Skip to main content
Lisa Graves

Lisa Graves

Activist

Nov 21, 2026

2:09
And then how that could get up to the United States Supreme Court through appellate decisions.
2:15
Well, this is like the three stooges, Stephen Miller, Will Scharf, and Aaron Reitz.
2:19
These are all people who, in my view, shouldn't have the positions of power that they have.
2:25
And, you know, maybe with an additional ancient analogy, it's like the Keystone Cops.
2:32
These guys are making ridiculous, ludicrous claims about congressional power that are completely ignorant and deliberately so of what the Supreme Court and Congress Constitution, in essence, has said over many, many, many years about the far-ranging power of Congress to investigate and issue subpoenas and pursue its legislative powers.
2:57
And so you have Miller, who is his own in his own category of Trump loyalist, the man behind some of the worst, most inhumane policies that Trump has put forward.
3:11
And then you have Will Scharf, who is someone who was a loser in his bid for an elected position in Missouri and was snapped up as this hot commodity by the White House, the White House Counsel's Office.

8 MINS LATER

11:03
Do you think the House and Senate just ignore these things? Do you think there's going to be any federal cases filed by Congress or these committees against the executive branch that spill back, that eventually make their way to the Supreme Court? How do you see this playing out?
35:14
I'm curious what your thoughts are.
35:17
Well, I think that there's, you know, obviously people are really fed up with corruption.
35:21
It is an absolute disaster.
35:24
The corruption that has been unleashed by Trump, the corruption of Trump's incredible sort of growth in his wealth, the new revelations about Nvidia and the national security concerns there that he seemingly ignored.
35:38
There are ample things that need to be investigated.
35:42
And it's also the case that coming back in January, this Congress is going to be facing some really disastrous scenarios for the American people because that so-called big, beautiful bill, which I call the billionaire bailout bill, that bill was so cynically timed.
36:00
to postpone some of the worst effects until right after this election, the Republicans and Trump sort of conspired to front load the tax benefits for the billionaires, but to put off some of the big cuts to major social programs to January.

12 MINS LATER

48:31
People are struggling to make ends meet.
2:41
I mean, what did you make of this?
2:43
Well, you know, Stanley Woodward, who you mentioned was questioned, is, as you said, the third in command of the Justice Department.
2:49
He's the associate attorney general.
2:51
He is another former criminal defense attorney of Donald Trump.
2:54
And so he's the guy who signed off on the settlement of that IRS contract.
3:00
suit by Donald Trump, just in my view, the dirty deal to basically create this process with Todd Blanch for Trump to have this slush fund, but then they try to walk back and say they're not going to be doing payouts to January 6th defendants, etc.
3:20
But that settlement, that was Woodward.
6:32
But Trump has managed to do that as well.
3:33
And what have you sort of picked up from all of this?
3:37
Well, there's a couple of things.
3:39
One, I recall that there used to be a saying back in the day that you never should sue someone who buys ink by the barrel.
3:47
But in this instance, you have, in essence, Trump choosing the wrong defendant.
3:53
He has been at this game of trying to get big media and law firms to blink.
3:59
And a lot of them have, and certainly some have that are subject to the control or would soon be subject to the control of his major donors or financial backers, big billionaires.
4:09
But the BBC is not, it is not subject to that kind of pressure, that effort to curry favor with him because of the donors that are controlling it, like we've been seeing with CBS.
8:15
very British.
2:42
Yeah, I just
2:43
want to say I want to underscore what you said about an audience of one, because when I watched that video, it felt like it was us taxpayers paying for a video with the audience of Trump.
2:52
That's really who the audience was for that video.
2:55
And, you know, one of the things that one of the most historic things that has happened within the structure of the U.S. military was the order by President Truman to integrate the United States military in the aftermath of of World War II, where so many soldiers came home, Black soldiers who came home from, you know, risking their lives in defense of freedom and in opposition to fascism and Nazism.
3:23
And they came home to racial segregation in the United States and to attacks on their character, and even their right to be citizens.
3:33
You know, it was extraordinary.
3:34
And so in 1948, when the U.S. military was racially integrated, that was a historic moment.

6 MINS LATER

9:16
I mean, Lisa? Oops, you're, yeah.
32:37
Democrats still probably would have won, but not by these margins, not...
32:41
So basically when you look at the 15 seats that they tried to steal in that particular way, they at least so far have only taken two or three of those.
32:52
And then they lost others that were safe.
32:57
But I don't say that to undermine the importance, the enormity of turnout.
33:03
That's what made the real difference.
33:04
But the behind-the-scenes maneuvering was designed to insulate Trump from having to deal with any countering by Congress to reassess what money is spent on, how money is being misspent, to put containers and restraints on these extreme, outrageous regressive policies of Trump to investigate the rampant corruption we're seeing within the government, and then the sons of these elected officials like Trump and others, or appointed officials like Trump and others, seemingly getting very, very wealthy.
33:39
on deals, whether it's government contracts, like, you know, absurdly, one of the Trump sons has a contract for drones for the military.

17 MINS LATER

50:29
Who knows? And the fact
23:27
Take it from there.
23:28
Yeah, so this Tuesday on Election Day, the Roberts Court had ordered an oral argument in a case about St. Mary's.
23:37
It's a private school in Colorado against the state of Colorado because the state of Colorado requires grantees to sign a non-discrimination clause that they won't discriminate based on race or LGBTQ status or national origin, all the usual things.
23:51
And because of what the Roberts Court has already done to decimate and erode the suffrage of the church and state, Colorado is basically now forced to give money, taxpayer dollars, to religious schools.
24:05
That did not used to be the case.
24:06
There used to be much more restraint on that.
24:09
But because of this court, we now have a situation in which Colorado is on an equal basis giving money to public schools, private schools, religious private schools, But St. Mary's Parish in Littleton or Englewood, Colorado, it does not want to sign that agreement that it won't discriminate against the parents of preschoolers.

7 MINS LATER

30:59
Yeah.
23:04
no, it is.
23:04
I mean, it really is astounding.
23:07
And that he is the sitting president of the United States.
23:10
And the part of it that this report details involving Todd Lange, I went back and looked at the transcript.
23:16
And you can see Todd Blanch steering Ghislaine Maxwell away from talking about specific survivors, specific victims.
23:24
Each time that comes up, he says, we're not going to get into specifics.

1 HR LATER

83:25
So I guess they realized they can't lie to the court without basically getting themselves in trouble and potentially getting Rule 11 sanctions because they were really clearly lying to the court.
0:42
and the um majority with um at least at least two in descent i think all three in descent yeah uh justice jackson and um uh kagan and sotomayor in descent um they said that no uh it's okay that new hampshire is going to not accept student ids uh along with other identification in order to allow people to vote And take it from there and how they applied what this made-up fiction, this ever-changing, shifting, shape-shifting Purcell doctrine.
1:22
Yeah.
1:22
Well, so, you know, interesting, right? When the state of Louisiana wanted to change the rules mid-election this spring, mid-primary in essence, or as the primary was underway, the court ignored the Purcell Doctrine.
1:37
The Purcell Doctrine is a precedent of the United States Supreme Court that apparently only predominantly applies when it when it hurts Democrats, but does not apply when it helps Republicans.
1:49
And here's why.
1:50
In the 2022 election, federal courts had found that Alabama's map coming out of the 2020 census violated the Voting Rights Act.
1:59
But in a decision that was issued the end of January, beginning of February, 2022, this court, the Roberts Court said, no, wait, too soon, too soon to allow, too close to the election in 2022, too close to allow the map that would comply with the Voting Rights Act to go forward.

9 MINS LATER

10:54
It was very peaceful, pleasant.
5:50
Lisa, what does this mean for this election in your mind?
5:55
Well, I wrote this piece because, you know, some of these stories are out there in different forms, but they're not aggregated in a way in a, you know, in a one piece story.
6:03
And I wanted people to have this information because we are at significant risk that this court, this Roberts court, will intervene in ways that help Donald Trump, in essence, subvert this midterm election.
6:17
We've seen them already try to tilt the scales.
6:21
in favor of Trump by wrecking the Voting Rights Act, by changing the interpretation of the Voting Rights Act in the Calais case this spring that allowed some of these Southern states, these former Confederate states, to redraw their maps in some instances, even though those elections were already underway.
6:38
And to redraw those maps to basically try to give Donald Trump a majority, to retain his majority in the House despite the headwinds against him.
6:47
And so the Roberts Court basically changed the rules midstream, threw out decades of legal precedent and statutory interpretation of the Voting Rights Act in order to allow Republicans aligned with Trump to redraw their maps to try to get more seats in Texas, Louisiana, Tennessee, and other places.
8:11
What are you anticipating, Lisa Graves?
28:30
Why do you think they took that case?
28:33
Well, I'm worried every time the court takes a case, basically, because as many people No, but a lot of people don't know the Supreme Court's jurisdiction is basically entirely discretionary.
28:44
So they don't have to take that case.
28:46
They're handpicking cases for where they want to change the law or where they, in my view, want to help Donald Trump or these MAGA Republicans, which they are so aligned with.
28:56
Not 100% of the time, but a lot of the time we've seen, especially through the shadow docket over the past 20 months.
29:03
In this instance, you have the court taking up a challenge to whether the Freedom of Information Act applies to communications about the activities of what everyone calls doge, but I call dodgy, because I just refuse to concede the name to Elon Musk of this agency, non-agency set of situations, where in essence, the Trump administration is claiming it's an executive branch function, and so it can't be subject to FOIA because the White House is not subject to FOIA the way the way the agencies are.
29:37
Instead, the White House is supposed to be subject to the Presidential Records Act and other retention rules, which Donald Trump violated and ignored, which was also part of that criminal indictment in Florida that Eileen Cannon was involved in.
34:06
Oh, okay.
19:35
Is he as originalist as they say? And what does that mean?
19:39
Well, you know, originalism is something that was invented as a so-called doctrine initially as an effort to attack the Supreme Court's unanimous decision in Brown versus Board of Education.
19:51
The idea was that because there were racially segregated schools in the District of Columbia shortly after the Civil War, that therefore the 14th Amendment, which commands the equal protection of the law, could not be used as a bar on racial segregation.
20:08
That's the origin story, the true origin story of this so-called originalism.
20:13
It morphed into an attack on the right to access abortion that was orchestrated in part by the Federal Society.
20:22
When it was launched in 1982, that's the group that has been led for a couple of decades now, both inside and outside by a guy named Leonard Leo, who Donald Trump tapped in his first term to handpick the people who were going to be put on the US Supreme Court on this Roberts Court.
20:40
But Roberts was put on the actual Supreme Court over 20 years ago, in part with the help of Leonard Leo back then, before he was famous.

5 MINS LATER

26:05
Talk about the Supreme Court as that, as a political entity.
7:47
Well, it's not that he didn't do it before, but ever since the book came out, it's like they're in overdrive.
7:54
Yeah.
7:54
It's true.
7:55
It's true.
7:55
It's been, um...
7:57
I, I guess the book was well-timed, uh, although I originally pitched it back in 2022, and, um, uh, wrote it in 2024.
8:08
Uh, so now unfortunately I've been vindicated, uh, not that I had any doubt [laughs] about who John Roberts was.

56 MINS LATER

64:18
Bye.
34:04
And what, what did, what did you take from, from this lawsuit, Lisa?
34:08
Well, this is an area where I spent a lot of time about 20 years ago looking into the rules regarding national security surveillance, wi- warrantless wiretapping, uh, the a- obtaining phone, phone records and what are known as pen registers, which, um, is an old-fashioned term for what you were describing, the numbers dialed and who dialed you and how long you spoke.
34:30
And, uh, you know, basically, the people who are involved in law enforcement, the Justice Department, at the FBI, in local law enforcement, know that pen registers are available when there's an open criminal investigation based on probable cause, which there was an investigation into the crimes that happened, in my view, on January 6th, the assault on the Capitol, um, and Donald Trump's role in it.
34:52
So there was an open criminal investigation into that action, that mob attack on our Capitol, a effort to subvert the, uh, the election results, uh, have the election, uh, certified, in essence, by Congress on January 6th.
35:05
And when you have an open criminal investigation, then, uh, pen register information is available based on the standard of is it relevant? Might it be relevant to that investigation? In this instance, we know that there were numerous communications happening, um, between Trump and some of his, some of his, uh, close inner circle and members of Congress.
35:24
Some of those members of Congress actually sought pardons immediate, in the immediate aftermath of what happened on January 6th, the violence, the assaults that led to the deaths of Capitol Police, both, uh, serious and many serious injuries that day, and then subsequent, subsequent deaths.
35:38
And the threats that were being made against Mike Pence, against Nancy Pelosi, threats to their lives.

27 MINS LATER

63:14
And the, the million-dollar question is, are any of the older, older people on the court, like Justice Alito or Thomas, do you see them retiring?
2:58
That's just my own, uh, my own, uh, personal thing that I like to watch for the next, for the next term.
3:04
Yeah, I mean, I do, I do think it's interesting and, you know, they say that the right has moved so far over the middle [laughs] the middle is pretty far on the right.
3:12
But, um, but I do think, you know, she is in some ways appearing as a swing vote.
3:17
I will say I have just been so impressed with the opinions of Ketanji Brown Jackson.
3:22
I've got her photo over my shoulder over here, too, along with my other heroes, Frederick Douglass and Thurgood Marshall.
3:27
Uh, she, I just think she's brilliant, and she's willing to be very direct about what's happening.
3:33
She's not mincing words.
7:30
The gavel.
3:10
I, I, I could give it up, sorry.
3:12
Yeah.
3:12
So I couldn't, I, was, it was, you couldn't, you couldn't resist hitting that.
3:15
But, um, it w- it was a softball.
3:17
But, uh, but you know, so tort law is, is pr- before the United States became the United States, but you know, it, for the last 200-plus years, this is traditionally the province of state law.
3:27
When a company pollutes, uh, and it harms you, harms your property, you sue them in state court for the harm.
3:33
That's just the way it's been.
7:03
... then how can you say that the state is preempted by anything that's left over?
11:36
But it was
11:37
a softball.
11:37
So tort law is... before the United States became the United States, but for the last 200 plus years, this is traditionally the province of state law.
11:51
When a company pollutes and it harms you, harms your property, you sue them in state court for the harm.
11:57
That's just the way it's been.
11:59
And the federal preemption law, to sort of summarize it, to simplify it, the federal law can preempt state law, but the rule typically has been it has to be expressed.
12:11
Federal law has to say, basically, we're clearing the field or we're providing the only remedy and we have a basis under the constitutional power of the federal government to do so and to do so exclusively.

10 MINS LATER

21:52
While they were busy drinking from the water fountain in the White House or the Department of Justice, she was trying to figure out how to make her gospel law coming out of the University of Notre
0:00
Hello, everyone.
0:00
This is Lisa Graves with Unprecedented here with a brief update on what just happened this week with the U.S. Supreme Court and a really important case involving holding oil companies accountable for climate change, the climate changes that are underway.
0:16
What just happened is that Sam Alito has recused himself from the case that is about to be heard by the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday, October 5th.
0:26
Why does this matter? It means that there are eight justices left to decide this case, but it also matters because this issue of Samuel Alito not recusing from this case has been a major controversy over the course of this year, and it's one that I've worked on to help make sure people understand what's at stake.
0:43
Here's what's happening.
0:44
Sam Alito has been a longtime investor in the oil and gas industry.
5:30
What did you make of it?
5:32
Well, it was a disgraceful day for the United States Senate Judiciary Committee, helmed by Senator Grassley, who helped orchestrate this ridiculous fiasco and allowing this hearing to go forward with these obviously incorrect and false charges of perjury.
5:51
You know, senators and members of the House under the U.S. Constitution have immunity under the speech and debate clause for the things they say on the floor of Congress and in essence, the things they say in committee.
6:03
So basically, Senator Schmidt was able to defame Jack Smith without consequence in terms of, you know, being sued publicly.
6:13
for just this what would what would certainly fail the libel standard of reckless disregard for the truth, you know, failure to actually investigate what happened when Schmidt accused Smith of lying when he said that he did not go to an Atlanta Hawks game, claimed that that Smith should reconsider his his statements because he was about to commit perjury and When, in fact, Smith had never gone to an Atlanta Hawks game at that time and was actually at a Hawkeyes game, an Iowa Hawkeyes game, as has been widely reported.
6:47
And just the sheer recklessness and malice and disregard for truth shown by Smith, shown by Senator Kennedy of Louisiana, shown by the other members of that other Republican side of that committee was just grotesque.
7:03
And I will say, you know, it was stunning to hear the language used by Schmidt to call Jack Smith, someone who has served our country honorably, has served at the Justice Department, has so ably put together the case of all the evidence that genuinely shows Donald Trump's criminal activity around the insurrection and in the the documents case in Florida to to to smear him.

7 MINS LATER

14:58
And how much do you think, Lisa, this is weakening the judicial branch across the board, particularly as Trump ignores rulings from U.S. district judges, like the judge that Harry Littman wrote about, Boesberg, in Washington, D.C.? who still hasn't gotten justice or any response from them over his initial efforts to block Trump and Stephen Miller from sending a bunch of Venezuelans to that hideous prison, Secot, in El Salvador.
5:30
What did you make of it?
5:32
Well, it was a disgraceful day for the United States Senate Judiciary Committee, helmed by Senator Grassley, who helped orchestrate this ridiculous fiasco and allowing this hearing to go forward with these obviously incorrect and false charges of perjury.
5:51
You know, senators and members of the House under the U.S. Constitution have immunity under the speech and debate clause for the things they say on the floor of Congress and in essence, the things they say in committee.
6:03
So basically, Senator Schmidt was able to defame Jack Smith without consequence in terms of, you know, being sued publicly.
6:13
for just this what would what would certainly fail the libel standard of reckless disregard for the truth, you know, failure to actually investigate what happened when Schmidt accused Smith of lying when he said that he did not go to an Atlanta Hawks game, claimed that that Smith should reconsider his his statements because he was about to commit perjury and When, in fact, Smith had never gone to an Atlanta Hawks game at that time and was actually at a Hawkeyes game, an Iowa Hawkeyes game, as has been widely reported.
6:47
And just the sheer recklessness and malice and disregard for truth shown by Smith, shown by Senator Kennedy of Louisiana, shown by the other members of that other Republican side of that committee was just grotesque.
7:03
And I will say, you know, it was stunning to hear the language used by Schmidt to call Jack Smith, someone who has served our country honorably, has served at the Justice Department, has so ably put together the case of all the evidence that genuinely shows Donald Trump's criminal activity around the insurrection and in the the documents case in Florida to to to smear him.

7 MINS LATER

14:58
And how much do you think, Lisa, this is weakening the judicial branch across the board, particularly as Trump ignores rulings from U.S. district judges, like the judge that Harry Littman wrote about, Boesberg, in Washington, D.C.? who still hasn't gotten justice or any response from them over his initial efforts to block Trump and Stephen Miller from sending a bunch of Venezuelans to that hideous prison, Secot, in El Salvador.
5:01
Why don't you tell us about what this so-called document is?
5:07
Well, it really is sort of a face-saving exhibition, basically, by both Todd Blanch and Tom Tillis and John Cornyn to claim that this somehow resolves this issue is absurd.
5:26
It is the theater of the absurd because it doesn't.
5:28
It doesn't resolve it at all.
5:30
There are a number of reasons why that's so.
5:32
First of all, you have the collusive non-settlement between Trump and this Justice Department that has failed to assert all the defenses that any other case and the other cases like this were received as part of the defense of the taxpayer's money.
5:50
But you also have the plain language that Senator John Cornyn specifically pointed to just two weeks ago, which said that this agreement could not be modified unless it was modified by both parties.

25 MINS LATER

30:53
And this doesn't even begin to get at the howling of the Department of Justice, which is now a shell of what it once was.
24:28
These two senators, Cornyn and Tillis, both of whom have lost their Senate seats because of Trump, they nevertheless showed that they are not profiles in Courage, and they accepted two worthless pieces of paper as assurances that Blanche won't revive the slush fund and the IRS immunity, which he clearly will do because he'll do anything that Trump tells him to do.
24:57
Yeah, it really was not a profiling courage.
25:00
It would not make the famous book series by JFK or anyone's notion of courage.
25:07
It was really I, you know, I was certainly hopeful that they would stand firm, although I feel like my hope was in vain, given their track record.
25:18
And just to see on the basis that they folded, as you point out, these are two worthless pieces of paper.
25:23
As John Cornyn himself pointed out during the hearing, the agreement, the collusive agreement in the in the view of the court that was struck between Trump and the Justice Department, meaning Trump.
25:35
people who are not adversarial, so not a real agreement, not a real settlement, that by its own terms required both parties to sign, to amend it.

11 MINS LATER

37:00
I mean, I'm disgusted with all of them, frankly.
3:40
What did you make of today's hearings? What did you take away? What were the things that you thought were the most important?
3:45
Well, I thought the statements in opposition to Todd Blanch were really strong and really compelling and really on the mark in terms of what's happened here.
3:58
One of the things that did not come out as much yesterday is the fact that and i think this is true i don't think this is pam bonnie throwing todd blanche under the bus in fact she claimed that he's amazing but he was in fact orchestrating the release or the response to the epstein transparency act he was in charge the buck stops with him he he's failed in numerous ways and not failed from the standpoint of the act not from his you know, a superior loyalty to Donald Trump at any cost.
4:30
But he's he failed.
4:31
He failed to release all the documents that are required to be released under the act.
4:36
He failed to protect the identities of survivors, like one of the most fundamental obligations, both under the statute and other longstanding statutes to protect the victims of crimes.
4:46
He went out of his way to protect Donald Trump and his his agents did as well in terms of trying to keep information pertinent to about Donald Trump out of the public domain and also to redact the name the names of of the men who were corresponding with Jeffrey Epstein about a variety of targeting of people, of women and young girls.

5 MINS LATER

10:15
It's over.
6:22
And I was surprised no one raised that in
6:25
the hearing.
6:27
Well, there were questions around that ruling.
6:30
I think right before we went on the air, Senator Schiff was questioning him in part about those conflicts.
6:36
But it was not at the front of the hearing.
6:39
It was not in the first set of questions from the ranking member.
6:42
um to blanche and i think that that decision by that federal district court judge is so powerful so well written so accurate that it should have been the through line for all of the questions like a starting point repeating what just happened which was we've never had a federal judge refer the acting attorney general or deputy attorney general for potential sanction by the bar that he is licensed under for his or her conduct in a particular case.

23 MINS LATER

30:37
And that's what it is.
20:31
Talk about that process, and then what do you think's going to come out of that?
20:35
Well, I was proud to sign that letter that was organized by the, uh, Lawyer Connection.
20:40
Um, that, um, that letter was signed by, by the Justice Connection, pardon me.
20:45
Um, that letter was signed by more than 1,000 alums of the Just- the Justice Department, including people who served under Republican and Democratic presidents at the highest levels of the department.
20:57
And together we, um, we've come together for this letter.
21:02
Uh, we may not agree on, you know, a, a million other things, but we agree on this.
21:07
Todd Blanche is the wrong man to lead the Justice Department.

20 MINS LATER

speaker_5UNKNOWN
41:27
What?

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.