Skip to main content

Marjorie Sheriff

Mother of Chris Sheriffe, the wrongfully convicted man profiled in the Toronto Star's "Suspicion: Murder on Mount Olive" podcast, where she appears as a guest.

Apr 25, 2025

28:56
She said she'd never seen anything gang-related, not in his bedroom, not anywhere in their house, and not in the car they shared.
29:06
When I went up and testified, the jurors, they were just...
29:11
I can't get inside the minds of the jury.
29:13
It's a criminal offence in Canada for the jurors, or anyone else, to disclose jury deliberations.
29:19
I do have a theory though.

21 MINS LATER

50:41
Marjorie, his mom, thinks back to what was said about her son in the courtroom and what the newspapers reported in their brief coverage of the case.
50:52
That story that you read in the newspaper and what they come from the prosecutor, it's not my son.
50:59
It's not my son.
5:10
That night, he'd apparently been in a car accident.
5:14
By this, Lloyd Jr. was getting sick.
5:19
And they stopped him, and they asked him for his driver's license and his insurance.
5:24
He gave them both.
5:26
And then they turned to him and said, they went back to the car and went back and said, oh...
5:30
This is a bogus insurance.
5:34
Take your car.
9:31
They were in a huddle, glancing over from time to time.
21:12
They had a job for him.
21:14
When they contacted me in 2009 September, I didn't tell them that my son was in jail.
21:21
I kept telling them call back, call back.
21:23
They called me right back up until January of 2010 and I told them he wasn't in the country.
22:33
Here's Marjorie, who wrote the petition.
22:36
Christopher was never in again.
22:39
Christopher lived at home with us, his spirit.
22:41
It was my house, our house, my husband and I. I had access to Christopher's room.
34:08
They told Chris's parents their real target was a wet.
34:13
They go, you know how long we've been after him? What did you get? Where did your son friend, like, how did he become a friend of your son? Where did your son know him from? We didn't know.
34:26
That's what they said to us, and then they started talking, oh, most people get this a couple years.
35:48
Some of the barbecue guests testified they'd noticed somebody else on the street just before the shooting.
35:56
And they told the judge that Apparently, at the preliminary, one of the witnesses from the house said there was a guy standing at the corner, at the corner of Mount Olive, smoking what looked like to be marijuana.
0:18
It's been 12 years since their son was sent to prison for life.
0:22
Because if he, I could accept it if he was guilty, and then he would have had to pay.
0:29
He wouldn't have to be responsible for what he did, okay? He wouldn't have to be responsible.
0:36
But I know he's innocent.
2:10
Marjorie carefully places the photo back in the box.
2:13
It's just that sometimes I get scared what if I go push too far and I hurt him.
2:19
Like, you know what I mean? Because I still have to remember that this is not a fair country.
2:26
You know what I mean? I'm still black.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.