Skip to main content
Jason DeParle

Jason DeParle

Reporter

Oct 14, 2026

4:45
When you went to Arizona, what did you see that made clear this was not simply an ordinary reduction in program enrollment, but a warning, a warning about a fundamental change in the nation's commitment to feeding people who are poor?
5:02
Jim, that was, um, excellent introductory context.
5:05
Can I add o- o- one other little bit? Um, the SNAP program has really taken on enormous significance in the past 20 years.
5:18
Um, with the decline of cash assistance, it's really become the safety net of last resort.
5:24
It's...
5:24
Y- you rightly describe it as a nutrition program, but it's more than that.
5:30
It's, um, it, it's a rent program.

11 MINS LATER

16:53
So tell us about some of these new, these error rates, uh, these, uh, these new dangers, uh, that res- uh, re- that result in so many people who are eligible losing their food stamps.
20:24
But by and large, most people, policymakers, activists, just regular Americans who are watching the news, don't really get a What is the impact on children and families who depended on this program and who no longer receive it? Jason, can we get into your reporting in Arizona and have you give us a picture of what you saw?
20:47
I'd say two things were interesting to me, Billy.
20:51
Sometimes you see a statistical trend that seems dramatic on paper, but you go to a place and it doesn't seem to have affected life in a particularly noticeable way.
21:04
That was not the case in Arizona.
21:06
So the snap rolls in Arizona have fallen by about half in a year.
21:10
And if you land in Phoenix and start talking to low-income people, you see it pretty quickly.
21:17
I mean, that's a lot of people, more than...
22:42
Where do they turn now and what does their life look like besides them, you know, seeing them standing in line to try to fix things? What else are you seeing?
27:05
Are we expecting to see this dramatic of an effect in other states?
27:10
I think most people would guess that Arizona's an extreme example, but we don't really know.
27:17
Nationwide, the rules haven't taken place yet.
27:20
If you recall, Congress delayed the changes they made till after the midterm elections.
27:25
So for the most part, we haven't seen the impact of these changes yet, but there are reasons to suspect that other states may respond in similar ways to Arizona.
27:35
Starting in November, the federal government's gonna cut in half the amount of administrative money it gives states to run the program.
27:43
That could cause states to lay off caseworkers just as Arizona did.
28:26
What are you thinking about this moment, about how significant it is?
15:41
But if unrestricted cash had the benefits that people were kind of hoping it might have, don't you think you would see it show up somewhere?
15:53
Well, absolutely one of the possible explanations for why the aid didn't have the expected impact is that it was wrong to expect it from the beginning, and the researchers themselves are quite divided over what to make of it.
16:07
One cautioned me, "You can't make anything of it.
16:10
It's just a Rorschach test.
16:12
People will project their own preferences upon it." And another, a quite a prominent researcher named Greg Duncan, who's a economist at the University of California, Irvine, told me that these results have prompted him to change his views.
16:27
He has been surprised, and he thinks they can't simply be dismissed away as the product of low stipends or pandemic interference.
16:36
Greg is one of the most prominent researchers in the field.

5 MINS LATER

21:45
What do you think this means for the field overall, for, for people who are trying to find interventions to try to address this core problem, that poor kids have worse outcomes than their more affluent peers? Like, if you're a person trying to figure out what will improve early childhood development, what do you do now that you have this study that's saying that, "Look, no strings cash, at least until now, hasn't had that effect"?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.