Skip to main content
Charles Calomiris

Charles Calomiris

Financial expert and author

Jul 30, 2026

3:11
So he didn't answer the question, why didn't you move? What do you make of this?
3:19
Well, I've been one of the people saying for the past several years that you can't be taken seriously having a 2% long-term target if you allow years and years to go by where you're substantially above your target.
3:33
And of course, that's where we are.
3:35
The complication, of course, is that you've had a lot of supply-side shocks, tariffs, the war, the rise in oil price, but also on the other side, AI and productivity growth.
3:48
And macroeconomists think the Fed, ideally what it should do is respond to shifts in aggregate demand and kind of ignore supply shocks.
4:00
And in fact, in the 1970s and the 80s, macroeconomics invented this difference between a change in the price level and a change in inflation, right? The Fed shouldn't react to a supply shock change in the price level, but they should react to a persistent change in inflation, which is driven by demand side things.
4:21
So the tricky thing is being able to disentangle those.

6 MINS LATER

10:32
I'm interested in what you guys thought.
14:55
I'm just curious, how have the political coalitions changed over time? Give us the whole history of how the politics of banking have changed since the founding of the US 250 years ago.
15:11
Well, I think the right starting point is to, once you realize that when big shocks from the macro economy occur, there's going to have to be some allocation of loss.
15:23
Okay, so somebody is going to experience some loss.
15:27
That could be When you're looking at the banking sector, because banks are making loans and some of those loans aren't going to work out now, that is, they're going to have loan losses, that means the stockholders and the banks are going to be the sort of first line of defense and they're going to be the first ones experiencing loss.
15:47
And that continues to happen today as well.
15:51
The difference is, it used to be that because that was true, bankers had a lot of incentive to manage their risks.
16:03
By the way, most bank closures that happened, let's say, during the Great Depression were actually voluntary liquidations.

28 MINS LATER

44:22
I'm curious, what do you think about the whole suite of financial regulatory reforms that came in after Dodd-Frank and after the gold financial crisis in the U.S.?
6:50
Charles, in short summary, what has the Fed done well and what has it done not so well?
6:57
Unfortunately, as the great late economist and Fed historian Alan Meltzer pointed out, you can only really say that over its now 100 plus years of existence, Fed's really only been successful at its job about a third of the time.
7:12
So that's not a very good record, right? But what we could say is in the 1920s, the Fed discovered at the capacity of smoothing the business cycle and did so pretty effectively.
7:25
We could also say that from about 1991 till about 2001, the Fed seemed to also get it right and do quite well.
7:33
Unfortunately, most of the rest of the time, either the Fed made dramatic errors or the Fed was removed from power.
7:43
One thing people don't even know generally is that from 1934, until 1951.
7:49
The US Treasury ran monetary policy and just basically took the power away from the Fed.
9:55
Is there any way to move these kinds of decisions into a more objective form, looking at statistics in some way or economic results as opposed to the opinions of assorted board members about what should be done?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.