Skip to main content
Patrick Neville

Patrick Neville

American Politician

Aug 17, 2026

13:34
Okay.
13:34
So bear with me, but there is some precedent for this kind of monopsony A-list, um, screenwriter talent case.
13:42
So when Penguin Random House tried to buy Simon & Schuster back in twenty twenty-two, the DOJ was able to bro- to block the deal.
13:50
And the court agreed with DOJ that combining two of these five, these big five book publishers would harm competition in the market for anticipated top-selling books, and more specifically, it would cause harm to author payments due to reduced competition.
14:08
So in that case, though, the relevant market was not all books, but a narrower segment where buyers competed for these marquee works.
14:15
So we can see that if we apply that, a similar framework here, there's at least a plausible claim for s- for the few screenwriters that compete for these wide-release films.
14:25
Now, proving this concept, like you said, is very tricky, and I would guess that if, if the Writers Guild are gonna try to do so, they'll have to follow a paradigm very similar to what Penguin-- uh, the DOJ did in Pengu- Penguin Random House, excuse me.

7 MINS LATER

21:14
What, what are you thinking about that? Is that a possibility here?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.