Skip to main content

Maura Meltzer-Cohen

Moira "Mo" Meltzer-Cohen is a New York City criminal defense attorney, abolitionist, and National Lawyers Guild movement lawyer known for defending activists and political prisoners.

Jul 3, 2026

OliveHOST
3:40
But my question to start for Mo, Garrett, Miriam, if you have an answer, can we just talk a little bit about why a conspiracy case like this is really significant in a movement context or just any context? What do charges like this mean for defendants' lives?
3:56
So the thing that is attractive to prosecutors about conspiracy charges is that a conspiracy, to prove a conspiracy, you have to demonstrate that two or more people made an agreement to do something that would constitute an unlawful act.
4:16
And that after making that agreement, they took steps in an effort to carry out that agreement to do something illegal.
4:23
Well, what constitutes an agreement, right? And what constitutes the kind of substantial steps that someone might take in the service of carrying out such an agreement? This is a very broad category of behavior, and it captures a huge amount of conduct that otherwise we might think of as clearly First Amendment protected conduct, like assembly or speech, expressive conduct, right? Well, what a conspiracy charge enables prosecutors to do is to criminalize whole communities of people and to criminalize behaviors that are not only lawful behaviors, but constitutionally protected behaviors.
5:10
And when I say criminalize, what I mean is to treat those communities or to treat those behaviors as though they are crimes, whether or not on their own they actually are.
5:23
And so by saying, well, this group of people made an agreement to do something illegal, prosecutors are able to capture a very large number of people who have not, in fact, carried out any criminal conduct.
5:40
And of course, this is significant in a movement context for the same reason it's significant in any other community where we see the widespread use of conspiracy charges.

16 MINS LATER

MiriamHOST
22:01
behavior.
OliveGUEST
3:30
But my question to start for Mo, Garrett, Miriam, if you have an answer, can we just talk a little bit about why a conspiracy case like this is really significant in a movement context or just any context? What do charges like this mean for defendants' lives?
3:45
So the thing that is attractive to prosecutors about conspiracy charges is that a conspiracy, to prove a conspiracy, you have to demonstrate that two or more people made an agreement to do something that would constitute an unlawful act.
4:05
And that after making that agreement, they took steps in an effort to carry out that agreement to do something illegal.
4:12
Well, what constitutes an agreement, right? And what constitutes the kind of substantial steps that someone might take in the service of carrying out such an agreement? This is a very broad category of behavior, and it captures a huge amount of conduct that otherwise we might think of as clearly First Amendment protected conduct, like assembly or speech, expressive conduct, right? Well, what a conspiracy charge enables prosecutors to do is to criminalize whole communities of people and to criminalize behaviors that are not only lawful behaviors, but constitutionally protected behaviors.
4:59
And when I say criminalize, what I mean is to treat those communities or to treat those behaviors as though they are crimes, whether or not on their own they actually are.
5:12
And so by saying, well, this group of people made an agreement to do something illegal, prosecutors are able to capture a very large number of people who have not, in fact, carried out any criminal conduct.
5:29
And of course, this is significant in a movement context for the same reason it's significant in any other community where we see the widespread use of conspiracy charges.

16 MINS LATER

MiriamHOST
21:50
is observing your behavior.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.