Skip to main content
Jason Josephson Storm

Jason Josephson Storm

Academic and philosopher

Nov 13, 2026

25:33
What do you mean by that, Han? Can you explain what you think Nietzsche was actually trying to do in that book and why is it a polemic against genealogy rather than being a work of genealogy? And have scholars misread this book over a century?
25:49
Yeah, so Nietzsche's The Genealogy of Moral, Ein Streitschrift, the title could be translated, like it's not translated The Genealogy of Morals or Morality, but people leave off the second half of the title.
26:02
And the second half of the title literally translated would be fighting words, but might also be described as a polemic.
26:08
And it would not be farfetched to describe the book as a polemic on or against the genealogy of morality.
26:16
Now what Nietzsche is so partially I'm focusing my attention on Nietzsche I should say first because genealogy often functions as a critique of origins And genealogists claim to reject pure origins and founding essences yet They often treat Nietzsche as genealogies privileged point of origin so that that's already problematic But then when you focus on Nietzsche's usage, I think it should trouble contemporary genealogists for two reasons one Nietzsche, if you track every single use of the word genealogy in Nietzsche, it's negative, or almost every single one.
26:49
It's either neutral or negative.
26:50
His very first reference to the term genealogy, he describes David Strauss as an apfengeneologen, so an ape or monkey genealogist.

8 MINS LATER

35:05
Why do you think Foucault, what do you think Foucault was doing when he later distanced himself from structuralism and presented himself more as a follower of Nietzsche, let's say? So why is it important to know, to understand that young, early structuralist Foucault and then how he distanced himself from that tradition?
29:04
What do you mean by that, Han? Can you explain what you think Nietzsche was actually trying to do in that book and why is it a polemic against genealogy rather than being a work of genealogy? And have scholars misread this book over a century?
29:19
Yeah, so Nietzsche's The Genealogy of Moral, Ein Streitschrift, the title could be translated, like it's not translated The Genealogy of Morals or Morality, but people leave off the second half of the title.
29:32
And the second half of the title literally translated would be fighting words, but might also be described as a polemic.
29:39
And it would not be farfetched to describe the book as a polemic on or against the genealogy of morality.
29:46
Now what Nietzsche is so partially I'm focusing my attention on Nietzsche I should say first because genealogy often functions as a critique of origins And genealogists claim to reject pure origins and founding essences yet They often treat Nietzsche as genealogies privileged point of origin so that that's already problematic But then when you focus on Nietzsche's usage, I think it should trouble contemporary genealogists for two reasons one Nietzsche, if you track every single use of the word genealogy in Nietzsche, it's negative, or almost every single one.
30:19
It's either neutral or negative.
30:20
His very first reference to the term genealogy, he describes David Strauss as an apfengeneologen, so an ape or monkey genealogist.

11 MINS LATER

speaker_10ADVERTISER
41:09
Availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan.
29:34
What do you mean by that, Han? Can you explain what you think Nietzsche was actually trying to do in that book and why is it a polemic against genealogy rather than being a work of genealogy? And have scholars misread this book over a century?
29:50
Yeah, so Nietzsche's The Genealogy of Moral, Ein Streitschrift, the title could be translated, like it's not translated The Genealogy of Morals or Morality, but people leave off the second half of the title.
30:03
And the second half of the title literally translated would be fighting words, but might also be described as a polemic.
30:09
And it would not be farfetched to describe the book as a polemic on or against the genealogy of morality.
30:16
Now what Nietzsche is so partially I'm focusing my attention on Nietzsche I should say first because genealogy often functions as a critique of origins And genealogists claim to reject pure origins and founding essences yet They often treat Nietzsche as genealogies privileged point of origin so that that's already problematic But then when you focus on Nietzsche's usage, I think it should trouble contemporary genealogists for two reasons one Nietzsche, if you track every single use of the word genealogy in Nietzsche, it's negative, or almost every single one.
30:49
It's either neutral or negative.
30:51
His very first reference to the term genealogy, he describes David Strauss as an apfingeniologen, so an ape or monkey genealogist.

9 MINS LATER

speaker_1ADVERTISER
40:23
Collect responsibly.
16:34
Around genealogy.
16:35
Yeah, in our own genealogy, exactly.
16:37
Um, yeah, so in a way my book is, is all, uh, could be read as all an elaborate, exhaustively critical but loving commentary on Foucault's Nietzsche genealogy history essay.
16:47
But one of the things that I centrally do is unravel that essay's account of Nietzsche, and in particular that essay, uh, asserts that Nietzsche is someone with a genealogical method.
16:58
But if you go back to, um, Nietzsche's original text, Zur Genealogie Der Moral: Ein Streitschrift, it is literally translated towards or on or against a genealogy of morals, fighting words or a polemic.
17:14
I mean, it turns out literally it's fighting words, but it's a polemic, and it wouldn't be too heavy-handed to describe it as a, a polemic against the genealogists of morality or the, against the genealogy of morality.
17:27
Um, what, what do I mean by this? So partially how is Foucault ...

22 MINS LATER

39:53
Mm.
33:26
What was happening 500 years ago that led us to this idea of a modern secular age?
33:33
Yeah, I mean, well, so I was gonna jump in a slightly different direction.
33:35
So I'll cut across your question in a way.
33:38
I mean, I think one of the, there's often a talk that suggests that we think in a very different way than let's say medieval Europeans did.
33:47
And a lot of that, it turns out to be an anachronism or back projected.
33:50
For example, in the 19th century, people got the idea that in the middle ages, people thought the world was flat.
33:56
People didn't think the world was fat before Columbus, not the majority of people in Europe.
38:27
If you know, so it corroborates the, the secularization thesis, but maybe it's not quite as profound a level of secularization that someone might say today.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.