Skip to main content

Jack Nuelle

Nov 14, 2026

46:42
Mm-hmm.
46:46
So the thing that I struggle with is like, well, what is the reason for that? I think on a surface level, you can make the claim that like, oh, there's a comfort with authority of a clerical type that means that there's a comfort with authority of a political type.
47:06
I think that's a fair reading to make just observationally, right? But I wonder if there's a deeper theological reason for somebody who understands the sacraments to be performed for the priest's duty to be the performer of these sacraments, that their participation in the sacraments is through the priest, that there is this kind of essential mediation that is not Like they bypass any sort of existential engagement with the sacraments in favor of the priest as this mediator.
47:49
Just not to say that the priest is not a mediator, but it's a matter of emphasis, right? I think that you can then, it can become easier to acquiesce to the status quo.
48:08
That's at least where I'm at now.
48:09
And the reason I say that is because I do some historical digging in the dissertation and there is an instance in France kind of during World War II, during the Vichy government of Jesuits who are resistant to fascism and resistance to Vichy.
48:39
using a theology of real presence as proof or a certain theology of the real presence, using this as evidence for a collaborationist politics.

8 MINS LATER

56:33
i mean you could

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.