Skip to main content
Brian Hofer

Brian Hofer

Sep 30, 2026

Natalia Navarro
Natalia NavarroCORRESPONDENT
6:03
First, what is your take on this new legislation?
6:06
As a privacy person, whenever I see a shorter retention period proposed, I'm going to appreciate that.
6:14
It's better than where they were before.
6:18
I don't think 30 days anymore is a reasonable cutoff, when even Flock is at seven days.
6:26
The shorter, the better.
6:27
The state of New Hampshire has had a three-minute retention period for 10 years by state law, so I think there's more room for improvement, but it is better than where they were before.
6:37
We do support the criminal penalty proposal.
Natalia Navarro
Natalia NavarroCORRESPONDENT
9:54
What would the next step look like for you?
5:51
What's wrong with trying to gather as much information to help crime enforcement? Yeah.
5:56
Well, that's a very broad question right there.
6:00
Secure justice is not anti-technology.
6:03
We do oppose the practice of mass surveillance.
6:05
And the way license plate readers are used today is to indiscriminately collect data on everybody, even when you're not suspected of any wrongdoing.
6:14
I do want to push back a little bit, too, on the earlier answers.
6:17
Flock cameras capture far more than just a license plate number and vehicle characteristics.
8:04
It's not the reason why you support this organization, but tell us what happened to you.
29:37
Tell me what concerns you have about that and examples of where you and your organization think they might have been misused.
29:44
Sure.
29:45
And I want to just first push back a little bit on the legality.
29:49
We're not wrong.
29:50
We're just early.
29:52
Mr. Chandler actually mentioned a couple of issues.
29:54
GPS trackers, cell phone searches, cell phone location data, drug sniffing dogs, drone surveillance.

8 MINS LATER

38:04
I mean, I wanted to ask you, Brian, I mean, is your issue with flock particularly or with the way in which police are using this data or both?
6:05
maintenance.So Brian, if I'm going through my neighborhood and I'm wondering if there's an acoustic gunshot detector, like, what would I see? What would be the clues that there was a gunshot detector thing set up? What would it look like?
6:17
The more dominant company right now has fairly recognizable sensors.
6:22
They're usually white, plastic housing units that have the microphones inside of them, and they're usually placed high enough up on a utility pole or a building, skyscraper office building, for example, with the goal of not being triggered, the sensors, by regular street noise conversations lower level.
6:42
They are supposed to only really capture loud static noises like a gunshot, of course, an automobile backfire, loud construction noises.
6:53
There's a number of examples where we've seen where it's actually captured other audio, and actually, we have recordings of human conversations too.
7:01
So under the right circumstances, it's not widespread, but under the right circumstances, it is capable of capturing human voices.

21 MINS LATER

28:11
Brian, any final comment from you?
28:13
Yeah, just I think as the New York City auditor that didn't just look at the false positive rate, but actually measured the salary of those officers spent on false positive rates, and supplementing what Jonathan said, that this hundred thousand dollars or even a couple million to a large city isn't that much, but New York had wasted, like, forty to fifty million dollars on false positives.
Rachel Myrow
Rachel MyrowCORRESPONDENT
2:18
Is it fair to say, Brian, a lot of people have woken up to the issues involved?
2:24
I would say it's fair to say that everywhere but the Bay Area.
2:28
I am stunned and very frustrated that we're probably some of the most educated people in the world.
2:36
We build this technology.
2:38
We certainly understand the risks that come with it.
2:41
Everywhere else in the country, they're waking up to these ridiculous number of scandals.
2:46
I've never seen in my 12 years A surveillance technology vendor have this many scandals in such a short window.
Rachel Myrow
Rachel MyrowCORRESPONDENT
3:09
What do you say, Brian, to those who say, hey, most jurisdictions just don't have enough law enforcement officers and this technology is a force multiplier?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.