Skip to main content

Ben Buchanan

Psychologist

Nov 21, 2026

46:22
That seems like a lot to ask, and I wouldn't be surprised if we get, like... lashing out from them as opposed to you know things actually going that way if we indeed like you know put pedal to the metal on exactly that plan for the foreseeable future but it seems like you think i shouldn't be worried or yeah tell me let's
46:40
people i mean we we of course worried about how our actions would be perceived and we tried to scope the actions in such a way that would not yield this kind of backlash and indeed there was not much retaliation from the chinese for the biden administration actions on chip controls because they were very carefully calibrated there's far more retaliation for things like the tariffs from Trump, far more lashing out than from anything we did.
47:02
And you'll certainly not see us advocating for overthrowing the CCP or things like that.
47:07
I personally don't think the CCP is a moral actor, but we understand the principles of sovereignty here.
47:14
I do think that history here can provide a guide to us, and I don't think the history suggests regime change.
47:22
I think the history suggests that when you have a nation with a lot of power, the long-term smart strategy for that nation is to build institutions that seed some of that power from the nation to the institutions and provide a stabilizing force to the broader ecosystem.
47:38
And oftentimes, though not always, those institutions relate to the management, the shared management of a new technology.

21 MINS LATER

68:45
What are our best ideas right now for how to govern that situation or get them to somehow govern each other, mutually police one another? What, what, what, if anything, are you bullish on the, in terms of actually slowing down for real in the short term.
17:53
What is Wang's policy towards China when it comes to selling to them around this period?
17:57
He said the same thing in private that he said in public, which is we put this policy in place in 2022.
18:03
We said to him, essentially, the supply of chips in the world is fixed because it's so hard to make them.
18:07
There's not going to be that many more coming off the line.
18:13
And we want those ships to not go to China because we're worried they're going to modernize their military.
18:18
They're going to repress their population with these surveillance tools and the like.
18:22
Instead, we want those ships to go to the rest of the world, but especially companies in democratic nations.

7 MINS LATER

25:47
So with the caveat that Megaspeed has declined all allegations of wrongdoing, can you explain a little bit about how this alleged chip smuggling works in practice?
38:19
Talk to me about Byron's question.
38:21
Yeah, I mean, I would say that we were urgent and we certainly felt like this was one of the biggest national security issues facing the United States, not necessarily to have a breakneck policy cutting corners on safety to make this technology as quickly as possible, but certainly to ensure there is American preeminence in making it.
38:40
And we felt like it was entirely compatible to say we both need to regulate our companies, which I do not think should be trusted to invent this technology on their own.
38:50
while also making sure there's a role for government and making sure that the national security of the United States is assured here.
38:56
We felt like they were entirely compatible missions.
39:00
And I think we tried to do everything we could to raise the urgency of this.
39:03
President Biden brought this up at the UN.

8 MINS LATER

47:07
Are any experts or politicians offering ideas on how to manage or restrain this consolidation of power and information? Ben, do you want to take a crack at that one? Because it's actually slightly distinct, I think, from most of the concerns that you've talked about at least so far today.
20:14
Why
20:14
would it not be complimentary? So, yeah, I think that's the first question, the Taiwan piece.
20:19
And I think the answer there is like actually there's much more going on.
20:21
And the second question is, would there be some retaliation from China economically? It's worth noting in the Biden administration, for all the controls we did, there was not much.
20:30
And in part because we were messaging to the Chinese, we are not trying to launch an economic broadside against your economy.
20:36
We've actually scoped these controls very carefully, too carefully, if you ask me, creating some loopholes that NVIDIA worked around.
20:42
But the only thing China really did in response was some noise about cybersecurity investigations and then controlled two critical minerals that were not particularly hard to have alternative supply chains for.

11 MINS LATER

31:32
How should these Democrats coming into Congress look to regulate AI? What are the relevant issues? Where can they actually make progress?
13:28
First of all, do you have an ability, do you have a sense of whether or not that this is being hyped
13:35
or this is accurate? I think this is accurate.
13:37
And certainly when I say this is accurate, the capacity for AI systems to help generate or help create more powerful successors, I think it's already demonstrated.
13:48
If you look at the writing of the code for the AI systems, Three or four years ago, essentially all the code at AI companies was written by humans.
13:56
Right now, essentially none of it is.
13:57
Maybe 10% of it is.
13:59
So the code itself is being written by AI.

10 MINS LATER

23:40
that the United States and other democracies need to exercise in order to best ensure
23:06
What is Megaspeed? And how long has this company been on the government radar?
23:13
We put, my co-author Teddy Collins and I put Megaspeed it exemplified for us so well the issues that we were confronting in 2024, which are not necessarily about Megaspeed in particular at the time, at least I didn't know the company's name then, but were about a series of very shady companies in places like Singapore and Malaysia that that were getting access to chips that were potentially being trans-chipped on to China or building pretty sketchy data centers that the Chinese could access remotely.
23:46
And our view was that this was the obvious way in which China, by 2024, was trying to circumvent the export control policies on Chinese companies in 2022 and 2023.
23:56
And here, the procedural history that's interesting is that Megaspeed began as a Chinese company, at least as the reporting indicates, and then became a Singaporean company.
24:02
So it just seemed to us as we were writing this book, the perfect example again, distillation of this kind of risk.
24:09
And the policy that we put in place to guard against this risk, again, this notion called diffusion rule, to limit the chips going to non-trusted actors around the world.
24:20
President Trump declined to enforce that policy when he came into office, which made this case, I think, much more likely and much more damaging.

17 MINS LATER

41:48
Ben, as an administration alum, as someone who advises for Anthropic, why am I wrong?
13:03
I want to start with the upside gains, as you understand them, of accelerated
13:11
AI development.
13:12
What could we gain? The upside here that resonates the most with me and resonated the most with President Biden is in biology and in medicine.
13:19
And we've already started to see some progress, significant progress, for AI in transforming medicine.
13:24
The 2024 Nobel Prize was awarded to Demis Hassabis, an AI scientist who used AI to solve one of the fundamental problems in biology called the protein folding problem, which is at the core of drug discovery.
13:34
So that's the upside.
13:35
And when President Biden asked me this exact question about the upside, He cares about ending cancer more than anything in the world for very good reason.
17:49
So you can't
12:43
Tell my audience what changed, what you did in the Biden administration as a top AI advisor with many others and the president, obviously, and what changed.
12:50
We came to the White House in 2021 with the conviction that AI would matter enormously for national security and that computing power is what would propel AI forward, so that computer chips would matter.
13:00
We knew that the United States and its democratic allies and partners had a significant advantage, almost a hundred to one advantage, in producing advanced AI chips.
13:09
What that meant is the United States could essentially pull this drawbridge up, deny China the access to this technology, and therefore deny China the access to the military, to the AI systems that they want to use in their military and their intelligence activities and their domestic repression.
13:22
We put that policy into place in 2022, 2023, The Chinese began to try to work around that policy, smuggling chips through third countries, building data centers overseas, accessing them remotely.
13:33
And we put an additional policy in place called the diffusion rule to cut off those routes.
13:37
President Trump reversed key aspects of this policy, said he would not enforce the diffusion rule.
13:43
During the Biden administration, as a result of these rules, did any of the companies in this space suffer economically?
9:31
Walk us through the difficulty in not only setting the controls themselves, but making sure that they are enforced in these kind of third-party situations.
9:39
It starts with the administration.
9:40
So the administration, the Trump administration, made a decision to not enforce something called the diffusion rule, which was built specifically for this purpose, to guard against companies in third countries, to guard against transshipment, to also guard against remote access to data centers overseas.
9:54
This was how China began working around the export controls that were put in place on Chinese companies in 2022 and 2023.
10:01
The Trump administration said they would not enforce that.
10:03
That, I think, enabled some of this activity to continue.
10:06
And certainly there's bipartisan concern in the Congress about this technology going to China.
13:30
How hard would it be for any other chip maker, Chinese or not, to try to fill the shoes of NVIDIA if this does lead to somewhat of a material change in the company's dominance in this area?
30:35
What are the important lessons that you've been seeing so far? And I guess what do you hope gets answered in the weeks and months to come, specifically around the administration's stance on regulating this supply, this smuggling?
30:51
This case shows how important AI chips are.
30:54
The products that NVIDIA makes are fundamental to the global economy and to America's national security.
30:59
Our posture in the Biden administration was that these chips were too powerful to be sold to China, or they could be diverted to the Chinese military.
31:07
The Trump administration has, in key respects, walked back a lot of the export control policy.
31:11
And I think this moment is one we're hearing bipartisan calls to say, no, America must be more aggressive once more in denying China access to this powerful technology.
31:42
Why don't you buy the idea that Jensen pushed that we should have China's AI built on American technology, that that is in our national security interest? I mean, there are plenty of experts who agree with that.
31:58
I think there's two things here.
SophiaHOST
13:15
So what would you how would you score them on a report card? What have they done well in the second term and what have they done poorly?
13:23
I think they came in with a very different philosophy.
13:26
And David Sachs, of course, was my successor.
13:28
And David Sachs' stayed philosophy on AI was let the private sector cook.
13:32
JD Vance, in his first big speech on AI, said, I don't want to hear about AI opportunity.
13:36
I'm here to talk about AI safe.
13:37
Sorry, I don't want to hear about AI safety, rather.

5 MINS LATER

SophiaHOST
18:52
So what policy proposals would you give to President Trump to regulate AI without substantially damaging the economy?
20:20
And just like flesh out the full race, give like the full best argument for why we need to be in a race with China for AI.
20:28
You won't usually hear me use the word race, but you certainly will hear me use the word competition.
20:33
And the theory of the case that we had since we got there in 2021 was that it would be important for the United States on behalf of democracies and at some level on behalf of humanity to have a leading role in shaping AI development.
20:46
And that we felt it was the democratic system that would be best positioned to manage this technology.
20:53
What that meant, what that conviction meant, is that we wanted the lead to be substantial over China, often by slowing China down rather than accelerating ourselves unduly, which I think is a really important distinction here, to build a very big lead such that we could, to use our phrase from 2021, spend the lead on safety.
21:10
So 2021, there were no real dangers of these systems, and we knew that.
21:13
But we wanted to use that period, essentially the Biden term, to build the lead such that when we got to 2026 and 2027 and these systems... as we thought, became more capable and also more dangerous, there wouldn't be a geopolitical arms race with China.

21 MINS LATER

41:59
Can we get stereoscopic vision that lets us integrate both of these threats at the same time?
54:22
You know, what are some of the moments that stand out to you where President Biden as an individual made himself felt in the AI policy interagency process, you know, being the final decider with an opinion, etc.? ?
54:33
Well, I did not brief President Biden until I became the White House Special Advisor for AI in 2023.
54:38
So I don't know exactly like how he and Jake divided things up.
54:41
So I would defer to Jake's.
54:43
I'm sure Jake's going to have a great book and I would defer to Jake's book on that.
54:45
I am sure that Jake talked to the president about chip controls and the like.
54:49
He obviously agreed with them, but I couldn't parse the meaning for you.

24 MINS LATER

79:11
What was the debate like then? And then what would you advise the Trump administration to do now, vis-a-vis data centers and energy infrastructure?
24:48
What are, what are the things they're struggling with? Like, what are the, the issues young men in particular have about thinning out and going bald?
24:56
Yeah, well, I think it's a, um, it's one of the, the first and obvious signs of aging, and I think for, um, young men in particular, if it happens early, it can be a real hit to self-esteem, and especially, um, if people ha- have, um, a, a preoccupation or a, or have their self-esteem really based on their appearance.
25:19
Really, healthy self-esteem should be based on a diversity of things, our values, our skills, our achievements.
25:26
But, um, if people are really basing their self-esteem on just their appearance, that's when I start to see problems.
27:56
Do you-
27:57
Yeah, Damo was a, a great example of, of where you, you simply accept it, and you talk about it with your mates as well.
28:04
You know, one thing that I sometimes see is that people suffering in silence and hiding something away, and I think especially when it comes to toupees, um, shame often, um, lives in secret.
28:16
And so I think it's really great that we're talking about it now.
18:24
Yeah
18:24
...
18:24
it, it has not become-- I mean, it's, it's, it's getting there, but it, but it was not at the time I was in the government, particularly polarized.
18:31
And we had very good conversations, um, with Republicans.
18:35
The, the president, the day after he signed his executive order, hosted a bipartisan group of senators in the Oval Office.
18:41
It was a great conversation.
18:43
It, it was actually like a little bit of a, a lesson for me in that conversations are not always that good.

11 MINS LATER

29:39
Yeah
13:20
A- as you understand the race or the contest or however exactly you would characterize it, w- what exactly are we talking about? What does it mean to win? You know, what are we talking about when we talk about AI competition, to put it, uh, put it in one day?
13:31
Yeah.
13:31
I think I prefer competition to race because race implies there's a single finish line, and I don't think that's the case in AI.
13:38
But I think this is a competition that has multiple facets.
13:41
The first an- and in my view, really essential part of the competition is the competition to develop high-end AI capabilities.
13:50
And sometimes this is called the competition for the frontier.
13:53
And that is vital because those are the systems that propel the technology forward.

29 MINS LATER

43:14
Can you just explain for those of us who are not experts on this why compute to you is the center of this and what the components of that are?
25:19
Like, do you have any advice, Dr. Ben, if someone is thinking of limb lengthening surgery, uh, what should they be thinking about?
25:28
Yeah.
25:29
So I think this goes for, for any cosmetic surgery.
25:32
Um, and, and I think that, um, the, the first things are to consider whether you've got an overvalued idea, that you think that your whole world will, uh, change and that your life will be, you know, 10X improved if you get a surgery.
25:47
If you're thinking thoughts like that, that's probably a sign that you're overvaluing the, the surgery and it's actually a false hope, and that the, the issue might actually reside in your relationship with yourself, um, and how you value yourself.
26:04
And so if that's happening for you, I suppose there are, there's lots of recommendations.
26:08
I, I think one key thing is to, um, consider the content you're consuming online.
27:26
Dr. Ben, I wanted to ask, do you think social media trends talking about the perfect height of men in particular could be doing a lot of damage? Do you think people need to ease up a bit on the short king jokes?
18:52
But just in terms of the capacities it gives our own government, how do you think about that?
18:57
Yeah, I, I would decompose essentially this question about AI and autocracy or the surveillance state, however you wanna define it, into t-two parts.
19:03
The first is the China piece of this.
19:05
How does this play out in a state that is truly in its bones an autocracy and, and doesn't even make any pretense towards democracy and the like? And I think we can probably agree pretty quickly here, this makes very tangible something that, y-you know, is probably core to the aspirations of their society of, like, a level of control that only an AI system could help, uh, bring about that I just find terrifying.
19:29
As an aside, I think there's a saying in both Russian and Chinese, something like, "Heaven is high and the Emperor is far away," which is, like, historically, even in those autocracies, there was some kind of space where the, the state couldn't intrude because of the scale and the, the breadth of the, the nation.
19:44
And it is the case that in those autocracies, I think AI would... could make the force of government power worse.
19:50
Then there's a more interesting question.

22 MINS LATER

41:35
What do you make of that?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.