Skip to main content
Nicole Hemmer

Nicole Hemmer

Historian

Nov 17, 2026

6:25
So if you are like us and you're in your 40s or your child of the 80s, you know, something like home ownership and stable employment is something that's much more of a challenge.
6:37
And that idea of a K-shaped economy is really important because it's around this time.
6:42
Actually, it was probably a little sooner than this when people started talking about the new Gilded Age.
6:47
And that's such an apt historical analogy because there was this period in U.S. history when you're having the first multimillionaires and you have these robber barons who are just obtaining so much wealth.
7:01
And that wealth is not trickling down.
7:04
It requires massive regulation in order to begin to close the gap between the very wealthiest and the very poorest Americans.
7:13
And it generates all of these political movements.

32 MINS LATER

39:17
You think money would be a good thing, but actually it can be so divisive in the way that people decide how to spend it.
14:10
And I think it's worth kind of trying to get our head around what life is like there in Cicero.
14:15
Cicero is one of those suburbs of Chicago.
14:18
And when we talk about housing in the 1950s, we talk about suburbs.
14:23
We talk about people moving out to the suburbs in order to have more space, in order to have some distance from the cities, and in order to set up these middle-class lives.
14:32
And in the case of the Clark family, they want to move out to Cicero in 1951 because, you know, they live in this packed tenement in the south side of Chicago.
14:44
It's a family of, I think, two parents.
14:47
and two children.

25 MINS LATER

39:31
We were brought under violence and now we've built it and made it our home and we won't be denied that identity.
29:48
But but where do you fall on it? I'm sure I'm curious.
29:52
The darker side peeks out now and then in public.
29:55
So he has a kind of viciousness toward the press that you later learn is actually being actualized into a war on certain journalists that are being investigated by the IRS and the FBI.
30:07
And he's keeping an enemies list.
30:09
That is the real Richard Nixon.
30:10
You know, he cuts loose Vice President Spiro Agnew.
30:13
to attack the liberal media and to really try to bring the fight to the press.
31:53
It's really extraordinary.
14:40
So, you know, let's paint a picture of how the North is industrializing, how World War I sort of changes the calculus there, and what that means for literally, you know, a labor demand and a supply issue.
14:52
Absolutely.
14:53
So industrialization had been ticking up throughout the last third of the 19th century.
14:58
But with World War I, something different happens.
15:03
Not only do you have all of these factories working basically 24 hours a day in order to create war material, but again, you have all of these folks who are working those factories who then get drafted and go to serve in the war.
15:15
And so there are all of these job openings.
15:18
And for Black Southerners, This is real opportunity.

10 MINS LATER

25:32
But let's paint a little bit of a picture of the rising tension in the North, really immediately, right? I mean, starting in, you know, the 19 teens, we see northern cities start to grapple with and push back against the sort of immense change that is taking place with all these newly arrived black residents.
2:01
And maybe it was a little more like, oh, no, one side's out there trying to kind of bend the rules as much as possible in a way that does offer a little bit of parallel to what we saw on January 6th.
2:10
Stress test is absolutely right.
2:11
And so, too, I mean, one of the things that's so fascinating about talking about the 2000 election is you start to see more of the seams of politics.
2:21
And by that, I mean, you know, I think that there is this common understanding of elections.
2:27
Let's table the past 10 years.
2:29
Well, let's say like most Americans, as we were growing up, thought of elections as like there's ballot counting.
2:34
There are these election officials that count them all up and they tally them and they give them to news services and news services put them on the radio or the television.

21 MINS LATER

23:56
And so I don't know.
2:24
But Nikki, you want to drop us back into the height of Bush v. Gore? What are your favorite little wrinkles of memory from that time?
2:33
I have a lot of them.
2:34
I teach Bush v. Gore in every class that I can because I feel like it's been a little too memory hold.
2:39
Or actually, I think that there has been an effort to legitimize it from across the political spectrum by pretending it wasn't as bad as what it actually was, because then we'd have to wrestle with the illegitimacy of that election.
2:52
And one of the moments that I like to point out, because it prefigures some of our contemporary politics, is this moment in late November, so November 22nd, We're a couple weeks out of the election, and there's a recount happening in Miami-Dade.
3:09
where they're trying to figure out what exactly was the vote in Miami-Dade, because we don't know, because we have all of these sort of like weird ballots that we have to decipher and decisions that we have to make about how these votes are calculated and counted.
3:22
And so there's a lot of media attention and a lot of pushback on this because Republicans are really afraid that it's going to increase the total for Al Gore and it will challenge the election that was called for George W. Bush by one one of his campaign managers, who was also the Secretary of State.

15 MINS LATER

18:45
What is your sense of kind of the lane that he occupies when he first enters the House as a representative in the late 70s? This is just after Watergate, right? Is he part of a wave or something?
15:59
Because he runs a business in such a large, successful business, I think he sees himself as saying, well, I could run the country and run it like a business, then everybody could win.
16:09
Yeah, this idea of running the country like a business as a selling point, Perot isn't the first person to use that, but you can see just how much it resonates in the support around the Perot campaign.
16:20
Now, remember, it's 1992, so the country is in a deep recession.
16:24
People are unhappy.
16:26
The Cold War has ended.
16:27
There's no sort of like uniting purpose for everyone.
16:30
It's just kind of like a crappy season.

14 MINS LATER

30:34
mickey before we move on kind of from the other candidates i mean tell us a little bit about how buchanan plays into all of this and uh sort of whether there were were there were there buchanan perot voters
9:29
Can you talk about that?
9:31
Right, to recapture the magic of past moments of glory.
9:34
And those past moments of glory have been so connected with misogyny.
9:39
They've been so anti-woman.
9:41
And that coalition has been just drenched in misogyny as a way of inspiring and bringing that out.
9:49
But I do think that there is something – In some ways, you can see Trump's response to the Ramaswamy ad.
9:58
It's almost like a take two on the response to the Access Hollywood tape, like, gosh, 10 years ago now.

8 MINS LATER

18:22
Can you talk a little about that sort of the lapsing of the 2024 cultural moment?
11:22
Can you talk about that?
11:23
Right, to recapture the magic of past moments of glory.
11:27
And those past moments of glory have been so connected with misogyny.
11:32
They've been so anti-woman.
11:34
And that coalition has been just drenched in misogyny as a way of inspiring and bringing that out.
11:42
But I do think that there is something – in some ways you can see Trump's response to the Ramaswamy ad.
11:51
It's almost like a take two on the response to the Access Hollywood tape, like eight, gosh, 10 years ago now.

8 MINS LATER

20:15
Can you talk a little about that sort of the lapsing of the 2024 cultural moment?
8:26
So this is so interesting
8:27
because Sacagawea is the indigenous guide who sort of helps Lewis and Clark over the course of their travels.
8:34
In 1919 in Charlottesville, Virginia, there's a statue that goes up that honors Meriwether Lewis and William Clark and Sacagawea.
8:45
But it's really about Lewis because Lewis was born in Albemarle County, which is where Charlottesville is.
8:51
And so what it ends up being is this statue with Lewis and Clark, these two strapping white men, like standing large.
8:57
And Sacagawea is like crouched behind them, almost hiding.
9:02
We can talk later about what happens to that statue.

6 MINS LATER

14:36
I feel like is when it really, really starts to take off for a number of reasons.
23:27
this? All by water?
23:29
Yeah.
23:30
You're going to run out of water soon.
23:34
But they get horses that allow them to cross different mountain passes.
23:37
They get more food to try to keep them from starving to death.
23:41
And so you begin to get the sense.
23:43
Even though all of these tribes would have encountered white settlers and explorers before, they're still seen as not an existential threat.

19 MINS LATER

43:04
And and I think that he he took that really hard.
4:42
But can you walk us through, just sort of remind us what those years leading up to the Louisiana Purchase and this just incredible, effectively overnight expansion of the U.S. territory?
4:51
Sure.
4:51
So all of these things are connected.
4:53
The Northwest Ordinance, which is established in 1787 under the Articles of the Confederacy, is bringing in what was at the time the Far West, places that would become Ohio, Indiana, Illinois.
5:04
And as I mentioned earlier, they banned slavery forever.
5:07
in those territories.
5:08
But what they also did was they established that new territories would not become colonies of the United States, but they would eventually be granted full equal citizenship as states.

23 MINS LATER

28:44
Of
14:45
But going back to this, what was the contract for America and who was behind it? And do you think it had the impact on the election that a lot of people say it had?
14:58
So the Contract for America was kind of a policy agenda.
15:01
It was almost like a party platform, but in a non-presidential year.
15:07
So it was a list of policy items that the Republicans pledged to pursue in their first year in office if they won the majority in the House.
15:17
And the agenda items that they put on there, Newt Gingrich was one of the people who was responsible for this, but so was a man named Frank Luntz.
15:25
Frank Luntz was a pollster who had worked for the Perot campaign and had been would end up being sanctioned by all of the national polling organizations because they're pretty sure he kind of made up a lot of the numbers.
15:38
But he like tested language and he tested people's responses to the way different policies were phrased.

19 MINS LATER

35:00
But
9:00
Was he representing us a kind of through line of violence and abolition that we don't really acknowledge as much as we should?
9:07
Absolutely.
9:07
I mean, I think that we really mischaracterize abolitionism as we think about it as a nonviolent movement.
9:13
There certainly were people who were opposed to the use of violence.
9:16
And there were people like Frederick Douglass who did not want anyone joining with John Brown because they thought that everyone was just going to get themselves killed, which point to Frederick Douglass.
9:26
Right.
9:26
But the use of violence as a political tool for abolitionists, particularly Black abolitionists, was something that had a decades-long tradition at this point because they fundamentally understood that slavery was a violent system.
14:24
And so I'm wondering if you have, you know, if you have thoughts about kind of how John Brown has been seen through the years and how that has reflected different ideas about slavery and abolition and so forth.
20:43
[gentle music]
20:50
Have you ever had the urge to sneak behind the cordoned-off areas of a museum or roam the halls after closing time? The Smithsonian's flagship podcast, Side Door, will sneak you behind the scenes of the world's largest museum and research complex.
21:07
Come learn about the ghosts that supposedly walk the museum halls after dark, how a train robbery gave rise to criminal forensics, why leeches are actually the coolest thing ever, and how to get away with murder in the Arctic, maybe.
21:21
You'll discover stories of history, science, art, and culture you won't find in a display case.
21:27
You can listen to Side Door wherever you get your podcasts, or find us online at si.edu/sidedoor.
21:34
[gentle music]
25:21
Mm-hmm
25:21
... because of the war.
18:42
Oh, absolutely.
18:43
And the Elijah Lovejoy moment also shows us that violence is going to be stalking the abolitionist movement for the entirety of its existence.
18:52
And that's something that I think John Brown gets right away.
18:57
He has this very religious declaration that Kelly mentioned of consecrating his life.
19:01
And as early as 1848, he's thinking of ways to try to incite an insurrection against slavery.
19:09
Because during that period, during the 1940s and the 1950s, as the country expands to the West, the question of slavery is just constantly on the table.
19:19
Territorial expansion keeps the question of slavery front and center because then you have to decide, does slavery go with the country? When you bring in a new territory, is it a free territory or a slave territory? And Kansas is going to be the site where the violence around that question plays out in very concentrated ways that make it clear that this question is never going to be settled politically.

12 MINS LATER

31:51
Iconic.
5:58
[upbeat music]
5:58
[upbeat music]This show is supported by Odoo.
6:03
When you buy business software from lots of vendors, the costs add up, and it gets complicated and confusing.
6:09
Odoo solves this.
6:11
It's a single company that sells a suite of enterprise apps that handles everything from accounting to inventory to sales.
6:17
Odoo is all connected on a single platform in a simple and affordable way.
6:22
You can save money without missing out on the features you need.

23 MINS LATER

29:28
Yeah
4:01
So it's just this just brilliant guide to watching a proto-Trump kind of create the mess that we're in right now.
4:10
Yeah, and that idea of a proto-Trump, it raises some questions to me about your question, Carlos, which is Cohn's influence on Trump.
4:17
And I think it's hard to say how much of the similarities between the two men is because Trump was the protege of Cohn or just that they're the same kind of political archetype.
4:32
that they came up in the same milieu in a lot of ways.
4:36
They were surrounded by amoral people and criminals who were making tons of money, and they are sort of walking in the same footsteps.
4:46
And so because this is a biography of Cohen and not of Trump, we don't know all of the other influences on Trump that also helped to shape him into this particular type of person.
4:58
And I think the other challenge with tracing the influence question is, I don't know if you noticed this, but in the sections where Cohn is talking about his influence on Trump and Trump is talking about his relationship with Cohn, you're just sitting there like this is like an unreliable narrator dance-off.

26 MINS LATER

31:08
And once one person does that, it's easier for others to do it as well.
24:13
Yeah.
24:14
Yeah.
24:14
I mean, there is this you have to have that sort of like anti-system philosophy in order to reject and break free of the traditions and the norms and the rules of the culture that you grew up in.
24:29
And then for a lot of folks at Woodstock and in communes and other places, they were choosing a communitarian lifestyle.
24:38
Right.
24:38
Like I individually am going to opt out of the culture I grew up in and I'm going to choose this this life, but with other people.
24:48
Right.

7 MINS LATER

31:55
I mean, Bad Bunny's whole performance was this global, political, like... like everyone had a take on same with Kendrick Lamar's the year before and every other person that is I feel like performed there's been some sort of critique or analysis or conversation about like you know what are they saying and who are they speaking to what are the symbols and like you know like all of that that's that's not necessarily every concert but or every halftime show but I do think that there's an expectation that who performs Tells us a lot about the space that we're in right now.
11:07
This was the period of WikiLeaks and Edward Snowden How serious was it for the image of the United States in the world that Barack Obama appeared unable to deal with these issues and change the way that the United States was approaching them?
11:25
Well, it was certainly the case that all of that promise that had been vested in Obama didn't seem to be delivering once you got several years into his presidency.
11:34
And that was true globally, but it was also true in the United States that there had been an anti-war left and an anti-war on terror liberal and left.
11:44
and to a certain extent a libertarian right that had hoped that barack obama would be able not to just rationalize the war on terror but to actually roll it back and what they found instead was that those appeals that barack obama had made to international law and to domestic law was his very lawyerly way of understanding the way the war on terror should work.
12:06
And so then some things like torture, which were outside of the conventions of international law, he wanted to do away with.
12:11
But then otherwise, he was helping to use the law in order to prosecute the war on terror.
12:18
And that was using the law as a way of figuring out how to escalate drone strikes abroad.

7 MINS LATER

19:16
When did it start to change into this more insurgent party?
38:39
[laughs]
38:40
... how particularly like the, the broad use of peptides in recent years has been a kind of a eugenics adjacent kind of movement, um, because it is focused so much on that idea of optimization and maximizing your genetic potential, which is often it's understood as like, um, you know, the, what is it? The gene set that load the, uh, uh, load the gun and the environment pulls the trigger.
39:05
Um, that you can actually do quite a lot, um, with that, uh, with that genetic environment that you can maximize.
39:13
But what are they maximizing for? Right? Bryan Johnson is maximizing for longevity, which I think there are some interesting, um, big moral and existential questions with.
39:23
But what most people are doing it for is because they want to be thinner, they want to have better hair, they wanna have better jawlines, they wanna build muscle more quickly.
39:33
Um, that it is, um, about trying to approach this culturally constructed idea of what the ideal hu- human form looks like and what ideal human optimization looks like.
39:45
And so I think that it's, it's related to genetics, but I also think it's related to, um, people trying to figure out how to maximize their advantage in an economic system that no longer works for them.
42:04
And all that's kinda absent from Gattaca in a way that I find really interesting.
3:38
He just thinks of himself as sort of naming the natural state of things.
3:42
Oh, absolutely.
3:43
Absolutely.
3:45
And his views are widely shared in a lot of the United States.
3:48
And in fact, I would say that this would have been the sort of mainstream white opinion in the 19th century and not just for people who believed in supported slavery.
3:59
But there is this kind of.
4:02
view of the world, that the world has been separated into races, to four or five different races.

6 MINS LATER

9:50
turning point for
17:37
Do you feel that way?
17:39
I do to a certain extent.
17:41
Um, certainly there has been a growing frustration among Republicans and even within parts of the base, um, when it comes to Donald Trump.
17:49
To the extent that he has lame-ducked himself, fantastic term, um, to the extent to which he's lame-ducked himself, um, it is by, by his own making, right? It, it's not just that he goes off and says crazy things.
18:03
He started the war in Iran, which sent gas prices and inflation through the roof.
18:08
Um, it was a deeply unpopular war.
18:10
He never tried to garner any public support for it, and he knew it was an issue that would fracture his base because he was supposed to be the no new wars president.
20:21
[laughs] Yeah
16:34
Do you feel that way?
16:36
I do to a certain extent.
16:37
Um, certainly there has been a growing frustration among Republicans and even within parts of the base, um, when it comes to Donald Trump.
16:46
To the extent that he has lame-ducked himself, fantastic term, um, to the extent to which he's lame-ducked himself, um, it is by, by his own making, right? It, it's not just that he goes off and says crazy things.
16:59
He started the war in Iran, which sent gas prices and inflation through the roof.
17:04
Um, it was a deeply unpopular war.
17:06
He never tried to garner any public support for it, and he knew it was an issue that would fracture his base, because he was supposed to be the no new wars president.
19:18
[laughs] Yeah
21:12
Supreme Court.
21:15
I think it has been...
21:17
Look, the Supreme Court has not been a great force in our politics over the past, certainly the past 30 years.
21:24
And why has it become so bad? Well, there was the Warren Court, which was the only progressive Supreme Court that we've ever had.
21:32
And Richard Nixon hated it, as did his supporters.
21:36
They wanted to change the court.
21:37
And the problem was there were all these liberals on the court.
24:51
High school debate where you go nuclear, right? Straight back into it.

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.