Skip to main content
Ian Bogost

Ian Bogost

American academic and video game designer

Nov 2, 2026

9:27
So tell us a little bit about your own experience of that, but then how that fed into your subsequent engagement with computer science over the course of the last 20, 25, 30 years.
9:40
Right.
9:41
It's been that long.
9:44
Things were quite different 30 years ago, and they were quite a bit different 20 years ago, and in some ways better and easier.
9:50
And I was a weird person.
9:52
As you can tell, I'm still kind of a strange person.
9:54
I've got my fingers in a lot of stuff, and I always had a lot of interests.

23 MINS LATER

33:18
I'd love to hear some questions from anyone here.
8:46
Okay, so tell us the other side then.
8:48
Yeah, so if you think about, so I make this distinction between different kinds of pleasure, different kinds of joy, and the three concepts that I discuss in the book at some length are happiness, satisfaction, and gratification.
9:01
Now, different people are gonna have like different words, different definitions, but I think this is a good way of thinking about kind of like the overarching view of contentment.
9:11
And happiness is weird.
9:13
It's difficult to define.
9:14
It's something that is big and hard.
9:17
It's about your career or your family life or your partner or your kids or your health or everything about your just overall sense of general contentment.

16 MINS LATER

25:37
And you say the marshmallow test gets gratification wrong.
5:59
What do you mean by that?
5:59
that?So we used to have just a lot more diverse opportunities to connect our bodies to the world and to feel the results, to like feel really engaged and connected to things and people and places.
6:12
Stick shift is one example, but one that I bring up all the time is, like, you go to a public restroom these days, a washroom, and you don't touch anything, you know? Which feels good, 'cause it's like, well, I don't know if I wanna touch stuff in there.
6:22
But then the faucet, instead of turning the handles, uh, you put your hands under and maybe the sensor works and maybe it doesn't.
6:28
And then the towel's like that, and the, and the, and the, the soap dispenser is like that, and the toilet flushes for you.
6:34
And so all of those kinds of automation systems, um, they've taken away this little, tiny opportunity to be in the world, uh, uh, physically.
6:43
There's all sorts of stuff like this.

6 MINS LATER

12:21
else.And so how do you, how do you get there? How do you appreciate those moments? How do you find the time? And maybe you don't need the time to have a, a gratification moment, but how do you do it?
6:06
That's the term Ian gives to the magical, enlightening, and kind of life-changing sensory stuff that we encounter all day long, or at least that we used to encounter all day long, but increasingly maybe aren't getting quite as much of.
6:23
So think about any- anything you do in your daily life.
6:27
I mean, you have to go shopping for, for groceries, and, you know, in the past you'd have to make a list, and maybe you'd write that down on, on paper, on a piece of scratch paper with a pen that you, you particularly liked using, and then you'd put it in your pocket, and you sort of fold it up, and it would have a certain feel of the paper as it tore off.
6:43
And maybe, maybe the paper made a sound as you tore it.
6:46
And then you'd get in your car, which maybe had a stick shift and maybe didn't, but even if it didn't, you'd turn the key in the ignition, and you'd press your foot down on the pedal, and you'd turn the knob on the radio physically as you drove to the store.
6:57
And you'd get the cart, and the cart wobbled a little bit, but you felt it underneath you and against the, the, the cold floor, uh, beneath your feet, and then you touch the, the produce to figure out which ones met your desired, uh, level of ripeness and all the rest of it.
7:10
And, you know, you can kind of fill in all those blanks.

7 MINS LATER

14:16
So is gratification one of the things that you think about when you are designing games and virtual worlds?
speaker_1NARRATOR
31:04
So my
31:04
friend Tom, like changing jobs, like kind of revising his whole life.
31:09
And, you know, when you do something like that, a big change in your life, it's all about being happier, right? And it's big and you have to figure out if you're in the right career and if you're at the right employer or like, you know, who am I even? Do I need to move to a different place? And he was going through that.
31:24
um but then at the same time he wanted to make a space like better and more comfortable in his home uh for his family uh it was the basement and it was kind of dank and dark and um and he came to me with uh some questions that i happened to be able to give some advice about brightening it up with this mason this thick masonry sealer that i that i love And like finishing a project like that, like a home improvement project and anything you kind of put your hips, your hands on your hips, you know, after and you look, you kind of nod your head a little bit like, hmm, that's like satisfaction.
31:55
You know, it's pride and accomplishment.
31:57
I got something big done and now my family can use that space.
32:01
And, you know, I've been a good steward of the home and that kind of thing.

7 MINS LATER

39:29
rewarding tactile experience
8:04
being sold this idea that life should be faster, more convenient, but we misunderstand the cost of convenience, I think.
8:12
That's right.
8:13
It's sort of like I have a name for this whole phenomenon, which is dematerialization is sort of my name for all of these factors.
8:19
And it could be like you're not supposed to drive a six.
8:22
Oh, you're not supposed to drive a car at all anymore.
8:25
Right.
8:25
Like you're just supposed to let a machine do it for you.

10 MINS LATER

18:40
about working anywhere means materialism?
9:02
What is the difference between happiness, satisfaction, and gratification, and why did you think it was important to differentiate them?
9:08
I'm gonna start with the why did I think it was important.
9:11
We have, for some reason, kind of overloaded contentment into one singular concept, and that's usually happiness.
9:20
So when we think about what it means to be content in your life, there's kind of one flavor of it, and we've named it happiness.
9:26
And nobody really quite knows what happiness is.
9:29
If you ask someone, "Are you happy?" They'll be like, "I don't know.
9:32
Like, what would it mean to be happy?" Right? And the psychologists and behavioral scientists, whatever, who study it, the way that they define this term is often by just asking people overall if they're happy, you know, which is sort of like a circular argument.

24 MINS LATER

33:57
Yeah
46:09
Which has been shrunk down to like our MacBooks, you know? Yeah.
46:14
Yeah, you're at your computer, you know, eight hours a day in a knowledge work job.
46:20
You're moving symbols, you know, you're typing, you're composing emails, you're responding to calendar requests, you're using Slack or Teams or whatever you use to tap out messages.
46:31
And so all work kind of has the same texture now, or at least all like knowledge work.
46:37
And, you know, like people are really unhappy sometimes.
46:40
in their work lives these days.
46:42
And I think they believe that that unhappiness is related to the economics of their jobs or the, you know, they're not understanding what their boss wants or feeling as though they need to achieve the next rung on the ladder of their career path.
50:20
How have you tried to infuse that work, which could just be moving symbols around on the screen with these elements of gratification that you're talking about?
IanHOST
13:43
Hmm
13:44
... temptation or f- kind of first look, that's great.
13:49
And then from it, I hope people will learn that they're, they're living their sensory lives all the time, and it's, it's available to them much more broadly.
14:00
So like I'm sitting here at my desk in my home office, and I have this, uh, walnut desk that, that has a certain smoothness to it and density, and it's smooth in front of me where my-- where the oils of my hands have sort of, you know, rubbed against it over, over months and years.
14:20
And sometimes I just feel that, and it just grounds me.
14:23
I'm, I'm here, and I'm here with this object, and then it goes away again as I stop touching it, and something else, you know, you know, enters, uh, the picture.
14:32
It might be the can of soda that, that I'm drinking.

15 MINS LATER

IanHOST
29:35
Mm
3:28
[upbeat music]
3:30
Insight one: happiness isn't enough.
3:33
Most of us spend a lot of time thinking about happiness, worrying about it even.
3:38
We want to be good parents, good partners, good friends.
3:41
We want meaningful work, healthy bodies, strong communities.
3:45
Those are worthwhile goals, but they're also enormous ones.
3:50
They can take years to achieve, and even then it's hard to know whether you've succeeded.
5:34
[upbeat music]
31:55
Right
31:55
... and, and the idea that you would go into an office became, like, why bother? And of course, managers wanted people together in the office because it's just much easier to work with people together [laughs] in the office.
32:08
It's not just because they were trying to exert control, which of course they were also trying to do.
32:14
But then there's all this stuff that is, is really lost when you're not in a particular place doing a particular thing, and that was starting to be lost even before we had reason to go online because of the pandemic.
32:28
It was in the nature of the work.
32:31
So, like, I'm a, I'm a writer.
32:32
Sometimes I do journalism where I have to talk to people and do reporting, and it's very different when I go somewhere, when I fly on a plane, and I go somewhere and I talk to people in their living rooms or in their workplaces, and I see where they are and what they're doing, and I experience the sounds and sights and smells and temperatures of the environment.
36:10
You just know they're, they're not present there.
19:03
What do you mean by that term? And give us some examples.
19:06
Yeah, essentially, over years and decades, we have slowly and invisibly disconnected ourselves from the physical world.
19:16
This wasn't something any of us chose.
19:19
It didn't happen by design in many cases.
19:21
It was just a secondary effect of a lot of different changes.
19:24
Some of them were technological.
19:26
So one of the things people think of first when they think about their lives today is maybe their smartphone and all sorts of stuff.

6 MINS LATER

25:54
So you think that the tactile and other sensory dimensions are somehow key to well-being.
6:06
What do you mean by that?
6:06
that?So we used to have just a lot more diverse opportunities to connect our bodies to the world and to feel the results, to, like, feel really engaged and connected to things and people and places.
6:19
Stick shift is one example, but one that I bring up all the time is, like, you go to a public restroom these days, a washroom, and you don't touch anything, you know? Which feels good 'cause it's like, "Well, I don't know if I wanna touch stuff in there." But then the faucet, instead of turning the handles, uh, you put your hands under, and maybe the sensor works, and maybe it doesn't.
6:35
And then the towel's like that, and the, and the, and the, the soap dispenser is like that, and the toilet flushes for you.
6:41
And so all of those kinds of automation systems, um, they've taken away this little, tiny opportunity to be in the world, uh, uh, physically.
6:50
There's all sorts of stuff like this.
6:52
A lot of our lives are now mediated by smartphones, right? And so things that y- we used to have to go somewhere to do, like maybe the grocery store to shop, and you'd feel the avocados and test if they were ripe, and now you punch it into Instacart or your favorite app, and it gets delivered to you.

5 MINS LATER

12:28
else.And so how do you, how do you get there? How do you appreciate those moments? How do you find the time? And maybe you don't need the time to have a, a gratification moment, but how do you do it?
25:23
... a previous, more difficult world.
25:25
No.
25:26
I th- I think it's easy to look at the past and notice how certain things or maybe like a diversity of experiences were available to us, and many of them got squished into computers, but others became disconnected through choices that we didn't really make, that aren't exactly about progress, but are more about automation and efficiency.
25:47
I think my favorite example of this is all of the automated sensors in a, in a washroom.
25:52
You know, you go into an airport-
26:58
Mm
26:58
... and I put the whole house to bed with the touch of a button.
27:02
But I'm still gratified by touching the button and feeling it give under my finger.
10:29
University in California started running in the late 1960s.
10:33
And they've been known as the marshmallow tests.
10:37
Walter Mischel and his colleagues and then successors ran these experiments in which they would take young children, kind of preschool age kids, three years old, four years old, and put them in a room with a marshmallow, a singular marshmallow, or sometimes it was another kind of treat.
10:55
And the researchers told the kids, you can have this one marshmallow now, or if you wait 10 or 15 minutes until I come back in the room, I'll give you another one later, and then we can play with some toys.
11:06
So the gambit was, do you want one marshmallow now or two marshmallows later? these experiments were used purportedly to show that kids who resisted who delayed gratification as they discussed it were much more successful later in life they ran longitudinal studies and showed that they had like better test scores in school and got into better schools for college and made more money and were happier all these sorts of factors that they attempted to correlate with their preschool-age predilections for delayed gratification instead of instant gratification.
11:42
And what's wrong about this to me is, like, imagine you're a three-year-old and you see a marshmallow.
11:48
I mean, it's just a miracle.
16:39
Anything else we can do to sort of live in the present and embrace the small stuff?
7:42
So how did we reach this point? 'Cause it, it seems to me like a very, as you just sort of touched on there, incremental process.
7:49
It's incremental, that's right.
7:51
Yeah, the, I think that it's all about making things work better.
7:55
You know? That's sort of the fundamental motivation.
7:58
A- and that could be technological advances.
8:01
You know? So, uh, one of the things that I talk about in the book is the stick shift car, which I, I, I wrote a piece about for The Atlantic.
8:06
It was one of the ways I got inspired to write the book.
10:34
Do you think, like, 'cause some people will, will, perhaps younger people, like, you know, I'm, I don't want to generalize, but will, will read this sort of without probably digging into it deeply enough and think, "Well, that's, it's just an old person's thing."
19:14
But being in the academia scene.
19:16
Even in the, in the '90s, I had sort of-- You know, I'd been working, I was working on my PhD, and I was pointed in the direction of an academic career.
19:26
But I was also-- First of all, I was making, like, much better money in the technology and media industries than I thought I could as a French professor or something, right? And my doctorate is in a field called comparative literature, which sounds like it's about literature, and it is, but it's, it's kind of a place where, like, media studies sort of happen and where, like, people could bring together lots of different stuff and, and, and, and, and try to make interesting new amalgams of them.
19:54
And that, and that's what drew me to everything that's interested me.
19:57
It was like, I'm interested in art, and I'm interested in computers, and I'm interested in video games as an expression of art and culture and computers together.
20:04
And, and that was something I was really trying to activate.
20:08
And luckily, when the opportunity to go to Georgia Tech in 2004 arose to, to work in a, a program in digital media, [lip smacks] that idea of putting together theoretical, philosophical, conceptual thinking about how computing was changing culture and practical hands-on design-oriented practice, that was what that...

53 MINS LATER

73:45
[instrumental music]
9:44
What do you see we're trading off, and what are we losing?
9:47
My name for this process is dematerialization, and it's this process of having been decoupled or disconnected from the physical world.
9:57
And you've named, you know, a number of examples that I discuss in the book, and there's a lot more that people could think of that I don't talk about in the book.
10:04
When you go into the airport restroom and you're trying to, like, wave your hands under the faucet to get it turned on, there's a sensor and an integrated circuit there, but that's not a computer really.
10:12
It's not like a smartphone problem.
10:15
Whereas the QR code example very much is the sort of way that we've been digitized.
10:19
The manual transmission is a different kind of example where certain kind of efficiencies that, you know, generally it's easier to drive an automatic transmission car.

23 MINS LATER

33:38
Is this an accurate characterization of the philosophy? And then how do we put that signal into software? Because inherently, it doesn't have that rich signal in so many ways.
5:08
Some people think it's necessary.
5:10
Yeah.
5:11
I talk about it a bit in the book, and it's great so long as self-care doesn't mean I need to take a break from all of those big-stuff pursuits in order that I can get back to them as soon as possible.
5:23
And if you're doing, like, mindfulness exercises or meditation or you're going to the spa, you're getting your nails done or whatever it is, only in order to give yourself a break from all of the overwork at, uh, at your job or at home, then you're not living in the moment in the way that I'm suggesting.
5:38
However, if you think of every moment as being a potential, like, self-care kind of moment because your senses are always available to you and you're always living in your body, then that gives you a chance to, like, you know, just eke out a little bit of that pleasure as much as you want anytime.
9:43
Yeah.
9:43
Well, they're meant to fill in that blank.
9:45
And often they'll go straight to this sort of feeling of, "Wait, am I happy? I don't think I am." Or, "If I am, what would make me happier?" And it's acquiring more.
5:39
... satisfaction with gratification? How are those different concepts?
5:43
I thought about this a lot when I was working on the book.
5:44
I've always had a lot of trouble with kind of happiness science or with happiness as a concept.
5:50
I don't think the people who know me wouldn't consider me a happy person exactly, or someone who, who's pursued that.
5:56
So it's always been a struggle for me to understand what does that even mean? And I think what it mean...
6:01
You know, there, there's a lot of writing and a lot of research on this topic, and often it's self-identified.
6:06
It's if you ask someone, "Are you happy?" Then do you say yes or no, or how happy are you? Which doesn't really define the concept, does it? So I think of it as this kind of overarching big picture, how good is my life going by my account of it? That's the idea.
9:08
So how do you, how do we deal with that?
11:31
Where does optimization culture fit into the gratification argument?
11:38
The forces that have disconnected us from everyday life, w- I have this name dematerialization for all of those different forces, technology, bureaucracy, efficiency, um, even economic factors.
11:51
They have been leaning toward optimization and efficiency for years and years and years now.
11:57
And so we've been sort of slowly led to believe, so much that we don't even realize we're believing it, that all that matters are outcomes, especially m- measurable outcomes.
12:08
And so anything that isn't focused on a future goal feels like it's not worth doing or that it's less worth doing than something else.
12:16
And, like, one way to think about the gratification problem is in terms of the difference between goals or outcomes and experiences, 'cause the experiences are, are different from The outcomes that they might produce.
12:32
So think about this in, like, really simple terms.

28 MINS LATER

40:24
Give me some things that, that people can, can, can do to help the small stuff feel more present in their lives.
3:33
Can you just give us a couple examples of kind of
3:35
the sort of thing you're thinking? So one of the examples that everyone, I think, has experienced is if you go to like a convention center or an airport or any public building, really, and you need to go to the restroom, you no longer touch anything.
3:50
And you may think, I don't want to touch things in the restroom.
3:53
But then you put your hands under the faucet and there's a sensor and it kind of doesn't work or maybe it works a little bit and then it stops.
3:59
Right.
4:00
The soap is like that, and the towel is like that, and the toilet might flush with you still on it because it thinks you're all done.
4:08
Terrifying the children.
5:48
So what do you, and we're going to go into the door example in particular a little bit later in greater depth, but what do you think the components of a gratifying physical experience are?
16:48
... 'cause it never works.
16:49
It never works and, and, and it doesn't really save water or, or other kinds of resources, uh, uh, either.
16:55
Uh, it's done because it makes things, uh ...
16:57
It makes those kind of spaces easier to manage, uh, for the, the operators of the, uh, of, of the building.
17:04
So, like, t- to kind of take that idea and connect it back to parents and kids, I think what we have to realize is that first, our lives are by and large good, and they're better than they used to be at a historical scale.
17:16
We're living very well collectively, even if there are problems.
17:20
But second, we must live in the present and into the future.
20:08
in some ways.
10:52
It's like, what do we mean by meaningful? What makes something meaningful versus not meaningful?
10:57
So this concept which I call gratification, which is all about being connected to the physical world.
11:03
This gives you a sense of grounding.
11:05
It makes you feel purpose, and it also...
11:07
You know, we live in these, in these physical human bodies that we carry with us everywhere we go, whether we like it or not.
11:14
We may think that a lot of our lives have been mediated or digitized, or we don't really need our bodies anymore, or that they're secondary to our computers and our smartphones, but they're not.
11:24
We still live in the world inside these bodies.

6 MINS LATER

17:16
Mm-hmm
17:02
In a, in a heartbeat
17:02
... "let's talk about why you're here." And some of them are there because they're interested in game design, and programming a very simple old computer like the Atari VCS is one way of kind of getting back to basics, almost like doing figure drawing or something like that, right? Or color theory.
17:18
That's one reason folks are there.
17:20
Some of them are just interested.
17:21
Um, but, you know, knowing how to work at the, at the metal, close to the metal like that with a microcontroller in assembly, that's, that's very uncommonly taught even in a computer science degree anymore, and that does have some value, 'cause you, you may still have to learn some new chip set, um, and write efficient code at a, at a very low level.
17:41
You might not, but if you're an electrical engineer, you would.
17:44
So I try to make it such that students can interpret value in various ways.

8 MINS LATER

25:19
... a, a universe inside it.

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.