Skip to main content
Jeff Smith

Jeff Smith

Director of the Asian Studies Center at The Heritage Foundation, author of "Cold Peace: China-India Rivalry in the 21st Century"

Nov 11, 2026

10:57
What are your thoughts on that?
10:59
So very good question.
11:01
Jensen Huang and NVIDIA allies have for the past two years been making a series of connected arguments for why it's in our interest to sell these chips to China.
11:12
The argument you just made is arguably their most potent argument, and let's address that.
11:18
But I first want to say that this argument is multilayered.
11:22
Mm-hmm.
11:23
And I found most of the assumptions and propositions in these arguments highly dubious from the start.

10 MINS LATER

21:25
Is there an argument to be made that the border is closed when it comes to these chips? They do not leave the country, not even maybe for the French,
speaker_3HOST
10:57
What are your thoughts on that?
10:59
So very good question.
11:01
Jensen Huang and NVIDIA allies have for the past two years been making a series of connected arguments for why it's in our interest to sell these chips to China.
11:12
The argument you just made is arguably their most potent argument, and let's address that.
11:18
But I first want to say that this argument is multilayered.
11:22
Mm-hmm.
11:23
And I found most of the assumptions and propositions in these arguments highly dubious from the start.

10 MINS LATER

speaker_3HOST
21:25
Is there an argument to be made that the border is closed when it comes to these chips? They do not leave the country, not even maybe for the French,
39:37
All right, what do you make of this story? I'm somewhat surprised this honeypot stuff still works with China and the CCP, doesn't it?
39:45
Apparently it does, and it is deeply concerning.
39:49
We're not just talking here about any old honeypot and any old CEO.
39:54
This is the CEO of our biggest technology company who is currently making the chips that are going to power the future of industrial revolution.
40:05
what this guy is saying and doing matters a great deal to the future of the United States, frankly, and our national security.
40:13
And so it's clear he was a high target for Chinese intelligence services.
40:17
I mean, what a coup that is for China, if all of this proves to be true.
40:59
How well is the United States handling this for what's going on on our soil?
6:11
Given that it doesn't seem like we got a whole lot out of this, and combined with the very warm reception the president presented towards Chairman Xi, where does the American-Chinese relationship stand right now? I
6:26
think we're in a state of ongoing rivalry.
6:31
And I think the best case for what the president is doing with Chairman Xi is leaning into diplomacy and engagement in order to accomplish three things.
6:44
I think you could make an argument for three things.
6:47
First, bide time to shore up your own position after decades of fairly stupid policies by American governments.
6:58
So we recognize that we are dependent on China for critical supply chains, including critical minerals and rare earths, a tool of economic coercion that they proved willing to use against the U.S. last year and use rather effectively.
7:14
There are other areas where the United States has essentially exposed itself to China, whether it's supply chains, China's presence inside U.S. telecommunications networks, inside critical infrastructure.

19 MINS LATER

26:12
Where are we on that front? Are we seeing any progress on this legislation or is it somewhat stalled?
11:09
... with the Chinese, or should we still look at them as a rival/a geopolitical foe?
11:13
Yeah.
11:13
It's a good question.
11:14
A lot to unpack there.
11:16
So, you know, the American public is for cooperation and engagement with China.
11:21
I think even us at Heritage, even sort of China hawks would say we don't oppose engagement.
11:27
We, we do think you need to talk to the Chinese at some point.

16 MINS LATER

27:05
[laughs] You decide
27:27
But that would seem to dictate that something else is coming down the pike, especially with respect to what you just said about the pomp and circumstance and not being commensurate with any type of results that come out of it.
27:39
Well, I think I think we are seeing sort of a dichotomy here, which is that there is a lot of pageantry and flowery diplomatic language happening at the very top level.
27:52
And in some cases, that is masking a lack of substance, a lack of concrete deliverables at the working level.
28:00
Normally, when you have leader-level summits, even an American president meeting with a mid-tier country's leader, you would have a tremendous amount of prep work going into it and a huge list of deliverables that both sides had been working on for months to show all the progress in the relationship.
28:19
And, you know, with the summits we've seen with President Xi at times, it's been light on the deliverables.
28:24
And I think that's just the reality that, you know, we are in a rivalry and there's not a lot of areas for huge cooperation.
28:32
We're sort of tinkering around at the margins with, you know, selling soybeans and hopefully halting the flow of fentanyl.
29:19
Is China setting up for that next big aggressive move against us with all of that?
12:06
What would you like to see President Trump hit first?
12:11
Yeah, it's a very good question.
12:12
You know, I almost approach this in the reverse, which is that there's a set of things I don't want to see President Trump do.
12:19
I don't want to see on the negotiating table things that are sort of vital to our national interest, like U.S. support for Taiwan, arms sales to Taiwan.
12:28
I don't want to be giving up critical advanced U.S. chips.
12:31
I don't want to be giving away the farm and the AI race.
12:35
I don't want to give China any more access than it already has to the United States, to farmland or, you know, opening up these Confucius Institutes on U.S. universities.
14:27
What do you think China wants from us?
19:59
But that would seem to dictate that something else is coming down the pike, especially with respect to what you just said about the pomp and circumstance and not being commensurate with any type of results that come out of it.
20:11
Well, I think we are seeing sort of a dichotomy here, which is that there is a lot of pageantry and flowery diplomatic language happening at the very top level.
20:23
And in some cases, that is masking a lack of substance, a lack of concrete deliverables at the working level.
20:32
Normally when you have leader level summits, even an American president meeting with like a mid-tier country's leader, you would have a tremendous amount of prep work going into it and a huge list of deliverables that both sides had been working on for months.
20:48
to show all the progress in the relationship.
20:51
And, you know, with the summits we've seen with President Xi at times, it's been light on the deliverables.
20:56
And I think that's just the reality that, you know, we are in a rivalry and there's not a lot of areas for huge cooperation.
21:51
Is China setting up for that next big aggressive move against us with all of that?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.