Skip to main content
Helen Thomas

Helen Thomas

American reporter and author

Oct 29, 2026

7:40
Do you believe him?
7:41
No, I don't.
7:42
I understand why he says it.
7:44
And I understand the idea that this may well just be an option.
7:48
It is an option I think will become increasingly the one they'll take because the drumbeat of a lot of our discussion here now and from your listeners, and in fact, was it Andy? Yeah, everyone's called Andy.
7:59
Everyone's called Andy, was pointing out there, which is that, If you've got the big ideas, if you want to do big things and you're just having to be constrained to do piecemeal steps, then everyone will be saying do more.
8:09
In fact, the opposition will be saying do more.
9:02
And he
1:36
What do you make about the groups that are being given bonuses and the groups that may be being taxed from?
1:42
Yeah, I mean, the context for this is, and I'm sure we'll go into this, that effectively it's a springboard into an early election.
1:50
Because you show the constraint of the Starmer Reefs manifesto to your point there, that it is, let's get away from that, it didn't work.
1:58
Give us a new mandate, which Alice has been talking about in the wonderful...
2:03
City AM crew.
2:05
So what I think therefore is interesting about the budget will be quite a specific winner versus loser in the sense of making sure your core vote comes out to vote.
2:17
So I think the most eye-catching of course was, and I love the way Healy said that, he said £100 direct into your bank account for people living in council tax band A to D homes.
4:13
Do
10:09
Are you clear on what a Burnham economy or this Labour government's economic big idea is?
10:18
I don't think so.
10:20
But I do think we'll get the set of values.
10:23
We had some of those from Burnham, which will matter to voters.
10:26
We will get that and we will get a sense of what that means economically.
10:30
I mean, if you want to delve into the ideology of this, it's to do with the productive state and how the state will then sort of... bear down on some of the cost of these utilities and things like that.
10:44
So sort of state involvement, but in a way that helps everybody out.
15:47
Do you believe him?
2:19
OK, Helen, let's get your view on the politics of it as well, but perhaps set it for us in the context of that all-important OBR analysis, starting with the growth forecasts.
2:30
Yeah, I mean, the growth forecast was up a bit, down a bit.
2:34
We're still hanging around 1% in all these years going forwards, which is still rather anemic.
2:39
We've got borrowing numbers look like they will be up over this period, which is not that surprising given what has happened since March in terms of rising inflation, rising interest rates, etc.
2:52
So, you know, the challenge that Alice was referring to, the constraints are only getting more constraining and we may touch on as we look forwards, that that could bite even harder.
3:02
So, yeah, the...
3:05
I think, you know, there was always focus on the headroom and the...
5:41
Are we really expecting that Labour MPs will vote through those sorts of public spending cuts? Or is it just more argument in favour of the theory that they'll never have to consider it because they'll have gone to the country long before then?
15:17
Okay, it could fade away, but if the mood continues deteriorating in the way it's done for the last few weeks and months, then, yeah, we've come to perhaps an endgame for a regime that we've been running more or less since the post-Thatcher Reagan era, I would say.
15:38
Can I jump in? Two parts.
15:41
One is...
15:43
Short-term optimism, because actually, I think the government will jump through the relevant hurdles regarding the markets with this budget, notwithstanding some volatility.
15:54
But it's actually more the voters and the party, the Labour Party, that will cause headaches for Burnham and Healey rather than markets, I think, because they are aware.
16:08
They are at least aware.
16:09
They may not know how to deal with it, but they're very aware.

5 MINS LATER

21:37
And now what is going to be interesting if that does happen? How is the electorate going to feel when that turns out to be, dare one say, a bit of a shambles?
6:30
It does inflation.
6:32
has always had huge political ramifications.
6:35
You could go back to like the Roman Empire and the constant, the denarii, these little silver coins getting devalued as they try and pay for these huge wars.
6:47
And I don't say that lightly, actually.
6:48
You know, I'm saying it sort of...
6:51
Not jokingly, but it's to show you that inflation, as you said, kitchen table issue affects everybody.
6:57
It doesn't actually even matter what level you're at.

12 MINS LATER

19:04
How do you think that the market can generally continue with these kind of rates? And will this put pressure on equity markets?
5:57
I- II, is it, is it turning out that way? I mean, how does it, how does what, uh, he, how does he affect, do you think, where rates in, in the US may, may head next? What's he, what's he said so far?
6:06
far?The chair of the Federal Reserve is always extremely important for, uh, US interest rates.
6:12
I remember a Fed watcher from years ago saying to me, "Look, they're not a democracy." We sometimes get in the, you know, weeds of who voted for this, that, and the other, but it's not a democracy.
6:22
So they really set the tone.
6:23
Um, also, just to step back from the specifics here, um, new, uh, leaders tend to like to appoint their own person at the central bank.
6:33
Uh, George Osborne did that with Mark Carney, people may remember in the UK.
6:36
In Japan, there was, uh, Abenomics under Shinzo Abe.

18 MINS LATER

24:49
I mean, what's gonna happen to, um, markets in the short and medium term? What, what sort of things should people be weighing up, do you think, at the moment around what, you know, where rates are potentially heading?
15:46
And again, that's sort of like the global repercussions that you're seeing.
15:50
Well, what we're talking about a lot today, Tom, is paradigm shifts in the global economy and global financial markets.
15:58
That 20-year-long period of low inflation and low interest rates gone, dead and buried.
16:05
We're in a higher inflation, higher interest rate world.
16:07
And it's been like that pretty much since the pandemic and will persist that for at least a decade or more.
16:13
So, first of all...
16:16
What we are talking about, this mind shift, we're at the foothills.

21 MINS LATER

37:41
That was, I mean, that's a big name, isn't it? That's a big chunk of money going.
29:52
I'm gonna have to do some maths here to get an average.
29:54
[laughs] Yeah.
29:55
Oh, yeah.
29:55
That's, uh...
29:56
Well, they, uh, are taking on from what Simon was saying.
30:01
The central banks, I think, have got a longer role to play in this.
30:04
They're a multi, they're a multi-decade villain potentially.
31:15
You think it's the top?
4:31
And I think garden centres are able to do that.
4:35
My name is Helen Thomas, I work for Plantworks.
4:38
I began within the science team within the company but fairly quickly moved to looking after the southeast region sales and now I do a little bit of marketing and also still involved in the sales for the southeast.
4:57
so over the last few years obviously it's a lot of um changes within the industry um we had the pandemic we had um that period where everybody was trapped inside but possibly the only uh silver lining was that people became more aware of their gardens of their house plants people began to engage with things like grow your own which is absolutely fantastic and also younger people and um i'd just love to see that momentum continue really um yeah get get more young people get kids involved get teenagers involved get um students get people involved because it is a fantastic thing it's brilliant for your mental health it's brilliant for meeting people social connections it's just a fantastic community and I would love that to just continue to grow really thank you

15 MINS LATER

21:13
I'm the National Sales Manager for the Heart of Eden brand.
21:16
I'd like some clarity on the peat ban.
7:12
I think things start to look considerably better.
7:16
Yeah, I mean, there's no doubt that there's been actual supply changes that have happened.
7:21
There has been shortages, and there has been this issue on fertilizer regarding the planting timelines.
7:29
So there has, in a sense, yes, there's been economic damage done, but there's been that adjustment, as you pointed out.
7:34
The adjustment has actually been very rapid.
7:36
I was quite interested to see Japan... talked about, they were saying in May, half of our oil will not come through the Strait of Hormuz.
7:44
I believe they've increased that up to almost 100%.

9 MINS LATER

16:27
I had a full head of hair before I started looking at the Bank of England, just to be clear.
15:56
the UK to start with, yes.
15:57
Well, I think equities must be kept separate from what's happening in the bond markets.
16:07
We're in a bit of a strange parallel universe between the two, where there's quite a lot of rising tide lifts all boats on equities globally that is helping in the UK.
16:18
And of course, FTSE 100 companies are hugely international.
16:20
They're not a bellwether really for the UK, as you've talked about many times, both of you.
16:26
And then the bond market, which as we've talked about, has all these vulnerabilities.
16:29
I think it's just, it pays to do your homework.

5 MINS LATER

21:40
supply chain as well, isn't it? We
3:28
And that is a very serious problem in particular for the UK.
3:32
Absolutely.
3:33
So the way I think people need to look at this, this is a physical issue.
3:38
It's had an overlap into financial markets.
3:41
It's got political beginnings and it may have political ends, but the physical side of this can't be undone.
3:48
Right.
3:48
So the way I found useful to look at this is the ever given ship.

16 MINS LATER

19:50
And we did have a guest on the other day who suggested that at some point the government will have no choice but to slash the coupon on existing guilt, you know, old-fashioned, full-on financial repression slash default.
20:07
in that year onwards.
20:09
And so, actually, I think that the risk of this unravelling, I mean, we're here less than 24 hours later, is extremely high that this unravels.
20:19
Don't forget that just because she made the statement doesn't mean it's all...
20:22
It gets through, yeah.
20:24
You have to vote on each tax measure.
20:26
Then there's a second reading.
20:28
I mean, there's the whole finance bill that goes through.

19 MINS LATER

39:39
1976, Helen? I
26:23
Um, how much notice should we take of the IMF and what, what, what do you, uh, analyze from what they said today?
26:29
Uh, well, you're right about, uh, focusing on the trend rather than the real point one base point here and there on specifics because it is really quite difficult to get these sorts of forecasts right.
26:41
But I think it's a, it's a broader, broader comment here that, you know, the period since the pandemic ushered in a much higher inflation era.
26:49
So we should...
26:49
We're used to...
26:50
Now as you say, not in the 1970s levels, but higher than the la- prior sort of 15-year period, if not 20-year period.
26:57
So I think what's quite significant is we're in a higher inflation period and that the UK is consistently coming out as one of those higher inflation economies.
27:57
How much effect do you think these forecasts are going to have on Rachel Reeves' calculations?
110:21
Um, what's your view on whether she, her position is under threat?
110:24
threat?I, it certainly is, and I think that is because of the actions she has taken over this last year, because there was, of course, the rise in National Insurance, which she herself had described as a tax on jobs, you know, when she was in opposition.
110:41
Um, and, of course, what a many focus groups describe as the original sin of the removal of Winter Fuel, uh, Allowance, which has obviously now been U-turned.
110:51
Uh, frankly, it's just all adding up to being a bit of a mess, and I think if the government had a better narrative, they might be able to sell it, but that's, that just seems to be falling apart at the moment, unfortunately for them.
111:14
So they, they, they're rather tied together, aren't they?
111:16
Well, they are, and historically, gosh, you can go back a very long way.
111:21
It's very difficult to lose your chancellor and continue as prime minister.
111:24
In fact, you probably know better than me, uh, when that happened in history, um, as you, you're a real political aficionado.
17:58
I think, Helen, where are you on the tariffs at the moment?
18:02
I mean, I think we are getting towards it settling where it was going to always settle, which was this idea of there being like a kind of baseline 10%.
18:12
But what is, I think, relevant and people touched on it there about the tariffs.
18:16
I mean, if you go back to the Liberation Day announcement and you look at the actual White House statement of what they're about, the important thing is it says, you know, reciprocal tariffs for economic and national security.
18:31
It is not a purely just an economic point here.
18:36
This is all tied up with defense being part of the American umbrella.
18:41
It is, you know, economic war in terms of rebalancing the powers, as Pippa has said there.

7 MINS LATER

25:54
Helen, what are you worried about? I
13:03
So as an investor, how do you respond to that kind of thing I've just told you?
13:10
I think that is to do with assessing where you think this is all going to end up, which requires an understanding of political aims, political power, political constraints, just in the way that you would look and say years ago, oh, inflation spiked a bit higher.
13:28
Does the central bank look through it? What's the argument they're making? Who's the hawk? Who's the dove? Where's the pressure? You know, we're all used to those things.
13:35
We're just used to them with a different style of person.
13:37
I totally get your point that Trump is a different character.
13:41
Not, again, though, not an unknown quantity.
13:44
I remember Trump won, you know, where we all had to spend our time looking at Twitter.

12 MINS LATER

25:30
And so Europe now is being forced to kind of get its act together and sort of step up, you know, both in terms of defence, military, obviously, but then also more generally, you know, do they have like a national economic sort of policy and, you know, how do they step up to the global stage? So how do you view Europe in all of this?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.