Skip to main content
Gerald Murray

Gerald Murray

Fr. Gerald E. Murray, J.C.D., canon lawyer and pastor of Holy Family Church in New York City, regular EWTN commentator on "The World Over" and author of "Calming the Storm."

Nov 20, 2026

14:56
Why is Rome micromanaging this at a time when they're saying we're synodal and everybody and their dog should be guiding the church and we should listen to everyone?
15:06
You raise a good point, Raymond.
15:07
Yeah, exactly.
15:08
I mean, if the pope is saying that you're free to ask for dispensations, the next question is, well, therefore, the presumption is it's a good thing to have the traditional Latin mass.
15:17
So why this extra obstacle, this hurdle you have to go through? Now, secondly, what if your bishop doesn't want to apply for a dispensation? Can a parish priest apply for a dispensation? No.
15:27
So it's up to the bishop to ask for it.
15:30
And then is wrong going to grant every dispensation? That's another question we have here.
19:51
So what's the problem here?
16:37
What's your objection there?
16:39
Yes, synodality is a whole program and it's got an office now that is very powerful within the Holy See, but it's undefined because it's a word that's defining something.
16:55
that was based on a previous practice, which was then abolished by Pope Francis.
16:59
So the brief history is, synod means meeting of bishops.
17:04
It's always meant that.
17:06
And, you know, Second Vatican Council was called the synod because that's how the language is used in Latin.
17:15
Pope Paul VI, following the Second Vatican Council's call for a synod of bishops, created the synod of bishops.

18 MINS LATER

35:14
So what about that? What about Trisicius Custodes, this seeming attack on the tradition of the Church of the traditional Latin Mass?
16:31
Comments?
16:32
Yeah, no, the Senate has become something very dangerous in the life of the church precisely because they're reexamining everything.
16:40
They came out, for instance, recently with a document about canon law in which they said that we need to rewrite the entire code of canon law of both the Latin and the Eastern Church.
16:50
There were two different codes which overlap.
16:53
But anyway, the code of canon law in the Latin Church was reformed and it was issued in 1983.
17:00
And this was a reform that began shortly after Vatican II, and it went on for almost 20 years.
17:07
So they're saying now that something that was given to us, you know, approximately 40 years ago has to be totally redone.

7 MINS LATER

24:00
What say you?
13:25
What about the legitimate taking up of arms to defend one's country? Is the pope basically calling for an absolute pacifism here? And where does that fit into the ancient teaching of the church to say nothing of the Crusades and Lepanto and other notorious and beautiful battles that the church waged in the past?
13:44
Well, in the Reconquista of Spain after the Muslim invasion, you know, and they got a Charles Martel, you know, he's honored in France because he rolled back the invaders.
13:54
You know, this is a little bit concerning because it's not an isolated statement.
13:59
In Magnifico Humanitas, he talks about just war theory needs to be reexamined, preserving the right of self-defense.
14:09
Well, the essence of just war theory is the right of self-defense.
14:13
And the right of self-defense includes your obligation to help the helpless.
14:18
In other words, neighbors who are attacked, who need some defense, you have to come to their aid.
18:20
Is Ireland becoming a new Germany here?
27:25
What does that mean?
27:26
Well, I mean, I can only guess at the full meaning of it.
27:30
Certainly, you know, the word itself, holy war, is not generally what we use in Christianity.
27:38
It's used in Islam, jihadism.
27:42
You know, Muhammad was a warrior.
27:45
His followers, you know, engaged in warfare, you know, different Medina and Mecca and all these things described during Muhammad's lifetime.
27:54
And then the history of the spread of Islam was by the sword, you know, the sword of the prophet, as it was called.
31:14
What would you say?
26:57
How do you see it?
26:58
Yes.
26:58
Well, um, Pope John Paul II said he did not say that the death penalty is immoral, but he did make the judgment that its application, uh, in the current modern world, uh, makes it rare, uh, if ever happening.
27:13
In other words, he tried to, uh, demonstrate that according to him, the goals that the death penalty seeks to, um, bring about of reparation for the crime and protection of the community from future crime by the convicted killer, uh, that that can be achieved by, uh, putting the person behind bars for life.
27:35
But he did not say that the death penalty is immoral per se.
27:39
Pope Francis, um, did not like the death penalty.
27:43
He said it was a violation of human dignity.

8 MINS LATER

35:27
Should he be executed on live television?
5:34
The question is should they go to them with the answers of the world?
5:39
Well, you know, when you start, exactly, when you start talking about fragility, um, the question is, well, what, what's the cause of the fragility? And of course we know what it is.
5:49
It's, it's human weakness due to original sin, our own personal sins.
5:53
But the implication of a lot of what's been going on recently is people are made fragile because the gospel is presented in an un-Christian and too hard fashion.
6:03
In other words, the doctrine doesn't respond to the real-life situation of people, and therefore, the doctrine has to be changed.
6:10
So when talking about divorce and remarriage, which is always a sadness in, in the life of any couple, um, the, the problem is not that Jesus said that what God has joined, man must not divide.
6:22
The problem is that man does divide what God has joined at times.

27 MINS LATER

33:35
In, in chapter six you write, "Our duty is to call out erring shepherds," quote, "rebuking them with the charity of truth." Where is that line between filial correction and rebellion? And how faithful Catholics, how, how are they to know whether they're on the right side of it?
21:19
W- did you feel like it was d- different than normal? Was it above average during his pontificate?
21:26
It was because what, uh, on a few cases, Amoris Laetitia, Fiducia Supplicans, and the Abu Dhabi doc-documents.
21:34
So the Abu Dhabi was about God willed all religions.
21:37
Uh, no pope would ever said that.
21:39
Uh, Fiducia Supplicans is that people and homosexual couples or same-sex couples could be blessed.
21:45
No pope ever said that.
21:47
And then communion could be given to people living in a publicly known adultery.

23 MINS LATER

44:26
What say you?
36:30
This seems upside down.
36:32
Yes, no, and that really is what I contend is to be the essence of the whole synodal project, which is a shared governance in the church by lay people and together with the bishops.
36:42
But in practicality, the bishops be overwhelmed by the lay people demanding this, that and the other thing.
36:49
No, the Synod, by the way, is the Synod of Bishops.
36:52
That's what the Second Vatican Council created, and it's based on the ancient practice of bishops meeting in synods.
36:59
But the Synod of Bishops did not include what Pope Francis made it into, which is basically a sort of semi-parliament, an assembly of all the different people of the church, bishops, priests, deacons, religious, lay people, etc.
37:15
And even at the Synod, you had non-believers and people who were doubters, who were invited to be members So, you know, this really is a troublesome thing that's going on.
42:16
How long do you think, what would you do, what would need to be done to reverse the course of some of the damages that we've seen in the church these last several decades for sure, especially synodality? What do we do to reverse it? How long does that take?
25:43
Uh, was he secretly a Red without us understanding it?
25:46
Uh, no, that's a falsification of history.
25:49
In fact, uh, ask the people of Poland were they happy under communism or what they have now.
25:53
Of course, they're happy with what they have now.
25:55
They have freedom.
25:56
They can leave their country.
25:57
They can put money in the bank.

21 MINS LATER

46:57
the gleaning laws would be a good example of a political construct that, um, that allows the poor to go out into the fields and, and glean
9:58
¿Dónde, diría, termina ese derecho del paciente de decidir sobre su vida, sus decisiones personales y esa libertad religiosa que tenemos aquí en Estados Unidos? Que es una gran pregunta.
10:09
No, si una persona que está en una casa de viejos que quiere quitarse la vida, tiene que quitarse la casa.
10:16
Tiene que ir a otro lugar para hacer, porque es un pecado y no se puede decir, Quiero recibir el sueño o la ayuda de la gente católica, pero quiere matarme a la misma vez.
10:28
No. Hay que decirle a la gente, aquí en la vida hay amor y sostener a la gente que necesita amor.
10:37
No hay que decirle, mátase porque así se puede quise.
10:43
It's something that I can't imagine, the government telling monks to do something that goes against the law of God, but it's happening in this state of New York, yes.
10:52
And how important could this case be in terms of possibly establishing a precedent on religious freedom in this country? Because it's not just New York that now has this law that will come into force on August 5th, but there are several more states in the country that already have laws like this approved.
11:12
No, ese es el problema porque lo que comienza en un lugar puede expandir y puede ser presente en los estados.
42:13
And the question I have, Father, is does the SSPX situation, does this highlight, does this put a big highlight on the need to be more generous to Catholics who want more of the patrimony and traditions of Holy Mother Church and not less? Because it feels lately that there has just been a vice grip clamp in many dioceses across the United States and the West, in particular, against traditional Catholics.
42:40
No, I think it does require the situation with the Society of St. Pius X does require that the Holy See respond with greater generosity in making available the traditional Latin Mass and the other sacraments to people who find great spiritual strength.
42:57
Cardinal Burke is absolutely right.
42:59
This Mass nourishes the faith.
43:01
It's been a source of spiritual strength.
43:03
You know, the great...
43:05
Mass, in its essence, has been celebrated for 1,500 years, has proven its worth, and since we're a Catholic Church which values tradition, that tradition of prayer and liturgical worship should not be cast aside.
46:31
It feels like the average traditional Catholic who wants it is going to be the one to suffer.
34:29
How do we begin to unravel the judgment of people's hearts?
34:33
Well, you see, the process document, it's called a practice.
34:37
There are two documents that were sent to nuncios by the Casio of the Doctrine of the Faith explaining to bishops what to do regarding both the SSPX priests and then the laity.
34:53
Now, the documents are full of problems, too, because as regards the priests, it never refers to the priests as being excommunicated.
35:01
It refers to them as being under a censure for receiving ordination improperly from an SSPX bishop or having joined the SSPX if they were ordained by another bishop.
35:13
So the priests are not in that practice document ever considered to be excommunicated and there's no provision for lifting of the penalty of excommunication.
35:22
Likewise, the practice for lay people is confusing because it is presumed that they have been somehow been excommunicated by adhering to the doctrinal positions of the SSPX.
36:46
And what kind of a document would that be?
3:56
Sure
3:56
... stylish now is kind of out of style later on.
4:00
Uh, so as regards something called the synodal style, uh, who determines that? Who identifies it? Who understands what it means? Synodality was, is a neologism.
4:11
It's a word that Pope Francis, uh, invented, you could say.
4:15
The word synod exists, but the idea of synodality as describing an aspect of, of the Church, almost a mark of the Church, this is a complete new thing.
4:25
And as with any, you know, uh, verbal engineering, uh, it's the engineers who tell you what it means because otherwise you don't know.
4:32
You, you can't go to a dictionary, you know, written 30 years ago and find out what is synodality, uh, because it doesn't exist.

9 MINS LATER

13:33
I wonder what yours is.
95:30
There's an ongoing debate about is it pastoral, doctrinal? But my simple question is this: Why is assent to the Second Vatican Council necessary if it was described by John XXIII and others as predominantly pastoral in character?
95:50
Well, I'll s- I'll start with a number of points.
95:52
The first is the description of a council by the pope, uh, it doesn't ch- change the nature of a council.
95:59
So as pastoral, meaning the direction was not to, uh, to define dogma against heretical attacks, but rather to promote the mission of the church by adapting the church's apostolate to modern needs.
96:13
I think that's what John XXIII was doing.
96:16
But by its nature, a council teaches, and we have two dogmatic constitutions on the word of God and on the church issued by the church fathers and then approved by Pope Paul VI.
96:27
So it's clear the church, the Va- Vatican Council is, Second Vatican Council is a teaching, uh, um, authority.

38 MINS LATER

134:34
[rock music] Does the existence of more traditional communities, such as the Fraternity of St. Peter, Institute of Christ the King, I think of also Clear Creek Abbey, the Benedictine Monks of Norcia, other traditional communities, does that mitigate their argument for the state of necessity?
41:45
What was your initial reaction to the to the AI encyclical? And I mean, you think it's emotionalism that we're dealing with here? Do they just is everything emotional these days?
41:57
Well, I looked at the encyclical, and I was interested because AI is a very important topic now in discussing education, work, its applications, etc.
42:09
But the encyclical is only about 25% on AI.
42:12
The rest is on Catholic social teaching.
42:15
But it is very thin, I thought.
42:17
It is not very scriptural.
42:19
There are very few citations of St. Thomas Aquinas.
45:42
If you could decide what the cardinals spoke of in the next consistory, what would be the important things? What should they be talking about? If it's not talking about the just war theory or some of this other social synodal whatever.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.