legitimate move.
4:00
China has extraordinary amount of economic leverage over the United States.
4:04
Some years ago, there was a coach in the NBA that tweeted support for protests in Hong Kong.

10 MINS LATER

13:42
Can you explain, kind of, the central thrust of that idea and how that kind of framing can inform what we're seeing in the headlines this week?
6:52
Paul, how do you respond to those comments that we've heard from the government saying this wasn't classified information, it's okay for Jeffrey Goldberg to share this?
7:00
Legally speaking, the president has declassification authority so that if he says it's not classified, it therefore isn't.
7:07
Looking at the text messages, I'm fairly confident that normally this would be considered classified information, again, judging from the time I spent dealing with lots of classified information in the government.
7:18
I want to both share Russell's concern that this happened and say that it shouldn't happen.
7:24
We should expect our government to live up to higher standards of operational security and good judgment.
7:30
Mike Waltz, he and I worked together on the NSC 15 years ago.
7:33
I do have high regard for him and for Secretary Marco Rubio.

5 MINS LATER

12:47
Should the easy access to classified information or perhaps just important information that should not be public to others, however you wanna describe it, should this make me worried about the safety of Americans, not just the safety of American servicemen or women who are assigned to particular missions, but are Americans in general less safe if something like this can happen?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.