Skip to main content

James Nation

Mathematician

Oct 28, 2026

12:39
As with all investments, your capital is at risk.
12:41
So it was genuinely a narrow fiscal event, Michael.
12:44
I think, you know, there are a few of us in the analyst community who after Liverpool, where Andy Burnham, I think, very much surprised with that reveal on the triple lock, were thinking that there'll be a potential rabbit.
12:55
There'll be something that we are missing here.
12:58
And You know, I think there were some interesting things in the budget which didn't quite fit with expectations, which I can come back to.
13:03
But when you look at it overall, I think it is broadly in line with what most of the markets would have been looking out for.
13:10
I mean, what, pre-measures headroom was down at 12 billion.
17:26
He's pushed it back to the spending review next year, but has he signalled enough that he's credible after literally resigning over us not doing enough to get towards the NATO targets?
17:56
He's pushed it back to the spending review next year, but has he signalled enough that he's credible after literally resigning over us not doing enough to get towards the NATO targets?
18:07
So I don't think so.
18:08
But in defence of the government, actually, this is always going to be tough to find 10 or 11 billion pounds additional per annum.
18:16
And what I would say, actually, Michael, is I just think, you know, I've just said it there in terms of a lot of tough decisions being pushed to the right.
18:24
I actually think whoever was in that seat at the moment would be delaying to some extent, because we've got a difficult global environment.
18:32
Who knows if the Bank of England are actually going to hike rates four times, as market expectations seem to think so, a couple of weeks or a month ago.
18:40
Who knows whether that happens? Therefore, it is a very risky and changeable environment to make some big decisions now.
23:19
Would you be, if you were a SPAD working for John Healey, would you be happy with his performance today, happy with his delivery?
21:17
for so
21:17
long i actually think the policy needs to come later matt i think i actually welcome that kemi is using this opportunity to paint more in primary colors a bit like as lucia says we saw from burnham last week you know i was there at the tail end of the last government at And it was a period where it was kind of characterised by risk aversion.
21:33
The party wasn't in a happy place.
21:34
As such, you were trying to split the difference on complex areas of policy.
21:39
And that meant you weren't quite sure where your North Star was, what you were about.
21:43
So I think it is wise to use this conference now in opposition.
21:47
to try and sort of paint that picture of what you're about and what you believe in.
24:57
He
2:15
Perhaps it hasn't disappeared yet.
2:17
If you remember last year when we were talking in advance about budget, Tom, it was incredibly messy.
2:22
There are a couple of reasons for that.
2:24
One, Rachel Reeves set last year's budget up in such a way that the speculation was how much she would need to fill in a black hole.
2:33
She had historically low headroom going into that fiscal event last year, and so all the commentary was...
2:41
Is she or isn't she going to breach the manifesto? What are some of the tax raising options to increase headroom? And then we even saw that speculation over, are they actually going to breach and put income tax rates up? And if you remember, I said, no, they wouldn't because no one is going to breach the manifesto.
2:58
And that's where we are now.

29 MINS LATER

32:19
Any signals or clues we should be looking for from John Healy or Andy Burnham when they speak?
2:15
Perhaps it hasn't disappeared yet.
2:17
If you remember last year when we were talking in advance of that budget, Tom, it was incredibly messy.
2:22
There are a couple of reasons for that.
2:24
One, Rachel Reeves set last year's budget up in such a way that the speculation was how much she would need to fill in a black hole.
2:33
She had historically low headroom going into that fiscal event last year, and so all the commentary was...
2:41
Is she or isn't she going to breach the manifesto? What are some of the tax raising options to increase headroom? And then we even saw that speculation over, are they actually going to breach and put income tax rates up? And if you remember, I said, no, they wouldn't because no one is going to breach the manifesto.
2:58
And that's where we are now.

29 MINS LATER

32:19
Any signals or clues we should be looking for from John Healy or Andy Burnham when they speak?
1:09
What was it like?
1:10
Weirdest time of my life.
1:11
Because remember, we'd lost.
1:12
Yeah.
1:12
We had lost.
1:14
I thought that was it.
1:15
I thought my kind of career in politics, such as it was, was over.
4:13
And how much of it is it, you know, where's the stationary? What number do you dial for an outside line? Do I have an email address yet? Or is there kind of an ability to push go on a kind of implementation strategy? Or are you just kind of, the phrase at the moment is kind of building the plane as you're already taking off?
11:47
Could I pin you down and give me, could you give me the top two likely contenders or is it still very much an open goal?
11:54
Oh, I'm going to cheat and give you three, but I'm going to say that I still, on balance, am not willing to move off Ed Miliband being favourite just yet.
12:03
I know there's some briefing against him from the unions for his policy on clean energy.
12:08
There's also a concern, not unreasonably, that this is an ideologically soft left politician who I think, if you gave him a blank sheet of paper, would not draw up the fiscal rules as they're currently designed under Rachel Reeves, where they bite after three years.
12:23
So I think some of the concerns about him from a policy perspective, inflationary risk and the like, what he means for taxation, are warranted.
12:32
But I also think at times like this, we have to try and think how the principal, Andy Burnham, will think and some of the key people around him.
12:40
Burnham's experience of the Treasury will be not a wholly positive one.

9 MINS LATER

21:27
Eventually, and what he's able to do in the short term, do you think he will try and front load the agenda and try and use that political capital that he has, having recently won the by-election, to drive through change? Does that feel like the sort of thing he'd probably try and do?
11:47
Could I pin you down and could you give me the top two likely contenders or is it still very much an open goal?
11:54
Oh, I'm going to cheat and give you three, but I'm going to say that I still, on balance, am not willing to move off Ed Miliband being favourite just yet.
12:03
I know there's some briefing against him from the unions for his policy on clean energy.
12:08
There's also a concern, not unreasonably, that this is an ideologically soft left politician who I think, if you gave him a blank sheet of paper, would not draw up the fiscal rules as they're currently designed under Rachel Reeves, where they bite after three years.
12:23
So I think some of the concerns about him from a policy perspective, inflationary risk and the like, what he means for taxation, are warranted.
12:32
But I also think at times like this, we have to try and think how the principal, Andy Burnham, will think and some of the key people around him.
12:40
Burnham's experience of the Treasury will be not a wholly positive one.

9 MINS LATER

21:27
Eventually, and what he's able to do in the short term, do you think he will try and front load the agenda and try and use that political capital that he has, having recently won the by-election, to drive through change? Does that feel like the sort of thing he'd probably try and do?
32:43
Should animals be forced by law to communicate in language?"
32:50
Well, uh, several questions there.
32:52
I mean, we could, we could start with the massive diversion of the education budget to that endeavor, Matt.
32:56
But, uh, I think there'd be some sort of, uh, some, some questions about comprehension of a language across different pet type, I'd have thought.
33:04
So, uh, so yeah, it'd be, it'd be quite the scheme.
33:06
It'd be quite the, quite the expansion of the state there.
33:10
Um, so, uh, so yeah, I think we probably need to scope it out before we go down that route.
33:40
Oh, yeah
3:09
(laughs)
3:09
...
3:09
but please do have me back.
3:10
But I think, you know, my read on it is, I think looking at alternative models internationally, those could still be equally as messy if poorly managed.
3:20
So I think actually a lot of the problem in the run-up to this budget has just been the mixture of kite flying, noises off, actual Treasury trails, which we're into now, by which I mean actual announcements that will be in the budget, like the rail fare freeze, where, for those of us who are observers, we find those maybe a little bit harder to square given they come after a lot of pitch rolling from the Treasury in recent weeks.
3:44
And I think part of the problem with this budget, James, and I remember discussing this with you guys when I was last on, is the problem is maybe markets and others have been prepared for a different budget than what you're gonna see tomorrow.
3:55
You know, they were expecting short term big pain, a difficult political lever pulled, but a big fiscal consolidation in the near term, early, and that's obviously not what we're gonna get with the smorgasbord.

6 MINS LATER

10:05
I think maybe her thinking has shifted upon coming into contact with the realities of office.
6:30
We're gonna be the party that you have to trust on the economy because everyone else is extreme." Are you worried now? Is, is Farage eating yet more Tory chips?
6:39
chips?Look, I agree with James Heale that it was a smart bit of political positioning, right? You know, so he, the fundamental calculation that Farage will have taken is this is a Labor Party that cannot and will not cut spending.
6:53
And then we've got a Conservative Party who are trying to reestablish themselves as the party for credible savings and funded tax cuts.
7:01
And I can't let that run away from me.
7:03
So it makes sense to me as a, a sort of feature of political positioning, as James was just outlining.
7:09
But it was looking through the Q&A, Michael, where I sort of got reminded of that point that always, always confronts you when you're in government, which is trade-offs.
7:18
So for example, we saw a desire to scrap IR35 come back in Farage's comments.
11:10
Where do you stand on these, having been inside the Treasury? Do you think this is, this is realistic or is this just the Treasury trying to get really bad news out that they then don't have to deliver?
3:41
What does the word austerity actually mean?
3:43
Well, it's a great question, isn't it? And I thought it was a curious choice, actually, for the chancellor to say that and bring almost the austerity word back in her comments, I think, to the Labour Party conference last year.
3:56
I think obviously people have in their minds, uh, the austerity era or the fiscal consolidation that was undertaken by George Osborne between 2010 and 2015.
4:06
And that's nowhere near what we're dealing with now.
4:09
But I think the problem, as you say, Michael, is that in that period, because of everyth- of everything that's happened, both planned, whether that's, for example, the Johnson government coming in off the back of the 2019 manifesto and announcing some planned increases in capital expenditure, or unplanned, as a result of the pandemic and various shocks, we've clearly seen not just total departmental expenditure really increase, but people's expectations get inflated as well, which means that if, on Wednesday, you do see some departments see some real term reductions, which you'll need to to make the numbers add up, the risk is that that doesn't quite align with, uh, what people understand when they hear no return to austerity.
4:53
So look, what Torsten's trying to do, I think, is he's trying to justify the strategy that Reeves and others have adopted since coming back, which is to change the fiscal rules, allow more room for capital investment to combat what has been underinvestment in the UK for quite some time, many people argue.
5:12
The challenge, though, will be, do Labour and- and MPs and others recognize that big increase to capital investment as a positive thing? Or actually, is it more on the day-to-day public service side where people feel the pressure?
7:29
Given all this, you know, massive, um, demands on spending down the line, does this sort of three-year envelope even really matter? I mean, how much attention should we even give to this?
7:10
But other stuff, of course, Woolust have been, um, facing HMG no matter who'd won the election last summer.
7:15
For sure.
7:15
And look, I think if we're fair and balanced about it, there would've been pressures across government departments and across government spending in future years that anyone would have to deal with.
7:26
And I think that was clear from spending plans signed up to by all parties at the last election.
7:32
You know, you look at the fiscal fundamentals in the UK, high debt-to-GDP, uh, high borrowing costs as well, climbing costs on the welfare side, which we know are gonna be a big political problem for this government.
7:45
And that would have been a challenge for anyone to confront.
7:49
I, I do just observe, I think what's made things slightly harder for Rachel Reeves is that she's simultaneously come in and actually loosened fiscal policy, i.e. allowed for a lot more space, particularly on capital spending, as I was saying earlier.

8 MINS LATER

15:51
And second of all, how do you keep troublesome ministers in line? Because it's very difficult to work out whether you sort of incentivize them or not in terms of going public with disagreements.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.