Skip to main content

Matilda Gosling

Social scientist and author of "Teenagers: The Evidence Base" and "Evidence-Based Parenting"; independent social research consultant who wrote Sex Matters' "Criminalising conversations" report.

Oct 2, 2026

4:39
People keep trying to do it and then they fail because they end up against some really fundamental contradictions and not just the one that you point out about the difficulties with, you know, is somebody gay or are they supposedly straight because they're trans? I mean, the most obvious one to me is that there's nothing left to ban except things that we shouldn't be banning.
5:00
Yeah, so it leaves ordinary conversations and there are definitions within the bill about harm or what is perceived as being harm, but those are all very, very subjective measures.
5:11
So if you were to say, something to me that hurt my feelings.
5:15
I could say, actually, I feel severe distress on the basis of what you've just said to me.
5:19
And then that could fall under the definition of harm under the proposed legislation, which makes it very, very difficult for people to be able to speak freely because you constantly be checking yourself to work out if what you're saying could lead to a criminal conviction and it could lead to a fine and it could even lead to up to five years imprisonment.
5:40
And this is something that I think is... going to have a real impact on therapists and psychologists in a way that hasn't really been foreseen.
5:49
So theoretically under the bill, there is a healthcare exemption.

17 MINS LATER

22:58
Therapists spontaneously brought this up to you, didn't they? The issue, the impact on families and family functioning and parental authority and so on.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.