Skip to main content
Eric Mangini

Eric Mangini

American football coach

Nov 18, 2026

2:05
Have you ever heard of it? Did you ever have to do it? I mean, have you ever done that with a coach that you just said halfway through a season, hey, I made a mistake here?
2:14
I've been in situations where I wasn't happy with coaches on the staff, and there were problems that I wanted fixed, but being part of Parcells and Belichick Family Tree, that didn't really remove people during the season.
2:29
And the whole idea was you chose them, you made the decision as to who to hire, and that your job as a head coach was not just to coach the players, but to coach the coaches.
2:39
And if there were things that you didn't like, you needed to have the hard conversations, you needed to address it, and you needed to have enough technical competency to actually understand what the problems were.
2:48
And I think sometimes that's a real issue, Colin, is when a guy is just an expert on one side of the ball and doesn't really understand things, like maybe has a very broad view of the other side of the ball.
3:00
It's a real issue when things are going wrong because he doesn't know how to address the problems.
3:05
And he doesn't know if the answers that guy's giving him are really good answers or not.

8 MINS LATER

10:44
But what's a realistic Fernando Mendoza runway here in the next six, seven weeks?
6:10
With Drake May, where are you now on him and on his ascension?
6:17
Well, when you saw the end of last season, that was problematic.
6:20
And then even going in the early part of this season, it was it was problematic, too.
6:24
And I've said you in the past, I compared him to Sam Darnold coming out of college with some of the ups and downs that he had.
6:30
And I think it was a little bit of that little bit of what Sam Darnold's going through right now is what Drake May was going through.
6:36
Where his confidence got shook and then he had all the expectations going into this season.
6:44
He was a silver medalist for MVP.
speaker_3ADVERTISER
9:08
or could have?
20:48
When you were, when you were coaching, was there anything when you were a head coach you still wanted to call?
20:56
I, I always wanted to be involved in those, in those gotta have it plays.
21:00
So maybe it was a two-point play, maybe it was the, the fourth and one, or fourth and three, or, or whatever it was.
21:08
Whether it was offensively or defensively, you know, we would go through those things during the course of the week.
21:12
We'd practice those things during the course of the week.
21:15
Because what you wanna do is, in the biggest moments, when the games were gonna be decided, to make sure you had exactly what you wanted and what you felt gave you the best chance to win.
21:26
Uh, my, my biggest frustration as a head coach is when we would go through those moments during the week, we'd get to in the game, and then suddenly the offensive coordinator would say, "Well, I had a feeling this other thing would work." And it's like, "No, no, no, no, no.

8 MINS LATER

29:08
[laughs]
4:49
Yeah
4:49
...
4:49
in Atlanta since, the whole season, right? I mean, he, he had two guys he thought were gonna play, and neither one of them could play.
4:55
He was down to his third.
4:56
And what, what's, what's gonna be so interesting about this is so much bravado at the start of the season about how great this offense was, so much talk about how many points they were gonna score.
5:08
So that's not all just Caleb Williams.
5:10
That's about scheme.

6 MINS LATER

11:18
Did you ever, did you ever coach in a culture that is almost ownership down unbreakable?
16:05
But what do you see right now with this raw, very talented guy?
16:11
Yeah, we, we really need to pump the brakes on these young quarterbacks that, that have had a good year.
16:17
Look, look at, look at the gold and silver medalist for the MVP last year.
16:20
When Stafford and, and, and Drake May come out and have terrible first games.
16:25
Everybody just assumes because you have a good season last year, that naturally you're gonna take the, this jump.
16:30
But he's got a, he's got a ton of stuff to work, work on.
16:33
The heroics are, are, are great.
18:41
Yeah
4:58
Why is it so low?
5:01
Yeah, a- and even on the list that you have up of their column, there's no guarantee that these guys are all franchise quarterbacks.
5:08
Remember Carson Wentz was considered a franchise quarterback, and, and then he went through his struggles, and then they, everybody thought that trajectory was gonna continue to go up.
5:17
Trevor's been up and down.
5:18
Brock we've gotta see at a, at a more consistent basis.
5:22
And, and CJ, who knows whether he's even gonna get an extension.
5:26
So but the, the reason it's, it's so hard, I, I think it's, it's multifold, is it's an extremely difficult position to play.

5 MINS LATER

10:57
Right.
37:52
Why is it so low?
37:55
Yeah, a- and even on the list that you have up, of there, Colin, there's no guarantee that these guys are all franchise quarterbacks.
38:01
Remember Carson Wentz was considered a franchise quarterback, and, and then he went through his struggles, and then they, everybody thought that trajectory was gonna continue to go up.
38:11
Trevor's been up and down.
38:12
Brock we've gotta see on a, on a more consistent basis.
38:15
And, and C.J., who knows whether he's even gonna get an extension.
38:20
So but the, the reason it's, it's so hard, I, I think it's, it's multifold is it's an extremely difficult position to play.
43:12
What's the Harbaugh secret?
StugotzADVERTISER
6:25
Your thoughts?
6:27
And in fairness to, to NFL coaches and, and the quarterbacks coming in the league, in a lot of ways college football's not developing quarterbacks.
6:34
Everything now is in the shotgun.
6:36
Every, a, a majority of the guys are getting the plays from the sideline so that, so they, the, the coordinator's looking at the defense.
6:43
He's calling the play to get them in the best position.
6:45
So there's that, that component to it.
6:47
So many guys are relying on running quarterbacks and instead of developing, developing them as passers, they just say, "Okay, we're gonna run quarterback-driven runs," or, "We're gonna run, run, you know, RPOs." That, that works to some degree in the NFL, but it- it's not what works over time.

6 MINS LATER

13:02
Do you think it works?
40:20
What do you think about Justin Herbert and, uh, and the Chargers this season?
40:24
I, I love Jim Harbaugh's comments on, on Justin Herbert, and, and being with Jim Harbaugh for a few years in San Francisco, that, that's sincere.
40:32
The, the belief that he has in him and, and the things that he says about him, that, that's not theatrics.
40:38
He, he really feels that way, and I, I...
40:40
That, that's valuable because when he does coach and critique and push Justin Herbert, Justin Herbert's gonna know that the, it's coming from an absolute place of sincerity and, and wanting to see, see him be the best he can be.
40:54
And then with McDaniels, Tua was struggling from a confidence standpoint when he got there, and he did great things with, with Tua.
41:01
So I think combine, combining those two coaches in terms of pushing his progress forward is really positive.
41:45
And now it sounds like I'm making excuses for the guy.
5:00
What do you think about Justin Herbert and, uh, and the Chargers this season?
5:05
I, I love Jim Harbaugh's comments on, on Justin Herbert.
5:09
And, and being with Jim Harbaugh for a few years in San Francisco, that, that's sincere.
5:13
The, the belief that he has in him and, and the things that he says about him, that- that's not theatrics.
5:19
He, he really feels that way, and I, I...
5:21
That, that's valuable because when he does coach and critique and push Justin Herbert, Justin Herbert's gonna know that the, it's coming from an absolute place of sincerity and, and wanting to m- see, see him be the best he can be.
5:35
And then with McDaniels, Tua was struggling from a confidence standpoint when he got there, and he did great things wi- with Tua.
6:21
Down their both top two tackles, like he really hasn't had a superstar wide receiver, and now it sounds like I'm making excuses for the guy.
33:00
Um, I don't know, what do you think about Justin Herbert and, uh, and the Chargers this season?
33:06
I, I love Jim Harbaugh's comments on, on Justin Herbert.
33:10
And, and being with Jim Harbaugh for a few years in San Francisco, that, that's sincere.
33:14
The, the belief that he has in him and, and the things that he says about him, that- that's not theatrics.
33:20
He, he really feels that way, and I, I...
33:22
That, that's valuable because when he does coach and critique and push Justin Herbert, Justin Herbert's gonna know that the, it's coming from an absolute place of sincerity and, and wanting to him see, see him be the best he can be.
33:36
And then with McDaniels, Tua was struggling from a confidence standpoint when he got there, and he did great things wi- with Tua.
34:27
And now it sounds like I'm making excuses for the guy.
116:59
With Dak and CeeDee
117:00
Yeah, the way that they pay their stars.
117:01
So to have another to be top-heavy again on defense, at some point you just run out of resources.
117:07
So if you're gonna have the dynamic offense and the explosive offense, you're gonna have to make adjustments other places and it'll, that was the philosophy is we, we're gonna go try to get a volume of guys.
117:18
We, we don't have one hole, we have multiple holes.
117:21
They were close to historically bad last season.
117:24
Was it 35 points a game the last five games? And that's problematic, so now you, you try to, you try to collectively improve that defense as opposed to, say, we've got one star and a bunch of other guys that, you know, we're, we're hoping can, can rise up.
118:11
Our primes playing great football, finding guys like Dexter Lawrence and Bryan Cook really solidify that defense so the young guys can also kind of rise up." You got this Bengals retool defense priming them to get over the hump?
7:47
What did you make of those moves?
7:50
Well, I, I really believe that, that what the Kansas City Chiefs did was, was extremely smart.
7:56
And when, when we drafted Darrelle Revis, we actually had a deal in place with Carolina the night before that said, "If our guy is on the, the board when you pick, we'll make this trade." And, and we agreed to the terms the night before because we realized that the next guy behind Darrelle was such a, such a huge difference in talent level.
8:15
So he w- he was our guy.
8:17
And it feels like that's how Kansas City was looking at it is this was their guy.
8:22
If he's on the, if he's on the board, we're gonna make a move because the next available guy is gonna be, is gonna be dramatically different.
8:29
And, and that secondary need in Kansas City was real.
11:47
Where would you go if you were the Raiders?
37:30
That, that to me is really noteworthy.
37:33
I can't wait to read the 10,000 word article about, you know, when he gets cut because this, this doesn't work.
37:40
This doesn't work.
37:41
I've not...
37:41
Maybe he won't get cut, but I can't imagine that you're gonna ha- sign a guy to a new contract if the only way you can motivate him is, is not through direct conversation with the, the coaching staff or the GM or the owner or his, his, the players that he plays with.
37:57
You have to motivate him through an article on ESPN or, or a tweets or a podcast.
38:02
I mean, that, that, I can't imagine the organization will move forward with him after this, this year if this is really the case.

1 HR 25 MINS LATER

122:52
And, and Chad in, in-
27:21
But from your perspective, what is, like, if you're geeking out on this, what's the most interesting parts or part of the Super Bowl coming up?
27:29
Yeah, look, I love New England defense, and that's really been the story since.
27:36
Through the playoffs, and listen, their offense had to face three really, really challenging defenses to get to the Super Bowl.
27:45
But when you look at what they've done defensively, it's very similar to what we did the first time we won the Super Bowl, where we were coming off a down year.
27:52
We brought in a bunch of players from all different teams, and Mike Brable was part of that group.
28:00
who we brought in, who was going to be a special teams player.
28:03
That was going to be his core identity.
32:48
What was Eric Mangini's reaction to that?
9:45
Yeah
9:46
... and not had that level of success.
9:48
Now, look, I've had my challenges with Bill.
9:50
A lot of people have.
9:51
He's not Mr.
9:52
Personality.
9:53
The stuff that at Carolina I don't think has helped him.

8 MINS LATER

17:51
Yeah.
10:15
Yeah
10:15
... and not had that level of success.
10:17
Now, look, I've had my challenges with Bill.
10:19
A lot of people have.
10:20
He's not Mr.
10:21
Personality.
10:22
The stuff that, at Carolina, I don't think has helped him.

8 MINS LATER

18:20
Yeah.
35:39
Yeah
35:39
... and not had that level of success.
35:41
Now, look, I've had my challenges with Bill.
35:44
A lot of people have.
35:45
He's not Mr.
35:45
Personality.
35:47
The stuff that, at Carolina, I don't think has helped him.

8 MINS LATER

43:44
Yeah.
36:12
Yeah
36:12
... and not had that level of success.
36:14
Now, look, I've had my challenges with Bill.
36:17
A lot of people have.
36:18
He's not Mr.
36:18
Personality.
36:20
The stuff that, at Carolina, I don't think has helped him.

8 MINS LATER

44:17
Yeah.
9:47
Thoughts on Daboll landing with Josh Allen?
9:51
Brian is the ultimate Buffalo guy.
9:53
He grew up in Buffalo.
9:54
He could...
9:54
He could literally work for the Buffalo Tourism Bureau because he loves Buffalo so much.
9:59
So from that perspective, yeah, i- it's a great fit.
10:02
He's got a gr- he's got, uh, a really good relationship with the most important player on the team and a lot of respect from him, and, and in my mind, did a significant amount to help develop him from a, a fairly raw talent in college to a, a, a much more polished talent.
9:46
Thoughts on Daboll landing with Josh Allen?
9:50
Brian is the ultimate Buffalo guy.
9:51
He grew up in Buffalo.
9:52
He could...
9:53
He could literally work for the Buffalo Tourism Bureau because he loves Buffalo so much.
9:58
So from that perspective, yeah, i- it's a great fit.
10:01
He's got a gr- he's got, uh, a really good relationship with the most important player on the team and a lot of respect from him, and in my mind, did a significant amount to help develop him from a, a fairly raw talent in college to a, a, a much more polished talent.

5 MINS LATER

15:45
Matthew-
2:38
Find your local station for The Herd at foxsportsradio.com, or stream us live every day on the iHeartRadio app by searching Fox Sports Radio or FSR.
2:47
[record scratching] Now let's get this party started.

7 MINS LATER

10:17
Thoughts on Daboll landing with Josh Allen.
10:21
Brian is the ultimate Buffalo guy.
10:23
He grew up in Buffalo.
10:24
He could, he could literally work for the Buffalo Tourism Bureau because he loves Buffalo so much.
10:29
So from that perspective, yeah, it, it's a great fit.
10:32
He's got a g- he's got, uh, a really good relationship with the most important player on the team and a lot of respect from...
2:42
Were you surprised when McDermott, in front of Brandon Beane and the owners, suggested recently, "I don't think we have a Super Bowl roster, I think we have some deficiencies"? Were you surprised that he would confront those guys?
2:56
No, I, y- you'd like to think that, that the, uh, GM and the owner wanna hear what you feel is the truth.
3:04
A- and when you have honest conversations, sometimes they're difficult conversations.
3:09
And, and y- you, you may disagree with, with my assessment, but I would think that's what you would want from your head coach, is what he feels is the truth about your situation.
3:21
Otherwise, how do you, how do you ever get better? If you're, if you're constantly glossing over deficiencies because you're worried about hurting people's feelings, then you have no chance to, chance to grow.
3:31
So, so go ahead.
3:33
Go hire someone that's a yes man.

17 MINS LATER

20:16
Yeah.
4:09
Were you surprised when McDermott, in front of Brandon Beane and the owners, suggested recently, "I don't think we have a Super Bowl roster; I think we have some deficiencies"? Were you surprised that he would confront those guys?
4:22
No, I...
4:23
Y- you'd like to think that, that the, uh, GM and the owner wanna hear what you feel is the truth.
4:31
And, and when you have honest conversations, sometimes they're difficult conversations, and, and y- you, you may disagree with, with my assessment, but I would think that's what you would want from your head coach, is what he feels is the truth about your situation.
4:48
Otherwise, how do you, how do you ever get better? If you're, if you're constantly glossing over deficiencies because you're worried about hurting people's feelings, then you have no chance to, chance to grow.
4:58
So, so go ahead.
4:59
Go hire someone that's a yes-man.

17 MINS LATER

21:32
Yeah.
3:54
You know, Peyton Manning in year two or three, you know, was throwing a lot of picks, and I, I kind of feel like with Drake May, it's been established he's really good, and he should probably win home playoff games, or is that unrealistic in your opinion?
4:10
Yeah, I, I don't think it's unrealistic.
4:11
It, it, it's strange with quarterbacks because you have the Jayden Daniels experience and, and then you have the C. J. Stroud experience where they pop in year one and fall off, and then you have other guys like Drake May and to some degree Caleb, where in year two, after they go through that learning curve...
4:28
C- it's, it's really hard to be successful as a rookie quarterback in the NFL.
4:33
There, there's all the, the, the volume of stuff that you have to learn, the volume of defenses that you face, the new environment, getting used to the longer season.
4:42
It, it's layers upon layers whi- which, which makes it challenging.
4:46
But in year two, once they get over that, that learning curve, especially if you're in the same system, you should take a significant jump if, if you're, you know, if you're of the talent level that they expected.

15 MINS LATER

19:32
Yeah.

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.