Skip to main content
Ash Sarkar

Ash Sarkar

Journalist

Sep 24, 2026

31:44
Ash, you wanted to come in.
31:45
I, I'm sorry.
31:46
I, I feel like I'm going completely nuts because there are mobs of men styling themselves as paramilitaries, and both of you have had more to say about refugees and asylum seekers than you have had racism, which I just think is completely obscene.
32:00
Wherever you stand- [audience applauds] Wherever you stand on the issue of immigration, there's a variety of opinions.
32:09
They're all legitimate.
32:10
We all want to see rule of law.
32:13
We all want to see people protesting within the law.

18 MINS LATER

50:26
[laughs]
Rudyard GriffithsMODERATOR
9:33
Six minutes on the clock is yours.
9:36
Let me see, by a show of hands, who here has seen the cost of their housing go up in the last 18 months? They have it.
9:44
Liberalism has failed.
9:48
I can imagine how I might be caricatured during this debate, but I imagine there are a lot of people here who describe themselves as liberals who believe many of the same things that I do.
9:58
You believe, like me, in freedom of conscience.
10:01
You believe, like me, in due process.
10:04
And maybe you believe in slaying the giants of racism, homophobia, ableism, and sexism.

1 HR 9 MINS LATER

79:05
We want to lead a full life.
28:59
Okay.
28:59
So, um, my colleague Aaron Bastani wrote a book called Fully Automated Luxury Communism, and what he basically was looking at is the way in which the price of information falls to zero.
29:09
And so the expectation of being able to access things for free really, really changes, and maybe that's a technological change which can usher in, um, a sort of end of, of privatized ownership.
29:21
Um, that's one way of doing it.
29:22
Um, you know, my, my former colleague Craig, who used to be our long-suffering head of operations, he's now an academic.
29:29
Um, you know, he would describe himself as an anarcho-communist, so he's very interested in syndicalist and, you know, workerist forms of organization.
29:38
For me, I consider myself, um, a philosophical communist.

7 MINS LATER

36:36
How significant is this for the BBC to be, um, to be challenged in this way?
3:29
[laughs]
3:29
These are apples and oranges.
3:32
Um, party candidates are different from pundits, and I, you know, I actually believe that, like, there is a real place for this, like, you know, we're not getting into this guilt by association thing anymore, particularly with punditry, right? Like, that's the new political norm.
3:47
It has been tried to reframe, bridge, and, you know, move on to, like, the issue you really want to talk about.
3:57
It ha- That's been tried, like, a zillion, million times in the UK regarding the antisemitism stuff, and I think that there is a place for it.
4:03
I'm not saying give that up.
4:05
What I'm saying is that if you want to be able to steer a party with a membership of hundreds of thousands of people through it, what you have to do is, one, be like, okay, we are creating an internal culture of discipline and strategy.
6:21
Party?I don't think I have.
2:19
And the response?
2:21
The response, everyone lost their minds.
2:25
And just to say up top, you know, I think it's fine if you object to that language or you find it vulgar or you say, you know, we should be kinder to each other.
2:32
That's fine.
2:32
But people started making out that it was some kind of race issue or a gender issue.
2:38
So you had this group of young people of color who were saying, you know, we've been made to feel unsafe as POC.
2:44
You had this person stand up in tears saying Roger Hallam's brought violence into this space.

11 MINS LATER

13:31
The politics of the right is identity politics.
18:17
the response?
18:18
The response, everyone lost their minds.
18:22
And just to say up top, you know, I think it's fine if you object to that language or you find it vulgar or you say, you know, we should be kinder to each other.
18:29
That's fine.
18:29
But people started making out that it was some kind of race issue or a gender issue.
18:35
So you had this group of young people of color who were saying, you know, we've been made to feel unsafe as POC.
18:41
You had this person stand up in tears saying Roger Hallam's brought violence into this space.

11 MINS LATER

29:28
The politics of the right is identity politics.
8:53
And if we don't pose that question, then we are doing a disservice to the real details of this story, right?
9:00
So on this question of who do politicians work for, like is it the people, is it capital? I think the best way to understand politicians as a class is to think of them as being intermediaries between democracy and capital.
9:14
And their job is to effectively manage democracy so it doesn't become too difficult for capital.
9:19
Because, you know, in a way, politicians aren't that different from dogs, right? They respond to reward and punishment.
9:25
And they've worked out that capital can punish them more effectively than people ever can.
9:32
And so that's, you know, there are lots of reasons for that.
9:34
Discuss this in the book.

11 MINS LATER

Keir StarmerSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
20:29
And it is a straight fight between Labour and Ripple.
8:18
What do you think we should be learning from that? And what do you think we need to have in terms of eyes on the future?
8:23
So many things.
8:24
And I've got, you know, I've got things to say.
8:27
I've got a list here.
8:28
I've got things for the Green Party and also things for, you know, this new, you know, Jeremy Corbyn's Arasultana party.
8:34
But here's the thing for the Greens specifically.
8:37
One is that I think people are really... unprepared, including myself, for what the scale of the assault was going to be like.

22 MINS LATER

30:57
And I did give an answer, but I'm just curious, like how important are those marches or are they not doing a huge amount?
0:58
Ash, do you think the government's achieved what it wanted to achieve by proscribing the group, or have they misstepped here?
1:06
Well, it's very difficult for me to get my head around what it was that the government wanted to achieve.
1:11
I think what happened was is that they were under a lot of pressure, including from weapons manufacturing lobbyists, including from the Israeli Embassy, to crack down on Palestine Action, whose direct action against the Israeli weapons firm Elbit has been relatively successful, it definitely raised the costs of Elbit, uh, operating in the UK.
1:33
And it was after the action at RAF Brize Norton that I think the government felt that they had a window to do something which maybe they'd been wanting to do for a long time.
1:42
Because previously, the kinds of legislation that would apply to a group like Palestine Action, it would be things like trespass, criminal damage, things of that nature.
1:51
And the defenses which are allowed in court for that include human rights defenses, arguing that you've committed an act of criminal damage to prevent a further harm.
2:01
That was actually an argument that one Mr. Keir Starmer mobilized when he was defending some, uh, protestors who undertook a very, a very similar kind of action, I believe in the early 2000s.
6:43
(laughs) Terrible.
28:19
That does not exist in the world of social media increasingly and that's why you get these con men like Andrew Tate essentially on the phones of every child in the world.
28:31
On the feminism has gone too far thing.
28:33
I mean, obviously, I completely disagree with that.
28:35
But it made me think about a dinner I had with my mom and my grandma when she was still with us.
28:43
It was three generations of women.
28:44
And when my grandma first got married and had kids, abortion was illegal in this country.
28:50
There was no such thing as no fault divorce.

9 MINS LATER

37:22
You would say that, wouldn't you? Have you found any solutions?
49:34
What, how did you first come to public prominence?
49:37
You know what? I never actually wanted to be a journalist.
49:40
My life plan in my head after I finished my master's was that at some point I'd go back, do a PhD, um, and write things that nobody read.
49:48
But while I was kicking my heels and working in a pub, um, I started working with a media organization that my friend set up, uh, Aaron Bassani set up Novara Media, and it was because there were certain stories which I thought really needed to be told.
50:02
So reluctantly and kind of by accident, I became really interested in journalism and journalistic writing.
50:09
And after I'd been doing that for a little bit, along comes Jeremy Corbyn, and something which would have seemed impossible, that you would have, you know, a very left-wing socialist leader of the Labor Party, it's, it's a political reality.
50:21
Um, so that was a big part of how Novara Media grew.

24 MINS LATER

HassanAUDIENCE
74:34
My question is, if Starmer continues on his current policy trajectory, will he be enabling a Farage prime ministership? And what changes to leadership does the Labor Party need to make to avoid such a unpleasant event from occurring?
13:51
... why do you think that is harmful for the left? What damage do you think it's done?
13:55
Well, first it puts everyone into this position of competing over who can be the victim, and it's so corrosive to solidarity because instead of looking at people as potential allies, you look at the, looking at them through the lens of, well, what are you gonna do to me? So stops you from being able to work together.
14:13
The second thing is that I think it is a separatist logic.
14:18
So it says, well, unless you are Bengali, Muslim, female, whatever, you're not gonna be able to understand my experience, and in fact, you're probably out to do me harm.
14:27
Whereas the left has historically succeeded when it has organized beyond those identity categories.
14:32
It doesn't mean getting rid of them or saying that it's not important, but being able to build bigger coalitions.
14:38
An example I give in the book is the Rainbow Coalition organized by Fred Hampton, who was a young Black Panther.

26 MINS LATER

40:19
The media is less powerful than it was.
10:46
Six minutes on the clock is yours.
10:49
Let me see, by a show of hands, who here has seen the cost of their housing go up in the last 18 months? They have it.
10:57
Liberalism has failed.
11:00
I can imagine how I might be caricatured during this debate, but I imagine there are a lot of people here who describe themselves as liberals who believe many of the same things that I do.
11:10
You believe, like me, in freedom of conscience.
11:14
You believe, like me, in due process.
11:17
And maybe you believe in slaying the giants of racism, homophobia, ableism, and sexism.

1 HR 9 MINS LATER

80:22
We want to lead a full life.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.