Skip to main content
Matt Ball

Matt Ball

PR & Advocacy Manager at the New Zealand Property Investors Federation (NZPIF) and regular property market commentator on Newstalk ZB.

Nov 19, 2026

0:15
Pat Cummins is a liar though, isn't he? Isn't he, Matt? Yeah.
0:19
Look, I don't know.
0:20
I mean, this is just sport.
0:21
It's not life and death.
0:22
Oh, how can you say that? But look, I think Bancroft, you've got to feel for that guy.
0:29
He seems to be the fall guy in all of this.
0:31
I have no idea what really happened.
2:24
Listen, was there any point, Matt, do you think, to this court ruling on the pay equity? I feel like it told us everything we already know.
0:28
This is just more of the same trend, isn't it?
0:33
It's more of the same trend, but I think the thing most people don't grasp with this is it's much worse than these headline numbers show.
0:41
So these numbers are just the gross sale price versus sale price, right? If you look at the inflation adjusted price, and also take into account the costs that are involved in owning a house, it is way worse than this.
0:54
Many more people are selling at a loss.
0:56
Can I give you an example? Please do.
0:59
I looked up a random house in my neighbourhood that sold recently.
1:03
It was bought in 2019 for $1.6 million.
3:03
What about if someone comes to you and says, I want to buy a rental property, I actually want to get into investing as a landlord, where should they go in New Zealand at the moment? Where's the hot places?
27:03
This is just more of the same trend, isn't it?
27:07
It's more of the same trend, but I think the thing most people don't grasp with this is it's much worse than these headline numbers show.
27:16
So these numbers are just the gross sale price versus sale price, right? If you look at the inflation adjusted price, and also take into account the costs that are involved in owning a house, it is way worse than this.
27:29
Many more people are selling at a loss.
27:30
Can I give you an example? Please do.
27:34
I looked up a random house in my neighborhood that sold recently.
27:38
It was bought in 2019 for $1.6 million.
29:36
What about if someone comes to you and says, I want to buy a rental property, I actually want to get into investing as a landlord, where should they go in New Zealand at the moment? Where's the hot places?
1:03
That's just my read on it.
1:04
Yeah, maybe.
1:04
I think she probably had a hard time from the electorate as well, which, I mean, you'd expect there's always people out there who are not going to like National.
1:10
I mean, if you look at it economically, National's not really that right wing.
1:14
They're certainly not as right as ACT.
1:17
And the handbrake is New Zealand First, who are holding them back and wanting to spend all the money on buying the BNZ and all that other stuff.
1:24
And socially, I was curious about this.

5 MINS LATER

6:42
He should probably go now.
3:33
Do you agree, though, Matt, that this is, with Winston, that this is one of the worst campaigns ever?
3:37
No, I don't.
3:38
You don't think so? No, Winston stands in front of a hall of 500 people who love him and says, raise your hands if you agree with me, and they all do.
3:44
Well, whoop-dee-doo, that's a surprise.
3:47
I actually think this is a really interesting campaign.
3:49
So we've got opportunity that's just come out from nowhere.
3:52
First party potentially to make it in without getting an MP or an electorate seat.
5:44
And if you put it up another 25 bips, it's going to hurt.
0:25
So does this work, this kind
0:27
of thing? Look, it's quite a niche scheme, but it is a good idea.
0:33
It's a new idea.
0:33
So part of the other scheme was the 5% deposits.
0:36
That's exactly the same as national scheme to encourage people into new homes.
0:40
The rent-to-buy is a new idea.
0:42
It's quite a good one, but it's quite niche is the criticism I would have of it, that it's just state tenants, not all working renters.
1:34
Do you risk sort of a negative equity situation when you start offering these incentives? It's happened a little bit in Australia.
11:50
Thanks for
11:51
having me on.
11:51
So does this work, this kind of thing? Look, it's quite a niche scheme, but it is a good idea.
11:59
It's a new idea.
11:59
So part of the other scheme was the 5% deposits.
12:02
That's exactly the same as national scheme to encourage people into new homes.
12:06
The rent-to-buy is a new idea.
13:06
Yeah.
1:38
toxic behaviour.
1:40
And we actually need to start protecting our MPs because this is an attack on our democracy.
1:45
It's an attack on us.
1:47
And I think what we've got to do is try and hit it where it starts.
1:50
Social media is a problem.
1:51
I agree with that last interviewee.
1:54
Let's actually do something about it.

6 MINS LATER

7:46
And writing people off as failures, half of them, Doesn't seem to me to be a sensible way of going about that.
54:44
not at all.
54:45
This is toxic behaviour.
54:47
And we actually need to start protecting our MPs because this is an attack on our democracy.
54:52
It's an attack on us.
54:53
And I think what we've got to do is try and hit it where it starts.
54:56
Social media is a problem.

7 MINS LATER

62:12
it'll buy the power in the middle of the night and then I can use it when I need it during the day.
speaker_3NARRATOR
1:53
You're going to
1:54
suffer, right? You've got commercial rates and residential rates.
1:58
That's going to be bad.
1:59
What do they do? Well, I mean, some of the ideas that Ben...
2:05
floated around like putting the debt on the government's books.
2:08
Yes, that might be fair enough.
2:09
They're going to come begging to government for money and we're not going to want
2:19
Hey, Matt, where do you sit on the billionaires debate?
2:23
Well, I've had the benefit of 24 hours to think about this.
2:28
Actually, I'm not going to say billionaires are great.
2:31
What I'm going to say is that don't put people into groups and then call those groups bad or good or whatever.
2:38
We know where that sort of thing goes.
2:39
So some people are good, some people are bad, some billionaires are good, some are bad, and we should celebrate success.
2:45
Your Rocket Labs, your Holters, the guy from Grinding Gears Games, they are awesome.

6 MINS LATER

8:47
No, I don't think it is growing the
4:11
Matt, I don't think this is the outcome that we want in Wellington City Council, do we? Them being charged over the sewage leak.
4:18
No, we don't want this.
4:19
Look, I did the numbers.
4:21
If they're successful, if they get their $10 million per case, it's $100 million.
4:25
Yes.
4:26
Across 83,000 ratepayers, that's $1,200 each.
4:30
There will be pitchforks in the street if that happens.
8:38
What do you think, Matt? That's right.
33:39
So does not changing something change something? Actually,
33:42
yes, it really does.
33:44
It's a huge relief for rental owners and for renters.
33:47
This is a terrible tax because it's a straight hit to the bottom line.
33:51
So the consequences pass straight through to the tenant.
33:54
Higher rent, less maintenance, less investment in their properties and eventually fewer rentals.
33:59
So every renter in New Zealand should breathe a sigh of relief about this change.
34:11
Do you reckon Labour's worked that out or do you reckon they're in trouble in the election so this is political and does it matter?
0:45
It's
0:45
a huge relief for rental owners and for renters.
0:49
This is a terrible tax because it's a straight hit to the bottom line.
0:52
So the consequences pass straight through to the tenant.
0:55
Higher rent, less maintenance, less investment in their properties and eventually fewer rentals.
1:01
So every renter in New Zealand should breathe a sigh of relief about this change.
1:05
They are more secure in their home, rents won't skyrocket, and landlords can now get on and invest and improve their property.
1:12
Do you reckon Labour's worked that out, or do you reckon they're in trouble in the election, so this is political, and does it matter?
0:45
It's
0:45
a huge relief for rental owners and for renters.
0:49
This is a terrible tax because it's a straight hit to the bottom line.
0:52
So the consequences pass straight through to the tenant.
0:55
Higher rent, less maintenance, less investment in their properties and eventually fewer rentals.
1:01
So every renter in New Zealand should breathe a sigh of relief about this change.
1:05
They are more secure in their home, rents won't skyrocket, and landlords can now get on and invest and improve their property.
1:12
Do you reckon Labour's worked that out, or do you reckon they're in trouble in the election so this is political, and does it matter?
14:55
How does that compare to other countries in the OECD as capital gain rate? Do you converse with what happens overseas?
15:04
Yeah, Australia had a 30% capital gains tax.
15:09
It's a slightly higher rate, but they have one thing that makes their one much better than ours.
15:15
They index for inflation.
15:17
And that's the key element that's missing from Labour's tax.
15:25
The unfortunate thing is they can't index for inflation because they won't raise any money from it.
15:29
And they've promised to spend the money already.

23 MINS LATER

38:32
Look, just on that one,
0:32
What has this got to do with the capital gains? OK, so the
0:37
data here is pretty good, but it doesn't tell the whole picture.
0:41
Totalities data looks at a sale 10 years ago and then a sale today and compares the two and you get the nominal profit or loss.
0:48
It doesn't take into account the cost of owning a property, your upgrade costs and all of that sort of thing.
0:53
But most importantly, it doesn't take into account inflation.
0:57
And inflation over the last 10 years is about 39%.
1:02
So it's probably worth putting some numbers on this.
2:52
Have you heard of anyone lately who's been trying to sell their rental property? How is it out there? It is
11:12
What has this got to do with the capital gains?
11:15
Okay, so the data here is pretty good, but it doesn't tell the whole picture.
11:20
Totalities data looks at a sale 10 years ago and then a sale today and compares the two and you get the nominal profit or loss.
11:28
It doesn't take into account the cost of owning a property, your upgrade costs and all of that sort of thing.
11:33
But most importantly, it doesn't take into account inflation.
11:37
And inflation over the last 10 years is about 39%.
11:42
So it's probably worth putting some numbers on this.
13:32
Have you heard of anyone lately who's been trying to sell their rental property? How is it out there?
39:54
They were all about it, yeah
39:54
...
39:54
they noticed me, and they, you know.
39:57
So security did tell me to, you know, sit down, tr- you know, quieten down and stuff several times.
40:03
And then finally they come and said, "Look, we're gonna...
40:05
It's not us.
40:06
You, and you're not doing anything.

18 MINS LATER

57:55
Do they really?
40:15
what's causing the change?
40:18
I think in this case it's really a supply and demand thing.
40:21
So demand has slackened off a bit as our migration numbers have dropped out, but also supply.
40:29
So actions that the previous government, the Labour government under Phil Twyford, took to increase the ability, the planning ability to build more houses and then this government increased.
40:39
has just pulled out all the stops to try and increase housing supply to make it easier, faster, and cheaper to build houses.
40:47
And we're seeing the effect of that.
40:48
So if you
41:33
a passing statistic or something that will stick?
0:46
And what's causing the change?
0:49
I think in this case, it's really a supply and demand thing.
0:53
So demand has slackened off a bit as our migration numbers have dropped out, but also supply.
1:00
So actions that the previous government, the Labour government under Phil Twyford, took to increase the ability, the planning ability to build more houses, and then this government has just pulled out all the stops to try and increase housing supply to make it easier, faster, and cheaper to build houses.
1:17
And we're seeing the effect of that.
1:19
So if you have more supply, I mean, you know.
2:04
this a passing statistic or something that will stick?
2:08
I don't think it's a passing statistic.
15:06
And so, Matt, again, why did the Property Investors Federation commission the report? What was the trigger?
15:14
A two-part trigger, if you like.
15:16
One is what you talked about, that whole description and running down of property investors, of landlords as parasites and people who don't contribute anything.
15:25
The other one was the release recently of some of the Labour Party's policy towards property investors.
15:31
And the thing that really stuck out to me from that is the use of the word unproductive.
15:36
or not a productive industry or direct money into a productive industry and speculators so in labor's mind they are thinking of us as unproductive speculators people who just buy a house like it's monopoly because we can just whip out a couple of million from our back pockets and then sit there and watch for it to increase in price i mean a bit like gold or shares or something like that and None of the public discourse captures the work, that real work that I talked about, the people in the overalls, Kevin and Duff, and all the tradies and everyone else who's hired and paid to support this industry.
16:15
So I wanted to capture that.
20:51
What's your take on that?
0:53
But add to that as well, do you not think that what is playing a role here is the expectations of an OCR lift?
1:00
Oh, absolutely.
1:01
I think that is dampening things down a wee bit, yes.
1:04
But it's still good buying conditions.
1:06
Like, if you're a first-time buyer, now's still a pretty good time to get into the market.
1:11
Also, if you're a property investor, it's never a bad time to buy.
1:15
If you do your maths, you make sure the fundamentals are right, you can get some growth out of it and get good cash flow, it's a good time to buy.
2:03
Where do you sit?
83:38
But add to that as well, do you not think that what is playing a role here is the expectations of an OCR lift?
83:45
Oh, absolutely.
83:46
I think that is dampening things down a wee bit, yes.
83:49
But it's still good buying conditions.
83:51
Like, if you're a first-time buyer, now's still a pretty good time to get into the market.
83:56
Also, if you're a property investor, it's never a bad time to buy.
83:59
If you do your maths, you make sure the fundamentals are right, you can get some growth out of it and get good cash flow, it's a good time to buy.
84:12
What about the election? How much of that is causing people to sit back a little

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.