Skip to main content
Isaac Beach

Isaac Beach

Australian writer and literary critic, author of the Substack "Within a Budding Grove" (isaacbeach.substack.com), guest on The Getting Lit Podcast.

Sep 22, 2026

MattHOST
17:17
like the book
17:17
i can tell i I swear to God, I can see it just in those couple of sentences littered throughout that I don't think this reviewer actually liked the book.
17:25
But because, especially in Australia, it's a very small ecosystem and you don't want to offend the people you're likely going to see at dinner parties or book launches or whatever it is that they attend to.
17:37
I'm not invited to them.
17:41
They sort of always pull their punches.
17:43
And I also think it really does a disservice to the writer because I don't think it's like a very authentic form of criticism.
17:52
And I think about that sort of, like, the form of criticism a lot.

1 HR 35 MINS LATER

MattHOST
113:14
positive stories?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.