Skip to main content
Helen Miller

Helen Miller

Nov 2, 2026

8:19
So could you try and summarise that if you can?
8:22
Yeah, let me have a go.
8:23
I think budget documents are always a bit hard to read if you're just a normal person at home.
8:28
I think there's two ways to think of how a budget affects you.
8:30
One is the individual measures that will immediately either give money to people or take money away from people.
8:36
And the other is the backdrop.
8:38
How's the economy running? How's that going to affect you? So on the immediate bit of it...

39 MINS LATER

47:30
Can you explain what's going on there? Because I know in previous budgets, they have not been happy.
Faisal Islam
Faisal IslamCORRESPONDENT
18:14
And to give a sense, it's 10% up in the 2010s and about 20% to 30% up before that.
18:20
So a really big change.
18:21
We got to the end of that decade, and obviously the pandemic was right at the end of that, but it really seemed like we'd been through a really rough decade.
18:28
And then you pop on the line for this decade, it's basically flat as a pancake, much, much flatter than all the other lines.
18:37
This now looks like it's going to be the worst decade for growth in household incomes that we have, at least in this chart.
18:45
And for people at home, that really matters.
18:47
That just means that this pattern we got used to of year on year, you get better off, your incomes rise, you have more wages, you can buy more stuff, you feel better off.
23:03
So maybe as a society we can cope with quite big variations in...
13:21
Do you think lenders to the UK believe that's credible?
13:24
So there's a few things to unpack there.
13:25
I mean, people who are lending to the UK don't take exactly what the government says as given.
13:32
They probably already think actually bond will be a bit higher than they're saying.
13:35
So in some ways, that's already a bit baked in.
13:38
It's also absolutely right.
13:39
The government doesn't have to find 35 billion tomorrow.
16:31
I
4:35
What is the big number that you are aiming for?
4:40
So the number I've picked is 35 billion.
4:44
That's a number we published in a big report at the start of the week.
4:47
And basically, that's a measure of the spending pressures that I think are facing John Healy.
4:52
So long story short, John Healy inherited a set of plans that spending plans for departments.
4:57
So things like NHS, health, education, police, they already look pretty tight.
5:03
Now we're facing much higher inflation.

15 MINS LATER

20:33
Where were you on the steady as she goes or Big Bang budget?
18:52
And- In overall terms, is that the big picture of what has happened in Iran and the impact of the Strait of Hormuz and the inflationary pe-pressures that the economy is now under?
19:03
Yeah.
19:04
So thanks to the war, energy prices have gone up.
19:06
That's pushing other prices across the economy up.
19:09
And in the same way that inflation is squeezing households' budgets, it's going to squeeze government departments' budgets.
19:14
So as you look forward, things like the NHS, education, police aren't going to be able to buy as much with their cash budgets because of those higher prices.
19:23
But on top of that, actually, if you wind back to March, Rachel Reeves had already penciled in a set of spending plans in coming years that looked f-pretty tight, looked like actually under reasonable assumptions for the NHS, you'd need to make spending cuts of something like nine billion.

9 MINS LATER

28:54
But what are you hearing from within the Treasury about w- where their thinking is on some of these questions that you've outlined?
7:55
Is there a way you can read across from the bond yields today, the interest rates today, to how much money he's got to play with at the end of October? And I know it's not as simple as that, but is there a way of, of joining the two things up?
8:08
Yes, but I mean, yes.
8:09
I mean, it's worth saying it's not the only factor in town, right? There are other things, uh, going on.
8:13
Um, for, so for example, if the OBR revises down its forecast of migration, that will also push up on borrowing.
8:19
So interest rates are only one factor in town.
8:22
But basically, the higher up interest rate goes, the less, the less headroom John Healey will have against his fiscal rules.
8:29
Um, it's going to depend on, you know, when the OBR decides to look at interest rates, lots of other factors.

11 MINS LATER

19:44
Oh, so saying, "Don't worry, we'll address this next year," is actually not a great strategy fiscally.
28:49
And yeah, Helen, do you think the appointment of John Healey as Chancellor after he resigned as Defense Secretary over that means that the defense budget kind of ballooning is inevitable? He can't really be the Chancellor that sticks with the previous defense spending plans that he resigned over, can he?
29:04
Well, oh, it's gonna look pretty odd, having argued really hard to go to 3%, to then be in charge of that decision and say, "Actually, I've changed my mind." I mean, I think we should remember as a country, it's not inevitable.
29:14
It is a choice that we can make about how much to spend on defense, and you can argue for 3 or another number, but there's no, there's no law of the nature that says we have to be 3.
29:22
But yeah, John Healey was quite clear that he wanted to get to 3.
29:25
Um, but, but as we, you know, we're just saying, it's, that is, that is a big increase.
29:29
To get from where we are now to 3%, you need to find something like 10, 11 billion.
29:35
If you want to get all the way to 3.5%, you have to find another 20 billion.

6 MINS LATER

35:24
Which has turned out to be true, yeah.
18:52
That's gonna be the cheapest place to develop this." So what is it that's stopping that? And obviously, it's the, uh, it's the set of interactions you need to make that kind of productive business flourish.
19:04
No, I think another way to say that that makes it clear in some sense why This is less asinine than it sounds in a sense, is that one thing that people look at is income inequality or wealth inequality, and they turn to the, well, let's just redistribute some income.
19:17
Let's, uh, do tax and transfers of some sort.
19:19
Let's just tax the rich more and give more to the poor, so more welfare benefits, for example.
19:23
Let's do minimum wages.
19:24
Let's take...
19:25
You know, the problem is people have low wages, let's give them higher minimum wages, and that'll solve the problem.

16 MINS LATER

35:06
I hope so.
1:43
I can't believe this is on our doorstep.
1:46
How long has it been there for? Okay, so it's been there since 2019.
1:49
It was set up actually by a retired chocolate manufacturer who's called Clive Beecham.
1:55
He ran a company called Kineton, actually.
1:58
So it's not Cadbury's, it's not Bourneville or anything like that.
2:00
It's the Kineton Chocolate Company.
2:03
company and it was a company that still exists actually but he sold it it's it's a company that makes chocolate novelties for christmases and things like that and for you know disney and and companies like that you might have um bought some in marks and spencers or have you so so when he retired he decided he wanted to set up a heritage craft center he's very interested in vintage cars And, you know, how difficult it was to or is to find the parts to repair those cars.
6:27
How can the community engage more with what's going on at Grandest Place? Because I think a lot of people still don't know it's there, don't know that this is happening right next to us.
Ilya Marritz
Ilya MarritzCORRESPONDENT
2:53
She is the director of a think tank, the Institute for Fiscal Studies, IFS, and she told me these stories can be overwhelming, so it helps to look at them as symptoms of a single underlying issue.
3:06
If there's one big-picture thing that's happening in the UK, I think it's low growth.
3:10
For many years now, the extent to which the economy is growing has, has been much lower than it was, you know, i- in prior decades, and that is underlying a lot of the government's problems.
3:19
It's why it's hard to run the public finances because, you know, we have a big debt pile.
3:24
It's hard to pay off that debt if you haven't got a growing economy.
3:26
It's hard to get people into work if the economy's not growing healthily.
3:29
So I think underlying a lot of these things are, is just the problem of low growth.
Ilya Marritz
Ilya MarritzCORRESPONDENT
8:29
But Helen Miller says it is the wrong framing for the United Kingdom.
18:18
Actually, loads of reforms are put in, net migration basically plunges, and then there ends up being a conversation about, oh, it's now too low.
18:26
I mean, possibly.
18:27
I mean, it- I think, you know, you can imagine it in, we've had this before, in certain sectors there being shortages of workers where even if you want to train British workers, it takes a while to do.
18:36
You know, think of, like, health and social care being good examples of that.
18:38
You might think that we get to a place where actually we need more workers.
18:41
Part of what we need to do therefore is think now about the kind of workers we might think of needing in the future years, what does training look like, whether that's, you know, general training and further education or specific training for specific sectors.
18:53
Um, in some sense, if we don't want higher migration, don't rely on that being the valve through which we adjust our labor markets, thinking about how we...

7 MINS LATER

Joe Pike
Joe PikeCORRESPONDENT
25:42
Right.
10:14
Is that a fair way of, of looking at the balance?
10:18
I think it's true to say you have to find a way to pay for welfare spending.
10:21
It, it's, as Ben said, there are sufficiently big sums here.
10:25
This isn't, isn't the money you find in the back of the sofa.
10:26
If you really want to meaningfully increase defense spending, um, on a permanent basis, not just for the next year, you gotta fund it.
10:33
Now, you either gotta fund it by higher taxes, that would be significant.
10:36
So if you wanna find an extra fifteen billion, you're looking at one or two percentage points on the rate of VAT, for example, or you cut other spending.

11 MINS LATER

21:24
Uh, but it looks like the UK had theirs cut by more than most people did.
11:18
So if I had to say one, that's the one I'd go for.
11:21
And actually for what it's worth, I'd pick that one too.
11:22
I've met my career.
11:23
We can pick some more as well.
11:24
There are plenty of others, don't worry.
11:25
But I think it's worth, that's a great case study of some of the points we talked about earlier because there are these absurd differences.
11:31
But the rate differences are very salient.

26 MINS LATER

37:31
So you think that makes it harder to be bolder, just the nature and the cycle of how we make policy?
6:56
So classic more or less question, is 1.5% growth a big number?
7:02
Well, I think it's worth kind of orienting ourselves.
7:04
Whenever you're talking about growth in the economy, they're all small numbers in some sense.
7:08
So you should be thinking of small numbers.
7:11
In that context, 1.5 is bigger than we've seen recently, but smaller than historically.
7:15
So pan back decades, we got used to a situation in which the economy grew by something like 2, 2.5% every year.
7:25
Then post-financial crisis, it grew by something more like, you know, half a percent or so.
8:34
So can you give us the big picture on government spending today?
25:05
Give us a simple one then.
25:07
Uh, housing taxes is a great example, lots of kites being flown about whether she'll try to put higher taxes on higher value houses.
25:14
We have a housing tax system that is embarrassing honestly, I mean the council tax is based on values from 1991.
25:21
Can you imagine doing that with any other part of the tax system? Taxing incomes or spending from 1991 is, it's just mad.
25:28
It's regressive, meaning that higher value properties pay a smaller share of their property value in tax, and we have this stamp duty which I think deserves a good kicking at every possible opportunity, it's a dreadful bit of the tax system.
25:41
So rather than just tweak the rates of this or find a way to prop up council tax, let's revalue council tax.
25:46
Let's base it on up-to-date values.
28:50
You'd get rid of it?
32:12
Yeah,
32:13
so I think the way to think of it is, I mean, obviously, there's a politics here about how people feel about employer national insurance.
32:19
I mean, currently there's a big subsidy to pension savings and it's a big subsidy related to employer pension contributions.
32:27
Remember, I think it's a name that's a bit misleading in some sense.
32:30
So many people make their own pension contributions, but they do it by agreeing with their employer.
32:37
They do it through salary sacrifice.
32:38
So you agree with your employer that they will reduce your salary by a certain amount and they will put that money into a pension.

12 MINS LATER

44:45
It's not good if the intervention is not actually ultimately helping these children.
14:59
Do we have data on that? Would the treasury know whether they've kind of lost money as a result of it?
15:05
I think you might be able to know eventually.
15:06
I think it's really hard to know in advance.
15:08
I think the non-dom one is an interesting kind of thing about a broader point.
15:11
Now, the way we tax non-doms I think was actually a bit silly.
15:15
The whole concept of non-dom is really archaic and old-fashioned.
15:19
It, like, depends on where your father was born, um, and, and a whole bunch of circumstances which really, the tax system shouldn't be caring about.
17:07
Yeah, exactly.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.