Skip to main content
Bryan Caplan

Bryan Caplan

American economist and author

Oct 8, 2026

0:00
What do people misunderstand about what eugenics is and means?
0:05
Good question.
0:06
So I would say eugenics in the broadest sense is any attempt to harness the knowledge that we have about heredity to influence the traits of our kids.
0:15
And in that sense, eugenics is as old as people, and actually much older.
0:19
Um, you know, any mammal that uses sexual selection, um, ends up in such a situation where females choose males on the basis of traits that will partly influence their own welfare, but will also influence the welfare of their kids.
0:35
And so in a way, eugenics is as old as you can think, uh, uh, as old as humanity.
0:41
But the, the term dates back to 1883 and, uh, Francis Galton, who coined the term, and I would say the reason that that term was invented and the concepts of eugenics in a really explicit way made a comeback, is that we had a few things happening in the 1800s.
5:50
But that is so off the table that it ends up being this pretzel-shaped loop-de-loop in a desperate attempt to kind of zero out or square the circle of this conversation.
26:24
Is there some extent to which a rational, eccentric view of the world and actions goes too far or has a detriment? Or is there some value to what these morons have built?
26:38
Yeah, like I definitely wouldn't consider the people that have actually built anything important to be morons.
26:43
They might be uncreative, but that's a very different point.
26:47
A person can be fantastically productive without being creative if they are just a master of a known craft.
26:55
The way that I would start is just like Econ 1, Day 1, Division of Labor.
27:01
No one, no matter how awesome, would be of any use by themselves, really.
27:05
You could put the greatest genius polymath craftsmen on an island by themselves and they would struggle to survive.

15 MINS LATER

41:44
What are some things in your career as an adult that you've changed your mind about?
26:27
Like, is that really going to work with the standard Rothbardian treatment of the, like, do you think we are ignoring really important stuff? Like, I don't know what, moral hazard or economies of scale or whatever? Yeah,
26:41
I mean, the only thing that we're really ignoring is just the transition cost and how do you get to a world where people expect the system to work.
26:50
It's one thing to say that once people are used to it, it will be fine.
26:53
And I think that's totally true.
26:55
And Rothbard does a good job of showing that.
26:57
It's another one to say, well, how do you move from one world to the other? I mean, it really is like saying, look, we can imagine a world where we all do phonetic spelling for English.
27:06
And it's like, yeah, it's not even hard.

16 MINS LATER

42:48
So how do you feel on that issue? If you're familiar with that accusation, I'm wondering if you are sympathetic to it.
Gene EpsteinMODERATOR
15:45
Take it away, Brian.
15:49
Uh, while I've done many debates on immigration, this is the first time you can figure out the correct side without knowing anything about immigration.
15:57
The resolution states, quote, "Immigration and Customs Enforcement should complete its mandate to deport all illegal aliens currently residing in the United States." And all means all, which is a crazy view about the enforcement of even the best law imaginable.
16:17
If we were debating, quote, "The NYPD should complete its mandate to imprison all murderers currently residing in New York City," every person here should still vote nay.
16:27
How can I say such a thing? This is the basic economics of crime.
16:31
Solving and prosecuting all murders would be astronomically expensive.
16:36
Some murders virtually solve themselves.

14 MINS LATER

Gene EpsteinMODERATOR
30:29
Brian
13:07
What are some of the arguments that people offer in favor of the human capital model? And what do you see some of the most compelling evidence against this argument?
13:17
The most popular argument is also the worst.
13:20
And it's just, well, what other explanation is there? That's why I just told you the other explanation.
13:26
But in terms of some of the better arguments, I mean, one is just like, well, it just doesn't make sense that you would have to spend so many years to get the stamps.
13:38
It doesn't make sense.
13:38
Like, why does it take so long to get certified? Why can't you just do an IQ test in three hours and then you can move on with your lives? Why is it that employers don't just hire people who are accepted to Harvard right out of high school and train them directly rather than having them go and do four more years and then come and work for them? So those are some of the better stories.
13:59
And for that first one, what I say is, look, if all that education were signaling were intelligence, that would make perfect sense.

25 MINS LATER

39:24
commit yourself to STEM and like,

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.