Skip to main content

Nora Devine

Oct 20, 2026

4:42
Are there other potential advantages to uh that you see you know ai bring to the assessment process i can see both in terms of uh you mentioned you touched on almost an enforcement issue there you know as well
4:56
Well, we've seen a lot of people reduce the amount of human capital they have out in the field, meaning the people that are out there actually looking at the new properties and looking at the additions that were put on or looking at property that blew away in a tornado or something like that.
5:12
So they are relying on technological advances.
5:16
tools in order to ascertain what changes have happened and how their assessment roles need to be updated in response to those changes and the biggest advantages are going to be just more consistency more accuracy more efficiency and that could help reduce any kind of human bias that might be in the system and improve how quickly assessors respond to changes in market conditions as well Right now we have a triennial system in Cook County.
5:41
We reassess one-third of the county this year, one-third the next year, and the other third the next year after that.
5:47
So once we get this data really flying, I think that we could go toward annual assessments without actually driving the employees of the assessor's offices into an early grave.
6:00
So it could also free up assessors to focus on more complex cases like unique properties or unique appeals while routine valuations are handled more efficiently.
8:13
How could automated valuation tools affect the evidence that property owners use in assessment appeals?
0:41
I, I just assumed you'd, you'd have to be licensed, so [chuckles] can you explain what's considered unlicensed practice of law under Illinois law?
0:50
Sure.
0:50
So speaking specifically about my practice area, which is real estate tax appeals, in Illinois, you do have to be a licensed attorney in order to go to the Boards of Review or in order to go to the Illinois Property Tax Appeal Board or in order to go to circuit court.
1:04
So that's three out of the four venues where you could seek tax relief that you do have to be a licensed attorney.
1:09
In other states, it may not be the case.
1:11
Um, Texas comes to mind.
1:13
They have a independent licensure structure for non-attorneys to become licensed as property tax reps, and they can be disciplined like any other licensed professional under, you know, the state's structure for disciplining anyone with a license.

16 MINS LATER

17:03
With the couple minutes we have left, I'm wondering, uh, you know, when a property, when property owners are trying to understand who is qualified to represent them in a property tax matter, what factors should they pay attention to?
30:08
What are some things that you think that they should be asking their sponsors if they're looking to be investing in a syndication or a fund? Do the people I'm investing with, do they have any idea about like, have they done any work to go and look at their tax forecasting or tax plan as an example?
30:24
Yeah, they are starting to be more proactive.
30:27
I give projections all the time to syndications who are thinking about more multifamily acquisitions.
30:33
And unfortunately, in Illinois, you really do have to ask somebody, is this a jurisdiction where they're going to chase this sale? Because I'm about ready to pay 100% more than what this asset is currently valued at for tax purposes.
30:46
And in Illinois, you're not supposed to chase the sale, but there are certain jurisdictions to do.
30:51
It's illegal, but it's going to take me years to straighten that out for you.
30:56
So you could be paying an enormous amount of money under protest and waiting for me to get the case all the way through the Illinois Property Tax Appeal Board to get you the relief that you need.
34:41
People do not know what to do with it.
3:30
What does that actually mean with the structure of Illinois property taxation?
3:34
I think that there will be shifts because there are shifts in the real estate market.
3:40
Right now, we've got the real estate markets very hot in this area, particularly in the suburbs.
3:46
So you've seen enormous increases in real estate values in most of the suburban towns around Chicago.
3:52
And then you've seen a lot of vacancy in the central business district, and you've seen a lot of vacancy, high vacancy rates.
4:00
You've seen some sales of commercial office buildings that are much lower than what we've seen in the past.
4:06
So when you have residential on a steep incline and you have commercial office and other categories of non-residential property on a decline, I guess you would expect to see the property tax burden shift slightly between commercial a commercial-based losing value and a residential-based gaining value.

8 MINS LATER

12:35
So that's interesting.
speaker_0UNKNOWN
1:12
assessment purposes
1:13
and commercial and industrial property are assessed at two and a half times higher than residential.
1:18
So residential is already enjoying pretty substantial benefit from the classification system.
1:24
And the way to explain it is if there's a million dollar commercial property that you buy, the assessment would be $250,000, assuming the million dollar purchase price was arm's length and nobody was under duress and everybody was apprised and it was a good sale and it was advertised on the market.
1:42
Conversely, if you were to buy a residential property across the street from that commercial property for a million dollars, the assessment would only be $100,000.
1:50
So you could see that difference there between...
1:53
Commercial and residential and the way that the classification system treats them differently.

10 MINS LATER

11:34
And so for taxpayers who maybe are trying to understand their bill, what are the clearest indicators that an incentive is in place on a neighboring commercial or industrial project? I mean, you mentioned sale prices differing as an indication.
0:40
When two nearly identical properties get very, very different assessments, what's usually driving the difference behind the scenes?
0:47
It depends on which jurisdiction you're in.
0:49
If you're in Cook County, there, you know, it could be that there was, uh, some sales activity.
0:54
Um, and then there's other counties that are more likely to, what we call chase the sale, meaning, um, if you've got, um, you know, 15 identical properties that haven't sold in 30 years, and you've got five properties that are exactly the same as those 15, and those have traded hands in the last five years, due to the way that the assessment, um, m-mass appraisal systems work, you may see higher assessed values for the five that traded, even though theoretically you shouldn't.
1:23
If they're identical or if they're similar enough, similarly classified, they should be moving up together, the whole class of them, if they're, uh, if they're truly identical.
1:32
But mass appraisal systems are designed to ... theoretically, under the Illinois law, you're supposed to be assessing a three-year median of sales.
1:42
So you take that house type in, in that neighborhood code, and you looked at what has sold in the last three years, what is the median of it, and then therefore there is, there is the value that you're supposed to be targeting.
2:07
So, so how, how then the, how does the assessor's use of comparable sales and neighborhood factors play into why one property value might shift?
1:30
Yeah.
1:30
I think that it really should be for a multifamily property, even if those properties may be clustered in a group of townhomes or may be small single-family homes, which is something that's more palatable for some of these communities where the affordable housing developers are, are trying to do deals.
1:47
So it's basically if there's seven or more units and they're willing to reserve some of those units for affordable tenants, meaning these are tenants who make at about 60% of area median income.
2:01
And so what, what that means is it's like $46,000 for an individual or $55,000 for a small family, and it's supposed to encourage the preservation of existing buildings, so it's to spur development where they would be doing major renovations of existing building systems of existing buildings, and it's also intended to spur the creation of new structures, so new affordable housing.
2:28
And i- in order to, um, incentivize this, this market activity, the idea is that if, if they can give them some kind of a tax, uh, credit or some kind of an offset or some kind of a tax reduction for a certain number of years, then hopefully that would in- increase the amount of affordable units that we're seeing.

8 MINS LATER

10:25
So are counties able to opt out of this incentive if they want to?
10:29
Uh, yes, and unfortunately, several have.
10:33
Uh, I have a colleague on the government side who tries to keep up with the list of counties that have opted out.
9:04
How much of the modern property tax process now depends on reliable digital records and system accuracy?
9:13
It's such a good question because today we still refer to something called warrant books and people that have been around a long time like me, we remember when there actually were huge books like this big and they were all lined up on a shelf in the actual county clerk's office.
9:30
And you would be recording things on the title to the property in terms of property tax information, whether it's the taxes weren't paid or some unpaid installments were sold to a tax buyer or what the finalized assessments were.
9:47
And so you can actually go into an office and like pick out a heavy physical book from a shelf and flip through it and look at it.
9:54
But, and you would think that that sounds ancient, but it wasn't that long ago that these books existed, not long at all.
10:01
So getting rid of these books and going totally digital.
10:07
I mean, it would be smart, but I don't think they have the staff to update them the way that they used to, but it is still a pretty physical process to figure out what taxes are due and owing if a property is delinquent.

6 MINS LATER

16:26
Nora, to the extent that public confidence in the system has been shaken a bit, as we look forward, what do you think needs to happen for property owners and other professionals to regain confidence in the system?
5:21
okay can you walk us through what happens once an appeal is filed how is evidence reviewed how long does this take
5:29
again it depends so um let's say will county uh they they mail everything out at once Everything that's being reassessed, all the townships are mailed at once.
5:40
And then the filing deadline is 30 days later.
5:43
So the filing deadline for the entire county is 30 days later.
5:47
And then the appeals happen over the course of two or three months.
5:50
And then they send out results like one or two months after that.
5:53
So we're expecting to have results out of Will County in December or January, I would think.

6 MINS LATER

11:57
The criteria that the boards look at generally isn't something that's common knowledge or isn't out there, but how transparent is the actual decision-making process? Is the board clear as far as why an appeal was granted or denied?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.