Skip to main content

Marie Benedict

Aug 27, 2026

0:47
Marie explained how they came up with the idea for the book.
0:51
Well, Victoria likes to describe me as our treasure hunter.
0:54
Um, I, there's nothing I love more than to be down in the rabbit hole of research.
1:00
And we had talked about looking for an unlikely duo, um, you know, two people on sort of opposite sides of, of the world coming together to effectuate great change.
1:13
And so I consulted this really long list of incredible historical women that I keep at the ready, um, women I've found over time writing a bunch of the other books that I've written, and, um, Eunice Carter had been on that list.
1:28
I was a litigator in New York City for over a decade, and I had come across her.
1:34
And then as I kinda switched from being a lawyer to being a writer, I wasn't, like, excited to revisit all the stuff that went with being a lawyer, so she kind of got, I wouldn't wanna say lost in the shuffle, but kind of I, I wasn't revisiting her.
3:43
Where did you go to find details about their lives? Um, or did you use your imagination?
18:43
I know Polly ended up writing like a memoir or biography or something because y'all sent me down the Google rabbit hole immediately.
18:51
However, how did you all find this story? First of all, thank you for highlighting that because shall I tell you that actually for a long time, our working title of the book was The Prosecutor and the Madam.
19:06
We wanted that so bad.
19:08
Thumbs it up.
19:09
But it started with, as I mentioned, like Victoria and I are interested in a particular theme.
19:13
And with this one, we really wanted to, you know, do something different and fresh for the readers.
19:18
And we live in divisive times, no matter what your belief systems are.

12 MINS LATER

31:06
but it did definitely come through but it's not just Eunice who's ambitious like Polly is also ambitious even in the
2:23
How did you come up with the idea? Who had the idea first?
2:27
Um, well Victoria likes to describe me as our treasure hunter.
2:30
Um, I, there's nothing I love more than to be down in the rabbit hole of research.
2:36
And we had talked about looking for an unlikely duo, um, you know, two people on sort of opposite sides of, of the world coming together to effectuate great change.
2:49
And so I consulted this really long list of incredible historical women that I keep at the ready, um, women I've found over time writing a bunch of the other books that I've written, and, um, Eunice Carter had been on that list.
3:04
I was a litigator in New York City for over a decade, and I had come across her.
3:10
And then as I kinda switched from being a lawyer to being a writer, I wasn't, like, excited to revisit all the stuff that went with being a lawyer.
5:19
Where did you go to find details about their lives? Um, or did you use your imagination?
9:36
[laughs]
9:37
I would kind of escape, don't tell anyone now, but I would escape to, um, the cultural institutions in New York, and the Morgan Library was one of my favorite places.
9:47
And I happened to be there one day, and if, if you don't know what it is, it's, uh, it was created by J.P. Morgan.
9:52
It houses one of the world's best collections of rare and priceless manuscripts, and it's like a time capsule.
9:57
It's like wa- It's like a time portal.
9:59
And I was there one day, and a docent happened to mention to me that a woman had helped create this collection as well.
10:06
Now, this was decades ago.

16 MINS LATER

25:56
How have you evolved or grown as writers in this partnership? Marie, I'd love to start with you.
4:36
I love it.
4:40
We really wanted to run with it.
4:42
We eventually obviously settled on a pair of vases, but it was the striking nature of this unlikely alliance that really drew us to the story.
4:52
You know, I think it all started with I was a New York City commercial litigator myself for a long time, and I came of age when there weren't that many women in the profession or not as many as there are now, certainly.
5:05
And when I first heard about Eunice Carter and I realized that she had this incredible role.
5:11
I had a sense of just how unbelievable that was, how remarkable that was, and that she had to battle not only society, but her own legal team to bring forth this case because it was based on prostitution.
5:28
And the sense at this time was that prostitution was a woman's crime that the mob wouldn't have bothered with.

6 MINS LATER

11:28
What was the glue, if I can put it that way, what was the glue in their relationship?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.