Skip to main content

Mia McAfee

Mia McHaffey is an Indianapolis-based paralegal who served on the jury in the Delphi murders trial of Richard Allen and later discussed her experience publicly, including in Murder Sheet podcast interviews.

Oct 7, 2026

21:37
It is the best way to support the show.
21:39
Absolutely.
21:40
It's not as much of doing anything with juries or jury related, but that, that is truly my passion and what I would like to do in the future.
21:50
And I would really, really a goal of mine would be to use this experience to do anything I can to help others, whether it be a defendant, a juror, a prosecutor, defense, a judge.
22:08
You know, I'm, I'm wanting to spread the wealth.
22:11
[laughs] Um, but, but yeah, I, I don't, I...
22:15
It's pretty just, you know, day-to-day boring law stuff, um, with what I do now.

6 MINS LATER

28:25
Oh my gosh, yeah.
speaker_6GUEST
31:44
And if you look at all of that, logically, it could not be anybody else.
31:50
So I wanted to also say, you know, I know that I was being facetious with the Puff the Magic Dragon thing, but again, from a perspective of a juror, and back when juror number one was saying how she felt about the prosecution versus the defense, the defense, picturing that we don't see, you know, the, the pretrial conferences, the, the arguments at the beginning and the rulings.
32:17
We don't know what it's even about.
32:20
So when we're hearing them trying to throw in these random scenarios like the F tree, and we have no idea what they could be talking about, like from our perspective, it's really, it's really like, one, you know, objection.
32:35
And it, it feels like they're not following the rules, so it felt a little unprofessional from that perspective.
32:42
But just in the sense of, you know, I do understand that that's the defense's job, to come up with anything they possibly can to cause doubt.
32:56
My problem with it all is that if that's what you're working so hard to bring in or versus also the things that you're saying, those are your, those are your best, best arguments.

11 MINS LATER

speaker_6GUEST
44:26
Like, it doesn't, it doesn't mean anything to me, if that makes sense.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.