Skip to main content

Matthew Asma

Crown counsel in Ontario's Crown Law Office–Criminal (Ministry of the Attorney General), arguing criminal appeals before the Supreme Court of Canada.

Oct 9, 2026

speaker_10PANELIST
125:55
Matthew As- Asma.
126:01
Yes, good afternoon.
126:02
Thank you.
126:03
Uh, I want to make a submission about how the court should understand the manpower to search incidental to a detention and the standalone safety search first described in McDonald as being two different common law powers.
126:17
Uh, and yet you should also conclude that both of them are available to police on a reasonable suspicion.
126:24
Um, they're different powers.
126:25
We knew this for three reasons.
127:17
Let me ask you, is, is there not overlap when you're talking about imminent threat of a firearm because possession of a firearm is usually or often, uh, evidence of a, of an offense?
speaker_0NARRATOR
125:55
Matthew As-Asma.
126:01
Yes.
126:01
Good afternoon.
126:02
Thank you.
126:03
Uh, I wanna make a submission about how the court should understand the manpower to search incidental to a detention and the standalone safety search first described in McDonald as being two different common law powers.
126:17
Uh, and yet you should also conclude that both of them are available to police on a reasonable suspicion.
126:24
Um, they're different powers.
KarakatsanisUNKNOWN
127:17
-may I ask you, is, is there not overlap when you're talking about imminent threat of a firearm because possession of a firearm is usually or often, uh, evidence of a-- of an offense?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.