Skip to main content

Libby Cantrell

Libby Cantrill is a managing director and head of public policy at PIMCO, and a regular Bloomberg and CNBC contributor analyzing policy and political risk.

Nov 3, 2026

16:05
What do you think?
16:07
No, I think that's exactly right.
16:08
And I think we're actually very like minded just in terms of what tonight may look like.
16:13
Looking a little bit like 2006, where you saw a very big Democratic wave kind of crashing against a relatively unpopular president.
16:22
But we do think that this is where the real risk lies.
16:24
This is not at the federal level.
16:26
Yes, you might see Congress pass some sort of symbolic legislation, putting some restraints on data centers.
18:04
Where else will kind of be the tell? You know, if I'm tired at 8 or 9 or 10 or 11 p.m., Libby, and I just want to know what are my AI stocks doing tomorrow, what should I be looking at?
6:04
Did I read correctly that there's maybe six Senate seats that are potentially up for grabs now, which is that's higher than I would have thought.
6:12
Yeah.
6:12
So, of course, you know, Republicans have a better map.
6:16
They are defending, you know, more territory and kind of deep red states.
6:22
Republicans, of course, control the majority of the U.S. Senate by four seats, meaning Democrats need to win four seats in order to win back the majority.
6:30
Not only are Democrats defending some, you know, somewhat tricky Senate races like Michigan, and potentially New Hampshire and maybe Georgia.
6:39
But they then need to win four of these sort of six Senate races, as you said, that are kind of in deep, deep Trump territory.
10:21
Libby, do you have any response to that? And what's your take on whether this twist move will work?
7:48
But first, the latest regarding Iran, what you're watching, what you think investors need to be watching and how all this translates to Washington.
7:57
Yeah, well, again, nice to be with you.
7:59
I mean, I think, you know, just talking to clients, I'm over in Europe this week.
8:03
Talking to clients, I think the real question, of course, is the fact that President Trump does seem to want a ceasefire, to continue this ceasefire.
8:12
He does want an off-ramp.
8:14
I think the real question, though, for investors is...
8:17
Does that require sort of an escalation to de-escalate approach? So could we see more conflict, more bombings and what have you? Or is this going to kind of the beginning of the end? And we will see a real sort of the ceasefire hold, and we'll actually see a resolution.
11:20
So how does all this tee us up here for Reconciliation 2.0, especially at a time where we're going to have to replenish some of these missiles and munitions and other weapons coffers as well? And the numbers are pretty eye-popping that are being thrown around.
43:22
After we saw a dizzying push on the affordability front a couple of weeks ago, it's been a little quieter since.
43:29
Yeah, good afternoon, Kelly.
43:30
I think that, I mean, the president really would like to revisit those, all of the policy announcements that he made earlier this year on affordability.
43:40
That is really what the plan was going into 2026 was to just, again, really emphasize both what President Trump has done, but also what he is looking to do.
43:54
Now, of course, there is some reality setting in that The president can only do so much without the U.S. Congress in terms of some of his affordability agenda.
44:04
We've talked about it before, preventing institutional investors from buying single-family homes and what have you.
44:11
But still, he would like to at least rhetorically go back to pushing for the affordability agenda and not necessarily be mired into a government shutdown or, of course, in terms of sort of responding and playing defense to what's happening or what happened.
45:49
What's left on the president's agenda or on Republicans' agenda if they have now a few months, perhaps, and then after that, maybe divided government or gridlock, which we know that Wall Street typically enjoys?
13:03
Libby, would you like to respond to anything on the housing front that you just heard that maybe kind of changed the way you're thinking about what could come next, what happens to home prices, what happens to Fannie and Freddie? Welcome.
13:13
Yeah, thanks so much, Kelly.
13:14
Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, like the director said, I mean, we anticipated that Fannie and Freddie would likely be using their balance sheet in order to buy more.
13:26
Of course, they've already bought around $65 billion of mortgages over the past year.
13:32
So in some ways, we were expecting them to do that.
13:34
$200 billion is obviously very significant.
13:37
I think there's still some questions about over what time period.
17:25
What would you tell investors and what's your anticipation?
13:04
It's pretty good.
13:04
I loved it.
13:05
So, you know, I mean, I think the, the, the conventional wisdom, probably right, is that a short-term shutdown doesn't really matter, doesn't matter for the economy, doesn't matter for markets.
13:13
Um, I think that the, the risk to that thinking, is that this very likely looks like it could be a prolonged shutdown.
13:20
And just remember, that the last, and the only real full shutdown that we've had in the last few decades was in 2013, that lasted for 16 days.
13:29
Uh, the catalyst there was to, to, to increase the debt, the debt ceiling.
13:32
There is no such catalyst.
15:00
Hmm.
speaker_10HOST
17:19
How much is it going to be a contentious fight with Stephen Myron in those hearings tomorrow versus just paving the way? "Come on down."
17:26
Yeah, well, I think, and we've talked about this before.
17:28
I mean, the Senate confirmation process is not necessarily perfunctory.
17:33
I think the market sort of just assumes that whomever the president, any president, uh, nominates, they'll likely get confirmed, and I think for- for in most cases, that is true.
17:42
But for this particular position and this particular context, we do think that, um, any sort of Fed nominee is going to be really questioned b- by Democrats, of course, uh, but also by Republicans.
17:55
And remember that the first step towards Senate confirmation is through the Senate Banking Committee.
18:00
And, you know, that, again, might just sort of seem like a bunch of kind of mumbo process- mumbo jumbo, but it's actually very important, because, uh, assuming no Democrats vote for, uh, say Chairm- Chairman Myron for- for a Fed governor, that means that he cannot lose even one Republican vote in order to advance to the- the full senate floor.
speaker_10HOST
18:47
Are you expecting us to actually shut down again? I mean, is this actually a worry that we have to focus on?
2:03
Here's Libby Cantrill on the moment.
2:05
This is in many ways self-defeating for the president, because, of course, not only does this potentially not have the impact on the yield curve that he wants to see, uh, and mortgage rates and what have you, but it also makes the confirmation of any future nominee that much more difficult.
2:23
Right.
2:23
Remember that in order to get confirmed, a nominee needs 50 votes in the Senate, Republicans right now have 53.
2:30
However, this is something that you all appreciate this nuance, but lots of financial press do not.
2:35
Uh, the Senate Banking Committee, which is the first step to confirmation, any nominee cannot lose one Republican, assuming Democrats vote against that- that person.
2:45
So, that means that- that by doing this, the president has focused attention on that confirmation process, and in my view, makes it a lot more difficult for him to get anybody who has any whiff of partisanship or any whiff of, you know, being, um, able to be influenced by the president in terms of monetary policy.
3:49
Right.
3:49
Remember that in order to get confirmed, a nominee needs 50 votes in the Senate.
3:54
Republicans right now have 53.
3:56
However, this is something that you all appreciate this nuance, but lots of financial press do not.
4:02
Uh, the Senate Banking Committee, which is the first step to confirmation, any nominee cannot lose one Republican, assuming Democrats vote against that, that person.
4:11
So, that means that, th- that by doing this, the president has focused attention on that confirmation process, and in my view, makes it a lot more difficult for him to get anybody who has any whiff of partisanship or any whiff of, you know, being, um, able to be influenced-
7:16
Listen here...
7:17
Well, they've already made a special case for the Fed, right? They've already, in their footnotes, in their recent judgments around firing other chairmen of independent agencies, they've already basically carved out and said that the Fed is a special case, and that, that the threshold for firing the chairman or a governor for the Fed is going to be different from firing somebody at the FTC, for example, which is also another, which is another independent agency.
3:34
Let's listen.
3:35
I think that's absolutely right, and I mean, this is part of the reason why, um, I think the majority of Americans elected President Trump, is that they did feel like the, sort of the establishment, that the elites, the Bloomberg elites, if you will, Tom, um, were, you know, were leaving, uh, the kind of the- the working, you know, person, uh, behind.
3:53
I- I'm not sure if those folks feel like that the Trump administration, at least yet, have addressed some of those concerns, particularly around cost of living.
4:02
I mean, these are all k- you know, kitchen table issues.
4:04
Yeah.
4:04
These are still, are the most important for voters, and I'm not, that- that doesn't seem to have gone away, if you just look.
18:07
Is there a summerness to your Washington, DC?
18:10
I mean, there typically is.
18:12
Uh, I think we all, uh, kind of wait, uh, with bated breath for, usually for Aug- the August recess.
18:18
Um, you know, Tom, though, I think that-
18:19
that-This president has proved that regardless if Congress is in session or not, um, there are still many headlines and subsequent market reactions, uh, to, to those headlines in Washington, regardless if Congress is in.
18:32
So, I'm not sure it will make that much of a difference this year, but usually it is a time where people do go on vacation and, um, and enjoy the respite before what usually is a busy fall in, in Congress.
19:57
Does that get us back on a disinflationary vector of low yields? Or do we have stimulus that gives us stable yields or higher yields?
20:07
Yeah.
33:32
What's the possible downside here?
33:34
Yeah, so I think, I mean, a couple of things, Kelly.
33:37
One is, and just sort of zooming out, I mean, we think it's really important to not, you know, don't fix what's not broken.
33:44
In terms of the liquidity in the secondary mortgage market, really the congressional intent of Fannie and Freddie, they're doing this very well in terms of assets.
33:53
ACCESS TO THE ALL-IMPORTANT 30-YEAR FIXED MORTGAGE RATE, THE FACT THAT SOMEBODY CAN GET THAT IN CORONA DEL MAR, CALIFORNIA, THEY CAN GET THE SAME RATE AS IN CORONA NEW MEXICO, VERY DIFFERENT HOUSING MARKETS.
34:07
BUT IF THEY HAVE THE SAME KIND OF BORROWER CREDIT, THEY CAN ACCESS THE SAME RATE.
34:11
AND THAT IS A UTILITY THAT IS A FUNCTION OF THE GSCs.
35:22
How does this FICO controversy fit into it? Do you think that's a tempest in a teapot?
6:52
Is it possible that yields are rising on that, on better real growth expectations as a result? And therefore, it's not a panicky move, but rather one that would explain why risk assets are higher as well?
7:05
Yeah, I think that's exactly right.
7:06
I mean, I think it's sort of all of the above, honestly.
7:08
I mean, there is definitely some indigestion because of, you know, this expectation for more deficit issuance that's already adding to this very big collective debt pile, but also that this is going to be stimulative and again, probably more stimulative than maybe folks had expected.
7:25
We were expecting that a lot of the additional tax cuts would be more front loaded to try to offset some of the drag from tariffs in particular.
7:35
But this is looking like this could add about a half a percent of GDP from a growth perspective in 2026.
7:40
I think something that's interesting, Kelly, is that a lot of these tax provisions were made retroactive to 2025.
9:10
The growth is going to beat expectations to kind of make this look OK in the medium to long term.
18:46
Has there been a pivot or not, from your perspective?
18:49
Yeah, I don't think there's necessarily been a pivot.
18:51
Um, maybe some practicality has, uh, you know, has, has sort of trumped, uh, the ideology, uh, if you will.
18:57
However, I think a co- a couple of important points.
19:00
One is that this Section 232 investigation on semiconductors, that has been... that was previewed at the beginning of this administration.
19:08
They are very committed to this.
19:09
Ambassador Greer, uh, reiterated this in front of Senate Finance and Ways and Means this week.
22:29
But can you get a sense of what exactly led to the shift and the exemptions being announced, or was this already planned? Do you have any insight?
37:14
Mm-hmm.
37:14
And he ran on this.
37:16
He believes he has a mandate to fulfill this.
37:19
He believes that there's a lot of unfinished business from the first administration.
37:24
And I think that the, uh, the market, obviously, wants to maybe see through this or hope that there is something, this will result in a different outcome.
37:32
But our view is, tariff rates are going to be going up and that will have a headwind on, you know, growth and likely have implications for inflation.
37:40
To the degree is going to depend on the stickiness of all of this, obviously.
39:46
Overlay more of whatever.
21:11
Just quickly, do you think maybe, based on the comments of the last 24 hours, the president and this White House are realizing some of the legal constraints around what they can and can't do on April 2nd?
21:19
Yeah, and what we know about his trade advisor, Jameson Greer in particular, who's his US trade representative, he is particularly focused on the legality and the durability of these tariff actions.
21:30
We remember that April 2nd was the first, was sort of the date that was set out in the executive order in the first week of the administration, um, that really w- was supposed to clarify kind of the trade agenda.
21:42
It was before the, the Canada and Mexico tariffs, before the Columbia threats, before, um, the aluminum and steel tariffs.
21:49
So, I think in some ways, this should, I think, provide some coherence in terms of the trade agenda.
21:55
But again, the legality, I think, is very crucial here.
21:58
One thing that we've been talking to clients about is, is this just an announcement of future tariffs? Is this sort of forward guidance, if you will, for tariffs? Or is this actually an announcement that tariffs are rolling on on April 2nd? And I think that actually has to interplay with the legality.
23:53
What countries do you think they're gonna go after?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.